§ 3.29 - Hearings and reviews.  


Latest version.
  • (a) A debtor who receives a Notice of Intent to Collect by Administrative Offset may request a hearing or documentary review of the agency's determination that the debt exists and the propriety of administrative offset. Any debtor who wishes to do this must submit a written explanation of why the debtor disagrees and seeks review. The request must be received by the creditor agency within 20 calendar days of the date the notice was delivered to the debtor.

    (b) In response, the creditor agency must notify the debtor in writing whether the review will be by documentary review or by hearing. If the debtor requests a hearing, and the creditor agency decides to conduct a documentary review, the agency must notify the debtor of the reason why a hearing will not be granted. The agency must also advise the debtor of the procedures to be used in reviewing the documentary record, or of the date, location and procedures to be used if review is by a hearing.

    (c) Unless otherwise arranged by mutual agreement between the debtor and the agency, evidenced in writing, any documentary review or hearing will be conducted not less than 10 calendar days and no more than 45 calendar days after receipt of the request for review.

    (d) Unless otherwise arranged by mutual agreement between the debtor and the agency, evidenced in writing, a documentary review or hearing will be based on agency records plus other relevant documentary evidence which may be submitted by the debtor within 10 calendar days after the request for review is received.

    (e)(1) Hearings will be as informal as possible, and will be conducted by a reviewing officer in a fair and expeditious manner. The reviewing officer need not use the formal rules of evidence with regard to the admissibility of evidence or the use of evidence once admitted. However, clearly irrelevant material should not be admitted, whether or not any party objects. Any party to the hearing may offer exhibits, such as copies of financial records, telephone memoranda, or agreements, provided the opposing party is notified at least 5 days before the hearing.

    (2) Debtors may represent themselves or may be represented at their own expense by an attorney or other person.

    (3) The substance of all significant matters discussed at the hearing must be recorded. No official record or transcript of the hearing need be created, but if a debtor requested that a transcript be made, it will be at the debtor's expense.

    (f)(1) Within no more than 30 calendar days after the hearing or the documentary review, the reviewing officer will issue a written decision to the debtor and the agency, including the supporting rationale for the decision. The deadline for issuance of the decision may be extended by the reviewing officer for good cause for no more than 30 calendar days, and beyond the 30 calendar days extension only with the consent of the debtor. The decision need not be lengthy or formal in style, but must address the substantive issues. The decision should address any significant procedural matter which was in dispute before or during the hearing or documentary review.

    (2) The reviewing officer's decision constitutes final agency action as to the following issues:

    (i) All issues of fact relating to the basis of the debt (including the existence of the debt and the propriety of administrative offset), in cases where the debtor previously had not been afforded due process; and

    (ii) The existence of the debt and the propriety of administrative offset, in cases where the debtor previously had been afforded due process as to issues of fact relating to the basis of the debt.

    (g) The reviewing officer will promptly distribute copies of the decision to the Assistant Secretary for Administration, USDA and to the debtor and the debtor's representative.