98-26909. Pesticide Reregistration Performance Measures and Goals  

  • [Federal Register Volume 63, Number 194 (Wednesday, October 7, 1998)]
    [Notices]
    [Pages 53895-53902]
    From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
    [FR Doc No: 98-26909]
    
    
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
    
    [OPP-34128; FRL-6016-5]
    
    
    Pesticide Reregistration Performance Measures and Goals
    
    AGENCY: Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
    
    ACTION: Notice.
    
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    SUMMARY: This notice announces EPA's progress in meeting its 
    performance measures and goals for pesticide reregistration during 
    1997. Publication of this notice meets the requirements of the Federal 
    Insecticide, Fungicide, and
    
    [[Page 53896]]
    
    Rodenticide Act (FIFRA) section 4(l), as established by the Food 
    Quality Protection Act of 1996 (FQPA). EPA is completing the task of 
    reregistering all pesticides initially registered prior to November 
    1984, as mandated by the 1988 amendments to FIFRA (FIFRA 88). 
    Reregistration has become integrated with the reassessment of 
    tolerances required under the FQPA. The new law provides a continuation 
    of fees to support reregistration, and contains a number of 
    requirements to ensure that these fees are used properly by the Agency, 
    including annual publication of this account of program performance 
    measures and goals for reregistration, tolerance reassessment, and 
    expedited registration.
    
    ADDRESSES: Written comments may be submitted by mail to: Public 
    Information and Records Integrity Branch, Information Resources and 
    Services Division (7502C), Office of Pesticide Programs, Environmental 
    Protection Agency, 401 M St., SW., Washington DC 20460. In person, 
    bring comments to: Rm. 119, CM2, 1921 Jefferson Davis Highway, 
    Arlington, VA.
        Comments must be identified by docket control number (OPP-34128). 
    Information submitted and any comments concerning this notice may be 
    claimed confidential by marking any part or all of that information as 
    ``Confidential Business Information'' (CBI). Information so marked will 
    not be disclosed except in accordance with procedures set forth in 40 
    CFR part 2. A copy of the comment(s) that does not contain CBI must be 
    submitted for inclusion in the public record.
        Comments may be submitted electronically by following the 
    instructions under Unit III below. No CBI should be submitted through 
    e-mail.
    
    FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: By mail: Wanda Daughtry, Special 
    Review and Reregistration Division (7508W), Office of Pesticide 
    Programs, Environmental Protection Agency, 401 M St., SW., Washington, 
    DC 20460. Office location, telephone number, and e-mail address: Rm. 
    3W63, Crystal Station 1, 2800 Crystal Drive, Arlington, VA 22202. 
    Telephone: (703) 308-8171; e-mail: daughtry.wanda@epa.gov.
    
    SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
    
    I. Background
    
        EPA must establish and publish annually in the Federal Register its 
    performance measures and goals for pesticide reregistration, tolerance 
    reassessment, and expedited registration, under section 4(l) of FIFRA 
    as amended by FQPA. Specifically, such measures and goals are to 
    include:
        The status of reregistration;
        The number of products reregistered, canceled, or amended;
        The number and type of data requests or Data Call-In 
    notices (DCIs) under section 3(c)(2)(B) issued to support product 
    reregistration by active ingredient;
        Progress in reducing the number of unreviewed, required 
    reregistration studies;
        The aggregate status of tolerances reassessed; and
        The number of applications for registration submitted under 
    subsection (k)(3), expedited processing and review of similar 
    applications, that were approved or disapproved; plus
        The future schedule for reregistrations; and
        The projected year of completion of the reregistrations 
    under section 4.
        FIFRA as amended in 1988 authorizes EPA to conduct a comprehensive 
    pesticide reregistration program--a complete review of the human health 
    and environmental effects of older pesticides originally registered 
    prior to November 1, 1984. Those pesticides that meet today's 
    scientific and regulatory standards may be declared ``eligible'' for 
    reregistration. In order to be so designated, an older pesticide must 
    have a substantially complete data base, and must be found not to cause 
    unreasonable risks to human health or the environment when used in 
    accordance with Agency approved label directions and precautions.
        In addition, all pesticides with food uses must meet the new 
    standard of the Food Quality Protection Act. Under FQPA, EPA must make 
    a determination that pesticide residues remaining in or on food are 
    ``safe''; that is, ``that there is reasonable certainty that no harm 
    will result from aggregate exposure to the pesticide chemical residue'' 
    from dietary and other sources. In determining allowable levels of 
    pesticide residues in food, EPA must perform a more comprehensive 
    assessment of each pesticide's risks, considering:
        Aggregate exposure (from food, drinking water, and residential 
    uses).
        Cumulative effects from all pesticides sharing a common mechanism 
    of toxicity.
        Possible increased susceptibility of infants and children.
        Possible endocrine or estrogenic effects.
        FQPA requires the reassessment of all existing tolerances 
    (pesticide residue limits in food) and tolerance exemptions within 10 
    years, to ensure that they meet the safety standard of the new law. 
    Pesticides posing the greatest potential risks are to be reevaluated 
    first. Specifically, EPA must reassess 33% of the almost 10,000 
    existing tolerances and exemptions within 3 years (by August 1999), 66% 
    within 6 years (by August 2002), and 100% in 10 years (by August 2006).
        EPA will meet FQPA's tolerance reassessment requirements primarily 
    through the reregistration program. Schedules have been coordinated, 
    integrated, and revised so that in the course of making reregistration 
    eligibility decisions, EPA also will complete much of tolerance 
    reassessment within the time frames mandated by the new law.
        When the accelerated reregistration program instituted by FIFRA 88 
    is completed in approximately the year 2002, registration review as 
    mandated by the FQPA will be underway. Under this new program, EPA is 
    to review every pesticide registration on a suggested 15 year cycle. 
    The tolerance reassessment program after 2002 will be accomplished 
    through the registration review program as will the periodic updating 
    of all pesticide registrations.
    
    II. FQPA and Program Accountability
    
        One of the hallmarks of FQPA is enhanced accountability. EPA has 
    incurred several additional obligations under the new law, including 
    the requirement to publish annually this summary of the program's 
    performance measures and goals for reregistration, tolerance 
    reassessment, and expedited registration. The following sections 
    describe EPA's progress in the areas specifically identified by FIFRA 
    section 4(l).
    
    A. Status of Reregistration
    
        Through the reregistration program, EPA is reviewing current 
    scientific data for older pesticides and effecting changes to improve 
    their safety. Pesticides that have sufficient supporting human health 
    and environmental effects data and do not pose unreasonable risks may 
    be declared ``eligible'' for reregistration. EPA presents this finding 
    in a Reregistration Eligibility Decision (RED) document. So far, the 
    Agency has completed 171 REDs out of a universe of 612 cases, or groups 
    of related pesticide active ingredients subject to reregistration. 
    (About 8 of the 171 are voluntary cancellations that were counted as 
    REDs because significant progress had been made in developing RED 
    documents at the time that the requests for cancellation were 
    received.) An additional 231 cases were voluntarily canceled before EPA 
    invested significant resources in
    
    [[Page 53897]]
    
