99-28579. Diseases Not Associated With Exposure to Certain Herbicide Agents  

  • [Federal Register Volume 64, Number 211 (Tuesday, November 2, 1999)]
    [Notices]
    [Pages 59232-59243]
    From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
    [FR Doc No: 99-28579]
    
    
    =======================================================================
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS
    
    
    Diseases Not Associated With Exposure to Certain Herbicide Agents
    
    AGENCY: Department of Veterans Affairs.
    
    ACTION: Notice.
    
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    SUMMARY: As required by law, the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) 
    hereby gives notice that the Secretary of Veterans Affairs, under the 
    authority granted by the Agent Orange Act of 1991, has determined that 
    a presumption of service connection based on exposure to herbicides 
    used in the Republic of Vietnam during the Vietnam era is not warranted 
    for the following conditions: Hepatobiliary cancers, nasal/
    nasopharyngeal cancer, bone cancer, breast cancer, female reproductive 
    cancers, urinary bladder cancer, renal cancer, testicular cancer, 
    leukemia, abnormal sperm parameters and infertility, motor/coordination 
    dysfunction, chronic peripheral nervous system disorders, metabolic and 
    digestive disorders (other than diabetes mellitus), immune system 
    disorders, circulatory disorders, respiratory disorders (other than 
    certain respiratory cancers), skin cancer, cognitive and 
    neuropsychiatric effects, gastrointestinal tumors, brain tumors, and 
    any other condition for which the Secretary has not specifically 
    determined a presumption of service connection is warranted.
    
    FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Donald England, Chief, Regulations 
    Staff, Compensation and Pension Service, Veterans Benefits 
    Administration, 810 Vermont Avenue, NW., Washington, DC 20420, 
    telephone (202) 273-7210.
    
    SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Section 3 of the Agent Orange Act of 1991, 
    Pub. L. 102-4, 105 Stat. 11, directed the Secretary to seek to enter 
    into an agreement with the National Academy
    
    [[Page 59233]]
    
