Appendix A to Part 242  


Latest version.
  • A penalty may be assessed against an individual only for a willful violation. The Administrator reserves the right to assess a penalty of up to $100,000 for any violation where circumstances warrant. See 49 CFR part 209, Appendix A.

    Section Violation Willful violation Subpart B - Program and Eligibility Requirements: 242.101 - Program failures: (a) Failure to have program$10,000$20,000 (a)(1)-(6) Program that fails to address a subject2,5005,000 242.103 - Program approval: (a)-(b) Failure to follow Appendix B1,0002,000 (c) Failure to comply with filing requirements1,0002,000 (h) to resubmit, when directed by FRA1,0002,000 242.105 - Schedule for implementation: (a)-(b) Failure to designate conductors2,0004,000 (c) Allowing uncertified person to serve as conductor7,50015,000 (d)-(e) Certifying without complying with subpart B or failure to issue a certificate2,5005,000 (f) Serving as a conductor without complying with subpart B or being issued a certificate7,50015,000 242.107 - Types of service: (a) Failure to designate types of service2,0004,000 (c) Reclassifying a certificate2,5005,000 242.109 - Certification and recertification determinations: (a) Failure to determine in writing the requirements of (a)(1), (a)(2), (a)(3), and/or (a)(4)2,5005,000 (b) Considering excluded data2,0004,000 (c) Failure to have required documents on file1,0002,000 (d), (e) Failure to provide timely review opportunity2,0004,000 242.111 - Motor vehicle operator records: (a) Failure to implement program meeting requirements6,000(b) Failure to determine eligibility requirements met5,0007,500 (c) Failure to initially certify2,0004,000 (d) Failure to recertify2,0004,000 (e) Allowing person to serve as conductor before information is evaluated7,50015,000 (f) Failure to certify or certify during pendency of waiver request2,0004,000 (g) Failure to take action to make information available1,0002,000 (h), (i), (j) Failure to request record1,0002,000 (k) Failure to notify of absence of license1,0002,000 (l) Failure to report in timely manner or railroad taking certification action for not reporting earlier than 48 hours1,0002,000 (m), (n) Considering excluded data2,0004,000 (o) Failure to:(1) Consider data6,00010,000 (3), (4) Properly act in response to data2,5005,000 242.113 - Prior safety conduct: (a) Failure to implement program meeting requirements6,000(b) Failure to determine eligibility requirements met5,0007,500 (c) Failure to request record or take required action2,0002,000 242.115 - Substance abuse/rules: (a) Failure to implement program meeting requirements6,000(b) Failure to determine eligibility requirements met5,0007,500 (c) Failure to have basis for taking action2,5005,000 (d)-(g) Failure to comply with requirements2,5005,000 242.117 - Vision and hearing acuity: (a) Failure to implement program meeting requirements6,000(b) Failure to determine eligibility requirements met5,0007,500 (c) Failure to have basis for finding proper acuity1,0002,000 (d) Acuity examination performed by unauthorized person1,0002,000 (e) Failure to note need for device to achieve acuity1,0002,000 (f) Failure to use device needed for proper acuity1,0002,000 (h)-(j) Failure to comply with requirements2,5005,000 (k) Failure of conductor to notify2,5005,000 242.119 - Training: (a) Failure to implement program meeting requirements6,000(b) Failure to determine eligibility requirements met5,0007,500 (c) Failure to determine in writing the requirements of (c)(1), (c)(2), and/or (c)(3)2,5005,000 (d) Failure to: (1) Make determination, include proper curriculum, and/or document knowledge and ability2,5005,000 (2) Failure to include component1,0002,000 (3) Failure to make information available1,0002,000 (4) Failure to maintain steps or tasks in one manual or make available1,0002,000 (5) Failure to review and modify training plan1,0002,000 (e) Failure to require person to meet requirements2,5005,000 (f) Failure to provide opportunity to consult1,0002,000 (g)-(k) Failure to have adequate procedures or include procedures in program2,5005,000 (l) Failure to have adequate procedures for or provide continuing education2,5005,000 242.121 - Knowledge testing: (a) Failure to implement program meeting requirements6,000(b) Failure to determine eligibility requirements met5,0007,500 (c) Failure to have adequate procedures for testing knowledge2,5005,000 (d) Failure to properly document testing2,5005,000 (e) Failure to provide opportunity to consult2,5005,000 (f) Failure to document whether test was passed or failed2,5005,000 (g) Allowing person to serve as a conductor despite test failure2,5005,000 242.123 - Monitoring operational performance: (a)-(b) Failure to implement program meeting requirements6,000(c) Failure to test each conductor annually2,5005,000 (d) Failure to test properly2,5005,000 (e) Failure to indicate the action to be take2,5005,000 (f) Failure to test within time limits2,5005,000 242.125 - Reliance on determination of another: (a) Failure to address in program or require newly hired conductor to take entire training program5,0007,500 (b) Failure to make any required determinations2,5005,000 242.127 - Relying on requirements of a country: (a)-(b) Failure to determine person employed and meets Canadian standards2,5005,000 Subpart C - Administration of the Certification Program: 242.201 - Time limitations: (a), (c), and (d) Exceeding time limit2,0004,000 242.203 - Supporting information: (a), (c)-(e) Failure to have a record2,5005,000 (b) Failure to have a complete record2,0004,000 (f) Falsification of a record(−)10,000 (g) Failure to comply with requirements if records maintained electronically2,0004,000 242.205 - Identification of persons: (a)-(b) Failure to have a record2,5005,000 (c) Failure to update or make a record available2,0004,000 (d) Falsification of a record(−)10,000 (e) Failure to comply with requirements if records maintained electronically2,0004,000 242.207 - Certificate components: (a) Improper certificate1,0002,000 (b) Failure to designate those with signing authority1,0002,000 (d) Falsification of a certificate(−)10,000 242.209 - Maintenance of the certificate: (a) Failure of conductor to carry certificate or display certificate when requested1,0002,000 (b) Failure of conductor to notify railroad of limitations or railroad requiring conductor to exceed limitations4,0008,000 242.211 - Replacement of certificates: (a) Failure to have a reasonably accessible system for certificate replacement2,0004,000 (b) Failure to comply with requirements for temporary replacement certificates1,0002,000 242.213 - Multiple certifications: (d) Allowing an engineer to operate without a conductor where the engineer is not certified as a conductor or not accompanied by a certified conductor7,50015,000 (e) Failure to comply with emergency restrictions2,5005,000 (f) Failure of conductor to notify railroad of denial or revocation4,0008,000 (g) Performing conductor service with a revoked conductor certificate7,50015,000 (h), (k) Performing work as an engineer or obtaining an engineer certificate with a conductor certification revoked for a violation of 242.403(e)(1)-(e)(5) or (e)(12)7,50015,000 (i), (j) Performing work as a conductor or obtaining a conductor certificate with an engineer certification revoked under 240.3077,50015,000 (l) Denying or revoking engineer certification or recertification based solely on the denial of conductor certification4,0008,000 (m) Denying or revoking conductor certification or recertification based solely on the denial of engineer certification4,0008,000 242.215 - Oversight responsibility: (a) Failure to perform annual review and analysis or perform on time2,0004,000 (b)-(i) Incomplete or inaccurate report2,5005,000 Subpart D - Territorial Qualification and Joint Operations 242.301 - Territorial qualification: (a) Allowing uncertified person or person not territorially qualified to serve as a conductor7,50015,000 (b) Failure to notify railroad of lack of qualifications4,0008,000 (c) Failure to provide required assistance4,0008,000 (d) Failure to provide assistance or up-to-date job aid4,0008,000 Subpart E - Denial and Revocation of Certification 242.401 - Denial of certification: (a) Failure to notify or provide opportunity for comment2,0004,000 (c) Failure to notify, provide data, or untimely notification2,0004,000 242.403 - Revocation criteria: (a) Failure to implement program meeting requirements6,000(b) Unlawful failure to comply with rules and practices2,5005,000 (c) Failure to revoke certification2,5005,000 (d) Considering excluded data2,5005,000 (e) Considering unlisted violations of operating rules and practices2,5005,000 (f) Improperly counting or considering violations2,5005,000 242.405 - Periods of ineligibility: (a)-(c) Imposition of incorrect period of ineligibility2,5005,000 242.407 - Revocation of certification: (a) Failure to revoke certification7,50015,000 (b) Failure to suspend, notify, provide hearing opportunity, or improper procedures2,5005,000 (c)-(h) Failure of railroad to comply with hearing or waiver procedures2,5005,000 (j) Failure of railroad to make record1,0002,000 (k) Failure of railroad to conduct reasonable inquiry or make good faith determination5,00010,000 [76 FR 69841, Nov. 9, 2011, as amended at 77 FR 24423, Apr. 24, 2012; 81 FR 43113, July 1, 2016; 83 FR 60750, Nov. 27, 2018[Reserved]