    developing their REDs. A total of 402 cases (66%), therefore, have 
    completed the reregistration process, leaving 210 reregistration cases 
    (34%) to complete reregistration by the year 2002.
        The 171 completed REDs include 265 active ingredients and encompass 
    about 6,194 products. Seventy-one (71) of these REDs have food uses, 
    and about 1,572 tolerances are associated with these pesticides. (Note: 
    Tolerances for the 53 food use REDs that were completed before FQPA was 
    enacted must be revisited during the next several years to ensure that 
    they meet the safety standard of the new law, as factored into the 
    Agency's Tolerance Reassessment Schedule.)
        EPA has completed 30 REDs since the FQPA was enacted in August 
    1996, and 18 of these REDs have food uses. About 415 tolerances were 
    reassessed for these post-FQPA REDs.
        Reducing pesticide risks is an important aspect of the 
    reregistration program. In developing REDs, EPA works with pesticide 
    registrants to develop voluntary measures or regulatory controls needed 
    to effectively reduce risks of concern. Every RED includes some risk 
    reduction measures. The options for reducing risks are extensive, and 
    include voluntary cancellation of pesticide products or uses, declaring 
    certain uses ineligible or not yet eligible (and then proceeding with 
    follow-up action to cancel the uses or require additional supporting 
    data), restricting use of products to certified applicators, limiting 
    the amount or frequency of use, improving use directions and 
    precautions, adding protective clothing and equipment requirements, 
    requiring special packaging or engineering controls, employing ground 
    water, surface water, or other environmental and ecological safeguards, 
    and others.
        EPA's goal is to complete about 40 REDs each fiscal year, and to 
    reassess tolerances for 33% of the tolerances existing as of August 3, 
    1996 by August 1999, with priority given to the food use pesticides 
    that appear to pose the greatest risk.
    
    B. Product Reregistration; Numbers of Products Reregistered, Canceled, 
    and Amended
    
        At the conclusion of the reregistration process, after a pesticide 
    has been declared eligible for reregistration and when product specific 
    data and revised labeling have been received, reviewed, and accepted by 
    EPA, pesticide products may be reregistered. For products with multiple 
    active ingredients, amendments are issued as each active ingredient is 
    reregistered--the product is reregistered when all of its active 
    ingredients are eligible for reregistration, thus completing the 
    process. Alternatively, pesticide producers, or registrants, may 
    voluntarily cancel their end use product registrations. In other 
    situations, registrations may be suspended temporarily by the Agency if 
    registrants have not submitted required product specific studies within 
    the timeframes specified, or have not paid registration maintenance 
    fees.
        At the end of fiscal year 1997, the status of the 5,622 pesticide 
    products associated with completed reregistration eligibility decisions 
    (or REDs) was as follows:
    
    
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Products reregistered..................  931
    Products amended.......................  56
    Products canceled......................  1683
    Products suspended.....................  146
    Products pending action................  1658
    Products not due for action............  1148
    TOTAL..................................  5,622 products associated with
                                              completed REDs
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    
        In the list above, ``products pending action'' are awaiting 
    decisions by EPA. ``Products not due for action'' are not yet ready for 
    product reregistration decisions; they are associated with REDs that 
    are completed but not yet mailed to registrants for their responses, or 
    they have product specific data that are not yet due to be submitted to 
    EPA.
        During fiscal year 1997, EPA completed 387 product reregistration 
    actions, although the target was to complete only 300 actions. The 
    Agency's goal is to complete 900 to 1,200 product reregistration 
    actions during fiscal year 1998. Several significant process 
    improvements are being implemented which should enable the Agency to 
    meet this goal, including:
        Establishment of a technical review section within the lead 
    division to provide expedited.
        in-house review of product specific data called in by EPA.
        Establishment of an in-house label review team.
        Development of an improved, tailored tracking system.
        Development and use of a clearer, more understandable Data Call-In 
    package for registrants of end use products going through 
    reregistration.
        With these improvements in place, EPA expects to eliminate the 
    backlog of pending product reregistration decisions within the next few 
    years.
    
    C. Number and Type of DCIs Issued to Support Product Reregistration by 
    Active Ingredient
    
        The number and type of data requests or Data Call-In notices (DCIs) 
    issued by EPA under FIFRA section 3(c)(2)(B) to support product 
    reregistration for pesticide active ingredients included in fiscal year 
    1997 REDs are shown in the following Table 1.
    