    of Sciences (NAS) to review and summarize the scientific evidence 
    concerning the association between exposure to herbicides used in 
    support of military operations in the Republic of Vietnam during the 
    Vietnam era and each disease suspected to be associated with such 
    exposure. Congress mandated that NAS determine, to the extent possible: 
    (1) Whether there is a statistical association between the suspect 
    diseases and herbicide exposure, taking into account the strength of 
    the scientific evidence and the appropriateness of the methods used to 
    detect the association; (2) the increased risk of disease among 
    individuals exposed to herbicides during service in the Republic of 
    Vietnam during the Vietnam era; and (3) whether there is a plausible 
    biological mechanism or other evidence of a causal relationship between 
    herbicide exposure and the suspect disease. Section 3 of Pub. L. 102-4 
    also required that NAS submit reports on its activities every two years 
    (as measured from the date of the first report) for a ten-year period.
        Section 2 of Pub. L. 102-4 provides that whenever the Secretary 
    determines, based on sound medical and scientific evidence, that a 
    positive association (i.e., the credible evidence for the association 
    is equal to or outweighs the credible evidence against the association) 
    exists between exposure of humans to an herbicide agent (i.e., a 
    chemical in an herbicide used in support of the United States and 
    allied military operations in the Republic of Vietnam during the 
    Vietnam era) and a disease, the Secretary will publish regulations 
    establishing presumptive service connection for that disease. If the 
    Secretary determines that a presumption of service connection is not 
    warranted, he is to publish a notice of that determination, including 
    an explanation of the scientific basis for that determination. The 
    Secretary's determination must be based on consideration of the NAS 
    reports and all other sound medical and scientific information and 
    analysis available to the Secretary.
        Although Pub. L. 102-4 does not define ``credible,'' it does 
    instruct the Secretary to ``take into consideration whether the results 
    [of any study] are statistically significant, are capable of 
    replication, and withstand peer review.'' Simply comparing the number 
    of studies which report a positive relative risk to the number of 
    studies which report a negative relative risk for a particular 
    condition is not a valid method for determining whether the weight of 
    evidence overall supports a finding that there is or is not a positive 
    association between herbicide exposure and the subsequent development 
    of the particular condition. Because of differences in statistical 
    significance, confidence levels, control for confounding factors, bias, 
    and other pertinent characteristics, some studies are clearly more 
    credible than others, and the Secretary has given the more credible 
    studies more weight in evaluating the overall weight of the evidence 
    concerning specific diseases.
        NAS issued its initial report, entitled ``Veterans and Agent 
    Orange: Health Effects of Herbicides Used in Vietnam,'' (VAO) on July 
    27, 1993. The Secretary subsequently determined that a positive 
    association exists between exposure to herbicides used in the Republic 
    of Vietnam and the subsequent development of Hodgkin's disease, 
    porphyria cutanea tarda, multiple myeloma, and certain respiratory 
    cancers; and that there was no positive association between herbicide 
    exposure and any other condition, other than chloracne, non-Hodgkin's 
    lymphoma, and soft-tissue sarcomas, for which presumptions already 
    existed. A notice of the diseases that the Secretary determined were 
    not associated with exposure to herbicide agents was published on 
    January 4, 1994 (See 59 FR 341-46).
        NAS issued its second report, entitled ``Veterans and Agent Orange: 
    Update 1996'' (Update 1996), on March 14, 1996. The Secretary 
    subsequently determined that a positive association exists between 
    exposure to herbicides used in the Republic of Vietnam and the 
    subsequent development of prostate cancer and acute and subacute 
    peripheral neuropathy in exposed persons. The Secretary further 
    determined that there was no positive association between herbicide 
    exposure and any other condition, other than those for which 
    presumptions already existed. A notice of the diseases that the 
    Secretary determined were not associated with exposure to herbicide 
    agents was published on August 8, 1996 (See 61 FR 41442-49).
        NAS issued a third report, entitled ``Veterans and Agent Orange: 
    Update 1998'' (Update 1998), on February 11, 1999. The focus of this 
    updated review was on new scientific studies published since the 
    release of Update 1996 and updates of scientific studies previously 
    reviewed.
        Shortly after NAS issued Update 1998, the Secretary formed a VA 
    task force to review the report and pertinent studies and to make 
    recommendations to assist him in determining whether a positive 
    association exists between herbicide exposure and any condition. The 
    task force has completed that review and submitted its recommendations 
    to the Secretary. This notice, pursuant to Pub. L. 102-4, conveys the 
    Secretary's determination that there is no positive association between 
    herbicide exposure and hepatobiliary cancers, nasal/nasopharyngeal 
    cancer, bone cancer, breast cancer, female reproductive cancers, 
    urinary bladder cancer, renal cancer, testicular cancer, leukemia, 
    abnormal sperm parameters and infertility, motor/coordination 
    dysfunction, chronic peripheral nervous system disorders, metabolic and 
    digestive disorders (other than diabetes mellitus), immune system 
    disorders, circulatory disorders, respiratory disorders (other than 
    certain respiratory cancers), skin cancer, cognitive and 
    neuropsychiatric effects, gastrointestinal tumors, brain tumors, and 
    any other condition for which the Secretary has not specifically 
    determined a presumption of service connection is warranted.
        This notice also conveys the Secretary's determination that a new 
    study concerning the possible association between exposure to 
    herbicides and diabetes mellitus that was published since NAS completed 
    Update 1998, is potentially significant. The Secretary has requested, 
    and the NAS is currently reviewing that new study and will determine 
    whether a positive association exists between herbicide exposure and 
    diabetes mellitus after their review.
        NAS, in Update 1998, assigns hepatobiliary cancers, nasal/
    nasopharyngeal cancer, bone cancer, breast cancer, female reproductive 
    cancers, urinary bladder cancer, renal cancer, testicular cancer, 
    leukemia, abnormal sperm parameters and infertility, motor/coordination 
    dysfunction, chronic peripheral nervous system disorders, metabolic and 
    digestive disorders (including diabetes mellitus), immune system 
    disorders, circulatory disorders, respiratory disorders (other than 
    certain respiratory cancers), and skin cancer to a category labeled 
    inadequate/insufficient evidence to determine whether an association 
    exists. This is defined as meaning that the available studies are of 
    insufficient quality, consistency, or statistical power to permit a 
    conclusion regarding the presence or absence of an association with 
    herbicide exposure.
    