    
                                        Table 1. -- Data Call Ins Issued to Support Product Reregistration for FY-97 REDs
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                                                           Number of Product       Number of Acute
                  Case No.                      Case Name          Number of Products      Chemistry Studies      Toxicology Studies     Number of Efficacy
                                                                     Covered in RED           Required\1\              Required           Studies Required
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    2415...............................  Methylene bis-          59....................  19...................  48...................  0
                                          thiocyanate (MBT).
    3147...............................  Vancide...............  2.....................  19...................  12...................  0
    2725...............................  Troysan...............  59....................  19...................  288..................  0
    0144...............................  Diflubenzuron.........  32....................  18...................  18...................  0
    0187...............................  Pendimethalin.........  58....................  17...................  102..................  0
    0181...............................  Metribuzin............  71....................  17...................  72...................  0
    0076...............................  Sulprofos\2\..........  0.....................  0....................  0....................  0
    
    [[Page 53898]]
    
    0263...............................  Dichlobenil...........  32....................  17...................  30...................  0
    2555...............................  Propoxur..............  147...................  17...................  450..................  0
    2755...............................  Brodifacoum...........  38....................  13...................  18...................  1
    2760...............................  Bromadiolone..........  27....................  13...................  12...................  1
    2765...............................  Bromethalin...........  18....................  14...................  108..................  1
    2075...............................  Butralin..............  2.....................  17...................  12...................  0
    2100...............................  Chlorophacinone.......  60....................  18...................  30...................  2
    2205...............................  Diphacinone...........  105...................  16...................  30...................  2
    2210...............................  Diphenylamine.........  3.....................  19...................  18...................  0
    2810...............................  Pival\3\..............  2.....................  0....................  0....................  0
    2465...............................  PNP\2\................  1.....................  0....................  0....................  0
    0039...............................  Terbacil..............  12....................  19...................  6....................  0
    2665...............................  Thiobencarb...........  23....................  17...................  18...................  0
    2710...............................  Triclopyr.............  37....................  19...................  108..................  0
    0026...............................  Zinc Phosphide........  59....................  13...................  30...................  2
    0247...............................  BT....................  186...................  1....................  930..................  1
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    \1\In an effort to reduce the time, resources, and number of animals needed to fulfill acute toxicity data requirements, EPA ``batches'' products which
      can be considered similar from an acute toxicity standpoint. For example, one batch could contain five products. In this instance, if 6 acute
      toxicology studies were required, only 6 studies would be needed rather than 30 studies. Factors considered in the sorting process include each
      product's active and inert ingredients (identity, percent composition, and biological activity), type of formulation (e.g., emulsifiable concentrate,
      aerosol, wettable powder, granular, etc.), and labeling (e.g., signal word, use classification, precautionary labeling, etc.). The Agency does not
      describe batched products as ``substantially similar'' since all products within a batch may not be considered chemically similar or have identical
      use patterns.
    \2\Voluntary Cancellation
    \3\Not Eligible for Reregistration
    
    
    D. Progress in Reducing the Number of Unreviewed, Required 
    Reregistration Studies
    
        EPA is making good progress in reviewing scientific studies 
    submitted by registrants in support of pesticides undergoing 
    reregistration. Over 27,000 studies (27,159) have been received by the 
    Agency through the reregistration program. About 75% (20,283) of these 
    studies either have been reviewed (19,007 or 70%), or have been found 
    to be extraneous (1,276 or 5%). (Extraneous studies is a term used to 
    classify those studies that are no longer needed because the guideline 
    or data requirement has been satisfied by other studies or has 
    changed.) EPA still must review 25% (6,876) of all studies received to 
    complete the reregistration program.
        The proportion of studies received that have been reviewed by EPA 
    has increased during the past year. At the end of fiscal year 1996, 
    only 69% of all studies received in support of reregistration had been 
    reviewed, compared to 75% at the end of 1997. Thus, the reregistration 
    study review ``backlog'' has decreased; only 25% of all studies 
    received currently are awaiting review, compared with 31% a year ago.
        A more detailed account of the number and percent of studies 
    received, reviewed, and awaiting review by reregistration list appears 
    the following in Table 2.
    
    
                                           Table 2. -- Review Status of Studies Submitted for Pesticide Reregistration
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                                                                                                                    Total
                                                                                  Studies Reviewed + Extraneous                Studies Awaiting    Studies
                                                                                                                                    Review         Received
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    List A........................................................                               10,061 + 291 = 10,352 (80%)        2,656 (20%)       13,008
    List B........................................................                                 5,541 + 663 = 6,204 (67%)        2,999 (33%)        9,203
    List C........................................................                                 2,126 + 228 = 2,354 (73%)          873 (27%)        3,227
    List D........................................................                                  1,279 + 94 = 1,373 (80%)          348 (25%)        1,721
    Lists A through D.............................................                             19,007 + 1,276 = 20,283 (75%)        6,876 (25%)       27,159
    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    
    E. Aggregate Status of Tolerances Reassessed
    
        Tolerance reassessment has been part of the reregistration process 
    since the FIFRA 88 accelerated reregistration program began. EPA 
    reassessed over 1,500 tolerances in the course of making reregistration 
    decisions regarding the 171 pesticides for which REDs have been 
    completed.
        Enactment of the FQPA in August 1996 brought a new safety standard-
    -``reasonable certainty of no harm''--for pesticides used on food 
    commodities. All non-occupational sources of exposure including food, 
    drinking water, and residential use must now be considered in 
    establishing new tolerances. All existing tolerances must be reassessed 
    over a 10 year period to consider aggregate exposure from those 
    sources, as well as the cumulative effects of pesticides and other 
    compounds with common mechanisms of toxicity, estrogen/endocrine 
    effects, and the special sensitivities of infants and children. EPA 
    must reassess approximately 1/3 (one third) of the nearly 10,000 
    existing tolerances and tolerance exemptions every 3 years, giving 
    priority to pesticides posing the greatest potential risks, so that 
    tolerance
    
    [[Page 53899]]
    
    reassessment under FQPA will be completed by August 2006.
        To meet the first statutory deadline, EPA plans to reassess 33% of 
    the approximately 9,600 existing tolerances and tolerance exemptions, 
    or complete about 3,200 tolerance reassessment actions, by August 1999. 
    Since FQPA was enacted in August 1996, EPA has completed 30 REDs, 18 of 
    which have food uses, and in so doing has reassessed over 400 
    tolerances. Current Agency plans call for reassessing an additional 
    1,500 tolerances during 1998.
    
    F. Applications for Registration requiring Expedited Processing - 
    Numbers Approved and Disapproved
    
        During fiscal year 1997, EPA considered and approved the following 
    numbers of applications for registration requiring expedited processing 
    (``fast track'' applications):
         Me-too product registration/fast track: 589
        Amendments/fast track: 3,273
        TOTAL: 3,862 applications processed by expedited means
        Regarding numbers of applications disapproved, the Agency generally 
    notifies the registrant of any deficiencies in the application that 
    need to be corrected or addressed before the application can be 
    approved.
        On a financial accounting basis, EPA devoted approximately 26 FTEs 
    to reviewing and processing applications for me-too product 
    registrations and fast-track label amendments. The Agency spent $2 
    million in direct costs (not including administrative expenses, 
    computer systems, management overhead, and other indirect costs) during 
    fiscal year 1997 on expedited processing and reviews.
    