    Hepatobiliary Cancers
    
        Hepatobiliary cancers are cancers of the liver and intrahepatic 
    bile ducts. There are a variety of known risk
    
    [[Page 59234]]
    
    factors, including chronic infections with hepatitis B and C, exposure 
    to aflatoxin, vinyl chloride and polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB) and 
    smoking, that should be considered by a credible study. NAS, in VAO, 
    found the relevant studies to be few, and to have not adequately 
    controlled for these risk factors. One large case-control study showed 
    a positive relationship between herbicide exposure and the subsequent 
    development of hepatobiliary cancer; however, most other credible 
    studies of similar size indicated no relationship. A large occupational 
    study and a study of farmers found no relationship. See 59 FR 343 for 
    study citations.
        NAS noted in Update 1996 that an association between dioxin and 
    liver cancer is biologically plausible, in view of evidence that very 
    high exposures to similar compounds which interact with the Ah receptor 
    (an intracellular protein) increase liver cancer risk. However, NAS 
    concluded in that report that the available evidence is inadequate to 
    determine whether an association exists between exposure to herbicides 
    or dioxin and the incurrence of hepatobiliary cancer. The evidence of 
    biologic plausibility may lend credibility to the evidence for an 
    association between herbicide exposure and liver cancer, but does not 
    itself provide significant evidence of such an association. NAS, in 
    Update 1996, again noted that there are few occupational, 
    environmental, or veterans' studies of liver cancer, and most of these 
    are small in size and were not controlled for other risk factors. For 
    example, one small occupational study of workers with potential 
    exposure to TCDD and 4-aminobiphenyl (Collins et al., 1993) showed a 
    slight, but not statistically significant, increased risk for 
    hepatobiliary cancer; however, it did not control for exposure to 4-
    aminobiphenyl. A large study of herbicide applicators in Finland (Asp 
    et al., 1994) found no increased risk of hepatobiliary cancer. A study 
    of farmers in 23 states (Blair et al., 1993) found no increase in 
    proportionate cancer mortality for liver cancer. In summary, most 
    studies that addressed hepatobiliary cancers suffered from 
    methodological problems or did not reflect an association. See 61 FR 
    41443 for study citations.
        NAS, in Update 1998, again assigned hepatobiliary cancer to the 
    category ``inadequate/insufficient evidence to determine whether an 
    association exists.'' The IARC study (Kogevinas M, Becher H, Benn T, 
    Bertazzi PA, Boffetta P, Bueno-de-Mesquita HB, Coggon D, Colin D, 
    Flesch-Janys D, Fingerhut M, Green L, Kauppinen T, Lettorin M, Lynge E, 
    Mathews JD, Neuberger M, Pearce N, Saracci R. 1997. Cancer mortality in 
    workers exposed to phenoxy herbicides, chlorophenols, and dioxins. An 
    expanded and updated international cohort study. American Journal of 
    Epidemiology 145(12): 1061-1075.) noted no excess of death from 
    hepatobiliary cancer among a group of all workers exposed to phenoxy 
    herbicides or chlorophenol, although those exposed to TCDD or higher 
    chlorinated dioxins had a higher risk (SMR=0.87, CI 0.45-1.52) than 
    those not exposed (SMR=0.41, CI 0.09-1.22). However, this study did not 
    include a detailed analysis by exposure variables (such as duration and 
    time since first exposure), and did not distinguish heavily exposed 
    workers from those with minor exposures. A study of 2,479 male workers 
    in German facilities that produced phenoxy herbicides and chlorophenols 
    (Becher H, Flesch-Janys D, Kauppinen T, Kogevinas M, Steindorf K, Manz 