    G. Future Schedule for Reregistrations
    
        EPA's schedule for completing future reregistration eligibility 
    decisions has been reconstructed to embrace the FQPA requirement that 
    the Agency reassess all existing tolerances over a 10 year period to 
    ensure consistency with the law's new safety standard, considering the 
    pesticides that appear to pose the most risk first. EPA's 
    reregistration and tolerance reassessment goals are integrated, as 
    reflected in schedules that will enable the Agency to complete the 
    FIFRA reregistration program by 2002, and complete tolerance 
    reassessment by August 2006.
        EPA has prioritized pesticides for reregistration review and 
    tolerance reassessment based on their potential risks, as explained in 
    the tolerance reassessment schedule published in the Federal Register 
    on August 4, 1997 (62 FR 42020-42030) (FRL-5734-6) (Raw and Processed 
    Food Schedule for Pesticide Tolerance Reassessment). Three priority 
    groups have been created; pesticides in Group 1 generally appear to 
    pose the greatest risks so they will be examined first. Group 1 
    includes the organophosphate (OP), carbamate, and organochlorine 
    classes of pesticides, probable and possible human carcinogens, high-
    hazard inert ingredients, and any pesticides that exceed their 
    reference dose (the amount believed not to cause adverse effects if 
    consumed daily over a 70-year lifetime). Group I also includes 
    pesticides for which REDs were substantially complete prior to 
    enactment of FQPA, even though they are not among those that appear to 
    pose the greatest potential risks. Pesticides in Group 1 are the 
    Agency's highest priority for both tolerancereassessment and 
    reregistration.
        EPA's tentative schedule for reviewing clusters or waves of 
    priority Group 1 pesticides for both tolerance reassessment and 
    reregistration during the next several years appears in the following 
    Table 3. The waves are intended to give a general sense of which 
    chemicals will be looked at first, second, and third within the highest 
    priority Group. The final schedule could vary from this listing based 
    on a variety of scheduling factors including the scheduling of some 
    non-food pesticides for reregistration decisions as resources permit.
    
    
     Table 3.--  Priority Group 1 Pesticides Subject to Reregistration Review and Tolerance Reassessment under FQPA
                                                      (Waves 1-11)
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                           Chemical                                   Chemical Class or Toxicology Concern
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                         WAVE 1
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Ethion..............................................                                           organophosphate
      Fenamiphos..........................................                                           organophosphate
      Fenthion............................................                                           organophosphate
      Naled...............................................                                           organophosphate
      Phorate.............................................                                           organophosphate
      Profenophos.........................................                                           organophosphate
      Terbufos............................................                                           organophosphate
      Formetanate HCI.....................................                                                 carbamate
      Chlorothalonil......................................                                             B2 carcinogen
      Captan..............................................                                             B2 carcinogen
      Folpet..............................................                                             B2 carcinogen
      Telone..............................................                                             B2 carcinogen
      Vinclozolin.........................................                                             B2 carcinogen
      Dicofol.............................................                                            organochlorine
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                         WAVE 2
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Azinphos-methyl.....................................                                           organophosphate
      Chlorpyrifos........................................                                           organophosphate
      DEF.................................................                                           organophosphate
      Dimethoate..........................................                                           organophosphate
      Isofenphos..........................................                                           organophosphate
      ODM.................................................                                           organophosphate
    
    [[Page 53900]]
    