    A, Wahrendorf J. 1996. Cancer mortality in German male workers exposed 
    to phenoxy herbicides and dioxins. Cancer Causes and Control 7(3): 312-
    21.) showed only one death due to hepatobiliary cancer (SMR=1.2, CI 0-
    6.9); this was in one of the groups with presumed lower TCDD exposure. 
    Observed and expected deaths due to liver cancer among a cohort of rice 
    growers in northern Italy between 1957 and 1992 (Gambini GF, Mantovani 
    C, Pira E, Piolatto PG, Negri E. 1997. Cancer mortality among rice 
    growers in Novara Province, Northern Italy. American Journal of 
    Industrial Medicine 31(4); 435-441.) did not differ significantly from 
    national rates (SMR=1.3, CI 0.5-2.6). This small study is limited by 
    its crude exposure assessment and uncertainty in establishing degree of 
    exposure. A 15-year follow-up of the exposed population of Seveso, 
    Italy (Bertazzi PA, Zochetti C, Guercilena S, Consonni D, Tironi A, 
    Landi MT, Pesatori AC. 1997. Dioxin exposure and cancer risk: A 15-year 
    mortality study after the ``Seveso Accident.'' Epidemiology 8(6): 646-
    652) showed nonsignificant decreases in liver cancer in all exposure 
    groups except for women in group B, where a nonsignificant elevation 
    was seen (3 cases for an SMR=1.3, CI 0.3-3.8). A study of two cohorts 
    of Swedish fishermen, distinguished by the types of fish in their diets 
    and the presumed levels of PCB, PCDD, and PCDF in the fish (Svennson 
    BG, Mikoczy Z, Stromberg U, Hagmar L. 1995. Mortality and cancer 
    incidence among Swedish fishermen with a high dietary intake of 
    persistent organochlorine compounds. Scandinavian Journal of Work, 
    Environment, and Health 21(2): 106-115.), showed nonsignificantly 
    decreased mortality from liver cancer in both groups. The group 
    presumed to have higher exposure had a nonsignificantly increased 
    incidence of the disease compared to national Swedish rates (SIR=1.31, 
    CI 0.48-2.85), while the less exposed group had a nonsignificantly 
    decreased incidence. A particular weakness of this study is the lack of 
    data to support the differences in reported blood levels of dioxin-like 
    compounds for each group. A study of male Australian Vietnam veterans 
    (Crane PJ, Horsley KD, Adena MA. 1997a. Mortality of Vietnam veterans: 
    the veteran cohort study: A report of the 1996 retrospective cohort 
    study of Australian Vietnam veterans, Canberra; Department of Veterans 
    Affairs.) reported a statistically significant excess of all cancer 
    deaths among the 2,067 deaths recorded from 1980 to 1994 but observed 
    no excess of mortality from liver cancer (SMR=0.6, CI 0.3-1.2). 
    However, among the weaknesses of this study are the possible under 
    ascertainment of death, and the uncertain quality of assessing such 
    risk factors as smoking, alcohol, and herbicide and dioxin exposure. 
    Crane's subsequent study of mortality among Australian National Service 
    Vietnam veterans reported similar findings for hepatobiliary cancer 
    (Crane PJ, Horsley KD, Adena MA. 1997b. Mortality of Vietnam veterans: 
    the national servicemen comparison. A report of the 1996 retrospective 
    cohort study of Australian Vietnam veterans. Canberra; Department of 
    Veterans Affairs.).
        Most of the few existing studies addressing hepatobiliary cancer 
    contain methodological difficulties such as small study size and 
    inadequate control for life-style-related risk factors, or do not 
    support an association with herbicide exposure. Accordingly, the 
    Secretary has found that the credible evidence against an association 
    between hepatobiliary cancer and herbicide exposure outweighs the 
    credible evidence for such an association, and he has determined that a 
    positive association does not exist.
    
    Nasal/Nasopharyngeal Cancer
    
        NAS noted that exposure to nickel, chromates, wood dust and 
    formaldehyde are risk factors for nasal cancers. Smoking, exposure to 
    salt-preserved foods, and Epstein-Barr virus may increase the risk of 
    nasopharyngeal cancer.
        In VAO, NAS found studies of nasal and nasopharyngeal cancers very 
    limited. Most studies showed
    
    [[Page 59235]]
    
    inconclusive results, and often did not control for known confounding 
    variables. Pharmacokinetic studies indicate that dioxin accumulates in 
    the nasopharyngeal areas of animals. Two epidemiological studies and 
    one case-control study showed increased risk associated with herbicide 
    exposure; however, two of those studies were statistically 
    insignificant and the small size of the three studies limits their 
    value in detecting an association. One study (Wiklund K., 1983) found a 
    decreased risk of nasal cancer in Swedish agricultural workers. A study 
    of Vietnam veterans (Centers for Disease Control, 1990) found no 
    association between nasal/nasopharyngeal cancers and Vietnam service. 
    (See 59 FR 345 for study citations.)
        NAS noted in Update 1996 that the scientific evidence concerning an 
    association between herbicide exposure and nasopharyngeal cancer 
    continues to be too sparse to make a definitive conclusion regarding 
    the association of nasal/nasopharyngeal cancers with herbicide 
    exposure. An 18-year follow-up of Finnish herbicide applicators (Asp et 
    al., 1994) showed a small, statistically insignificant increased risk 
    and a decreased mortality risk for cancers of the nasopharynx and 
    larynx. Moreover, that study presented little data and combined cancers 
    of the nasopharynx and larynx into a single category, which diminishes 
    its importance regarding the relationship between herbicide exposure 
    and nasopharyngeal cancers. An environmental study based on a follow-up 
    of the Seveso, Italy, population (Bertazzi et al., 1993) found a 
    statistically insignificant increased risk for cancer of the nose and 
    nasal cavity among women in the least-contaminated area and found no 
    cases among men in the same area (although 1.5 were expected) and no 
    cases in the most-contaminated areas. (See 61 FR 41443-44 for study 
    citations.)
        In Update 1998, NAS stated that scientific evidence of an 
    association with herbicide exposure continues to be too sparse to make 
    a definitive statement. The IARC study (Kogevinas et al., 1997) has 
    brought together almost all of the phenoxy herbicide production workers 
    in 36 cohorts for a joint analysis. That combined cohort study showed 
    no effect of phenoxy herbicide exposure on oral cavity or pharyngeal 
    cancers (RR=1.1, CI 0.7-1.6). There were three deaths from cancer of 
    the nose and nasal sinuses, but none in the TCDD-exposed group (RR=1.6, 
    CI 0.3-4.7). Crane et al, (1997a) found no deaths from either nasal or 
    nasopharyngeal cancer in Australian Vietnam veterans during 1964-1979, 
    with 0.8 expected. For the period 1980-1994, there were two deaths due 
    to nasal and two due to nasopharyngeal cancers, with 1.7 and 3.9 
    expected, respectively. Crane's companion study comparing Australian 
    Vietnam veterans with military personnel who did not serve there showed 
    one death due to nasopharyngeal cancer in each group between 1982-1994, 
    and only one death due to nasal cancer, which occurred in the 
    comparison population (Crane et al., 1997b). NAS found that the 
    scientific evidence of the association between herbicide exposure and 
    nasopharyngeal cancer continues to be too sparse to make a definitive 
    statement.
        Accordingly, the Secretary has found that the credible evidence 
    against an association between nasal/nasopharyngeal cancer and 
    herbicide exposure outweighs the credible evidence for such an 
    association, and he has determined that a positive association does not 
    exist.
    
    Bone Cancers
    
        Bone cancers were considered together with joint cancers in VAO. 
    Because of the rarity of bone cancers, most studies were too small to 
    detect a significant risk. There was not a consistent finding of bone 
    cancer in exposed groups; a number of studies showed no association, 
    and the few studies that demonstrated a positive relationship were 
    small and had large confidence intervals. The small size of the studies 
    and the statistical limitations compromised their credibility. (See 59 
    FR 343 for study citations.)
        NAS noted in Update 1996 only two new studies that considered bone 
    cancers. Both studies (Collins et al., 1993 and Blair et al., 1993) 
    found nonsignificant increases in mortality rates due to bone cancers. 
    Methodologic problems did not permit NAS to reach a conclusion 
    regarding the presence or absence of an association between bone 
    cancers and exposure to herbicides. (See 61 FR 41444 for study 
    citations.)
        In Update 1998, NAS reports that there is minimal new information 
    regarding bone cancer and that few data existed before. A study of the 
    IARC combined occupational cohorts (Kogevinas et al., 1997) found five 
    cases of bone cancer for all workers (SMR=1.2, CI 0.4-2.8). The SMR in 
    those exposed to TCDD was lower (1.1) than in those not exposed (1.4). 
    A study of 770 pentachlorophenol workers reported no deaths from bone 
    cancer (Ramlow JM, Spadacene JW, Hoag SR, Stafford BA, Cartmill JB, 
    Lerner PJ. 1996. Mortality in a cohort of pentachlorophenol 
    manufacturing workers, 1940-1989. American Journal of Industrial 
    Medicine 30(2): 180-194.). A study of rice growers in northern Italy 
    (Gambini et al., 1997) identified only one death, and a study of 26,000 
    Canadian sawmill workers presumptively exposed to dioxin-contaminated 
    chlorophenate reported five bone cancer deaths (SMR=1.3, CI 0.5-2.7) 
    (Hertzmann C, Teschke K, Ostry A, Hershler R, Dimich-Ward H, Kelly S, 
    Spinelli JJ, Gallagher RP, McBride M, Marion SA. 1997. Mortality and 
    cancer incidence among sawmill workers exposed to chlorophenate wood 
    preservatives. American Journal of Public Health 87(1): 71-79.). A 
    follow-up of individuals exposed as a result of the 1976 industrial 
    accident in Seveso, Italy, found 2 deaths in men (SMR=0.5) in the 
    lowest exposure zone and 7 deaths in women in the lowest exposure zone 
    (SMR=2.4) (Bertazzi et al., 1997). Clapp's update of his study of 
    Massachusetts Vietnam veterans reports 4 cases of bone cancer (OR=0.9, 
    CI 0.1-11.3) (Clapp RW. 1997. Update of cancer surveillance of veterans 
    in Massachusetts, USA. International Journal of Epidemiology 26(3): 
    679-681.). Other Vietnam veteran studies did not report bone cancer 
    results. After reviewing all available evidence, the Secretary has 
    found that the credible evidence against an association between bone 
    cancers and herbicide exposure outweighs the credible evidence for such 
    an association, and he has determined that a positive association does 
    not exist.
    