      Propetamphos........................................                                           organophosphate
      Iprodione...........................................                                             B2 carcinogen
      Bendiocarb..........................................                                                 carbamate
      Carbofuran..........................................                                                 carbamate
      Methomyl............................................                                                 carbamate
      Thiodicarb..........................................                                                 carbamate
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                         WAVE 3
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Bensulide...........................................                                           organophosphate
      DDVP................................................                                           organophosphate
      Disulfoton..........................................                                           organophosphate
      Malathion...........................................                                           organophosphate
      Phosmet.............................................                                           organophosphate
      Benomyl.............................................                                                 carbamate
      Alachlor............................................                                             B2 carcinogen
      Propachlor..........................................                                         chloroacetanilide
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                         WAVE 4
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Diazinon............................................                                           organophosphate
      Ethyl Parathionorganophosphate......................
      Methyl Parathion....................................                                           organophosphate
      Pirimiphos-methyl...................................                                           organophosphate
      Sulfotepp...........................................                                           organophosphate
      Temephos............................................                                           organophosphate
      Al and Mg Phosphide phosphide fumigants (inhalation
       hazard)............................................
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                         WAVE 5
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Acephate............................................                                           organophosphate
      Dicrotophos.........................................                                           organophosphate
      Ethoprop............................................                                           organophosphate
      Methamidophos.......................................                                           organophosphate
      Methidathion........................................                                           organophosphate
      Fonofos.............................................                                           organophosphate
    Non-RED Organophosphates1.............................
      Food-Use Organophosphates:..........................
        Cadusafos (post-84)...............................
        Coumaphos (pre-FQPA RED)..........................
        Chlorpyriphos-methyl (post-84)....................
        Fenitrothion (pre-FQPA RED).......................
        Mevinphos (pre-FQPA RED)..........................
        Monocrotophos.....................................
        Phostebupirim (post-84)...........................
        Chlorethoxyfos (post-84)..........................
        Tetrachlorvinphos (pre-FQPA RED)..................
        Trichlorfon (pre-FQPA RED)........................
      Non-Food Use Organophosphates:......................
        Isazophos-methyl (post-84)........................
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                         WAVE 6
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Phenmedipham........................................                                                 carbamate
      Asulam..............................................                                                 carbamate
      CIPC................................................                                                 carbamate
      Desmedipham.........................................                                                 carbamate
      Propamocarb hydrochloride (pre-FQPA RED)............                                                 carbamate
      Aldicarb............................................                                           oxime carbamate
      Oxamyl..............................................                                           oxime carbamate
    
    [[Page 53901]]
    
      Aldoxycarb (post-84)................................                                           oxime carbamate
      Molinate............................................                                             thiocarbamate
        ..................................................                                              C carcinogen
      Tri-allate..........................................                                             thiocarbamate
        ..................................................                                              C carcinogen
      EPTC................................................                                             thiocarbamate
      Pebulate............................................                                             thiocarbamate
      Vernolate...........................................                                             thiocarbamate
      Butylate............................................                                             thiocarbamate
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                         WAVE 7
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Lindane.............................................                                        organochlorine, B2
      Endosulfan..........................................                                            organochlorine
      Methoxychlor........................................                                            organochlorine
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                         WAVE 8
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      2-Phenylphenol......................................
      Ethylene oxide (ETO)................................
      Propylene oxide.....................................
      Mancozeb............................................                              alkylenebis(dithiocarbamate)
      Maneb...............................................                              alkylenebis(dithiocarbamate)
      Metiram.............................................                              alkylenebis(dithiocarbamate)
      Cacodylic Acid......................................                                          organo arsenical
      Propargite..........................................                                              organosulfur
      TPTH................................................                                                 organotin
      Oxythioquinox.......................................                                               quinoxaline
      Terrazole...........................................                                                  Thiazole
      PCNB................................................                           aromatic hydrocarbon derivative
      Formaldehyde........................................
      Paraformaldehyde....................................
      Sodium dimethyldithiocarbamate......................                                            diphenyl ether
      Thiram..............................................
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                         WAVE 9
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Carbaryl............................................                                                 carbamate
      Atrazine............................................                                            1,3,5-triazine
      Simazine............................................                                            1,3,5-triazine
      Propazine (section 18 use only).....................                                            1,3,5-triazine
      Cyanazine (to be canceled in 1999 & phased out by
       2002)..............................................                                            1,3,5-triazine
      Oxadiazon...........................................
      Imazalil............................................                                             benzimidazole
      Oxyfluorfen.........................................                                            diphenyl ether
      Permethrin..........................................                                                pyrethroid
      Thiabendazole.......................................                                             benzimidazole
      Thiophanate methyl..................................                                             benzimidazole
      Lactofen............................................                                            diphenyl ether
      Sodium salt of fomesafen............................                                            diphenyl ether
      Diclofop-methyl.....................................                       2-(4-aryloxyphenoxy) propionic acid
      Fenoxaprop-ethyl....................................                       2-(4-aryloxyphenoxy) propionic acid
      Quizalofop-ethyl....................................                       2-(4-aryloxyphenoxy) propionic acid
      Sodium salt of acifluorfen..........................                                   dimethyldithiocarbamate
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                         WAVE 10
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Cypermethrin........................................                                                pyrethroid
      Propiconazole.......................................                                                     azole
      Triadimefon.........................................                                                     azole
      Fenbuconazole.......................................                                                     azole
    