    Breast Cancer and Female Reproductive Cancers
    
        The data related to women and herbicide exposure have been 
    extremely limited because few of the studies have included women. 
    Cohorts reviewed in occupational studies have included few exposed 
    female workers.
        Female reproductive cancers reviewed by NAS in VAO included those 
    of the breast, ovaries, and uterus (including the cervix and 
    endometrium). Because of the public health significance of breast 
    cancer, NAS, in Update 1996, considered breast cancer separately from 
    the other reproductive cancers. In Update 1998, NAS again addresses 
    breast cancer separately from the other cancers.
    
    Breast Cancer
    
        Risk factors for breast cancer include age, race, personal or 
    family history of breast cancer and reproductive history. The data 
    relating exposure to herbicides to breast cancer are sparse. In VAO, 
    NAS found that most of the breast cancer studies showed no association. 
    Two studies, both of which failed to
    
    [[Page 59236]]
    
    control for reproductive histories and had methodological problems, 
    showed a nonsignificant risk for breast cancer. (See 59 FR 343 for 
    study citations.)
        In Update 1996, NAS reviewed four recently published studies 
    (Bertazzi et al., 1993; Blair et al., 1993; Kogevinas et al., 1993, and 
    Dalager et al., 1995) that showed no increased risk for breast cancer. 
    NAS noted that it was unclear whether the female members of those 
    cohorts had substantial chemical exposure. (See 61 FR 41444 for study 
    citations.)
        NAS found few new published studies on breast cancer since Update 
    1996. The IARC study (Kogevinas et al., 1997) found a nonsignificant 
    increased risk of breast cancer in males, as well as a significant 
    increased risk in one cohort of women from Germany with substantial 
    exposure to TCDD or higher chlorinated dioxins. Data from Australian 
    Vietnam veterans (Crane et al., 1997a) also indicated an elevation of 
    male breast cancer (SMR=5.5, 95% CI 1.1-16.1). The findings of 
    increased risk for males are notable because breast cancer in males is 
    rare. On the other hand, the 15-year follow-up of the Seveso population 
    (Bertazzi et al., 1997) indicates no excess of breast cancer, and even 
    suggests a possible protective effect of TCDD exposure (RR less than 
    1.0). TCDD also appears to exert a protective effect on the incidence 
    of mammary tumors in experimental animals. Taken together, the data 
    continue to be inconclusive. Accordingly, the Secretary has found that 
    the credible evidence against an association between herbicide exposure 
    and breast cancer outweighs the credible evidence for such an 
    association, and he has determined that a positive association does not 
    exist.
    
    Female Reproductive Cancers (Ovaries, Uterus, Cervix, Endometrium)
    