    [[Page 53902]]
    
      Myclobutanil........................................                                                     azole
      Tebuconazole........................................                                                     azole
      Triflumazole........................................                                                     azole
      Triadimenol.........................................                                                     azole
      Difenoconazole......................................                                                     azole
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                         WAVE 11
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Diphenamid..........................................
      Dipropyl isocinchomeronate..........................
      DNOC................................................
      TCMB................................................
      Tetradifon..........................................
      2,4-D...............................................                                      aryloxyalkanoic acid
      Cycloate............................................
      Chloramben..........................................
      Chloroxuron.........................................
      Diethatyl ethyl.....................................
      Hexythiazox.........................................
      Benfluralin.........................................                                        2,6-dinitroaniline
      Ethalfluralin.......................................                                        2,6-dinitroaniline
      Oryzalin............................................                                        2,6-dinitroaniline
      Pendimethalin.......................................                                        2,6-dinitroaniline
      Trifluralin.........................................                                        2,6-dinitroaniline
      Butralin............................................                                        2,6-dinitroaniline
      Dinocap.............................................                                  dinitrophenol derivative
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    \1\ These Organophosphates (OPs) are not in the reregistration queue--REDs were completed for them prior to
      FQPA, or they are not subject to reregistration (initially registered prior to November 1, 1984). However, for
      most, tolerances still must be reassessed under FQPA. The other OPs are scheduled for REDs in Waves 1 through
      5.
    
    
    H. Projected Year of Completion of Reregistrations
    
        EPA is committed to completing the pesticide reregistration program 
    by the year 2002.
    
    III. Electronic Submissions and Public Response
    
        This notice is not subject to a formal public comment period. 
    Nevertheless, EPA welcomes input from interested parties and the 
    general public. Public responses to this notice should be submitted to 
    the address in the ADDRESS section above, with an additional copy sent 
    to Wanda Daughtry, Special Review and Reregistration Division, at the 
    address and telephone number listed above in the section titled, ``FOR 
    FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT.''
        The official record for this notice, as well as the public version, 
    has been established under docket number OPP-34128 (including comments 
    and data submitted electronically as described below). A public version 
    of this record, including printed, paper versions of electronic 
    comments, which does not include any information claimed as CBI, is 
    available for inspection from 8:30 a.m. to 4 p.m. Monday through 
    Friday, excluding legal holidays. The official record is located at the 
    address in ``ADDRESS'' at the beginning of this document.
        Electronic comments can be sent directly to EPA at: opp-
    [email protected] Electronic responses must be submitted in ASCII file 
    format, avoiding the use of special characters and any form of 
    encryption. Comments will also be accepted on disks in WordPerfect 5.1/
    6.1 file format or ASCII file format. All comments in electronic form 
    must be identified by the docket control number OPP-34128. Electronic 
    responses to this schedule may be filed on line at many Federal 
    Depository libraries.
    
    List of Subjects
    
        Environmental protection.
    
        Dated: September 30, 1998.
    
    Lynn R. Goldman,
    
    Assistant Administrator, Office of Prevention, Pesticides, and Toxic 
    Substances.
    
    [FR Doc. 98-26909 Filed 10-6-98; 8:45 am]
    BILLING CODE 6560-50-F
    
    
    

Document Information

Published:
10/07/1998
Department:
Environmental Protection Agency
Entry Type:
Notice
Action:
Notice.
Document Number:
98-26909
Pages:
53895-53902 (8 pages)
Docket Numbers:
OPP-34128, FRL-6016-5
PDF File:
98-26909.pdf