        In VAO, NAS identified only one small case-control study which 
    found an association with ovarian cancer, but the confidence intervals 
    were very large. The larger occupational and farm worker studies 
    generally showed no increased risk for ovarian or uterine cancers. VAO 
    identified three studies showing no increased risk for uterine cancer 
    (including cancers of the cervix and endometrium). One study showed a 
    slightly increased risk for cervical cancer and no increased risk for 
    endometrial cancer. (See 59 FR 343 for study citations.)
        In Update 1996, NAS reviewed a follow-up study of the Seveso 
    population which found no significant increased risk of ovarian or 
    uterine cancer. A study of 701 women occupationally exposed to 
    chlorophenoxy herbicides, chlorophenols and dioxins found one death 
    from each of the following types of cancer: cervical (SMR=80), uterine 
    nonspecified (SMR=192), and ovarian (SMR=74). One study found a 
    statistically significant increase in cervical cancer among employees 
    of two Danish phenoxy herbicide manufacturing facilities, based on 
    seven cases (SIR=3.2, CI 1.3-6.6). A study of farmers in 23 states 
    found no increase in the proportionate cancer mortality ratio (PCMR) 
    for cervical cancer in white female farmers, but found a significantly 
    increased PCMR in nonwhite female farmers. This study did not correlate 
    the increased PCMR to herbicide exposure and NAS noted that the 
    increased mortality may reflect risks associated with factors other 
    than herbicide exposure. A study of female Vietnam veterans showed a 
    nonsignificant increased risk of uterine cancer. Although the studies 
    cited in Update 1996 provided some evidence of an association between 
    herbicide exposure and cervical cancer, there continued to be a number 
    of significant studies showing no association between herbicide 
    exposure and either ovarian or uterine cancers (including cervical and 
    endometrial cancers). (See 61 FR 4144-45 for study citations.)
        In Update 1998, NAS reviewed two new studies. A 15-year follow-up 
    of more than 20,000 exposed women in the Seveso population (Bertazzi et 
    al., 1997) provides no evidence that TCDD is associated with deaths 
    from either uterine or ovarian cancer. Deaths from uterine cancer were 
    lower than expected in the two zones with the highest exposures, and 
    the deaths from ovarian cancer were 1 and 0, respectively, where 0.4 
    and 2.7, respectively, were expected. In one zone with a lower exposure 
    (but still greater than those not exposed to the accident), 27 uterine 
    cancer deaths were observed, where 23.7 were expected (RR=1.1, 95% CI 
    0.8-1.7). The RR for ovarian cancer in this zone was 1.0 (CI 0.6-1.6). 
    However, it may still be too early for tumors related to exposure to 
    have come to clinical attention. In the IARC study (Kogevinas et al., 
    1997), no deaths from cancer of the uterine cervix or the ovary were 
    observed among women exposed to TCDD or higher chlorinated dioxins. An 
    SMR of 3.41 was observed for cancer of the endometrium and uterus based 
    on three cases with exposure to TCDD or higher chlorinated dioxins. Two 
    of these cases occurred in the cohort that included most of the TCDD-
    exposed female production workers. NAS concluded that despite some 
    strong associations with ovarian and uterine cancers, the evidence 
    remains inconclusive, largely because most of the published studies 
    have only a small number of cases, poor exposure characterization, or 
    too short a follow-up period. Considering the entire evidence, the 
    Secretary has found that the credible evidence against an association 
    between herbicide exposure and ovarian and uterine cancers outweighs 
    the credible evidence for such an association, and he has determined 
    that a positive association does not exist.
    
    Urinary Bladder Cancer
    
        Smoking is the most important risk factor for cancer of the urinary 
    bladder. However, exposure to aromatic amines, high fat diet and 
    schistosoma hematobium infection have also been implicated. In VAO and 
    Update 1996, NAS assigned urinary bladder cancer to a category labeled 
    limited/suggestive evidence of no association with herbicide exposure. 
    This category is defined as meaning that several adequate studies, 
    covering the full range of levels of exposure that humans are known to 
    encounter, are mutually consistent in not showing a positive 
    association between herbicide exposure and the particular health 
    outcome at any level of exposure. One study found a small excess of 
    mortality in chemical production workers exposed to TCDD. There were 
    many other credible studies that produced inconclusive results. (For 
    study citations, see pages 515-17 of the 1993 report and pages 225-27 
    of the 1996 report.)
        In Update 1998, NAS, on the basis of all epidemiologic evidence, 
    felt that urinary bladder cancer should now be assigned to the category 
    ``inadequate/insufficient evidence to determine whether an association 
    exists.'' The risk ratios (RR) in some of the largest cohorts tended to 
    be greater than 1, weakening the prior conclusion that there was 
    positive evidence of no relationship. The IARC study found an SMR of 
    1.0 (CI 0.7-1.5) for all workers, and an SMR of 1.4 (CI 0.9-2.1) among 
    workers exposed to TCDD or higher chlorinated dioxins (Kogevinas et 
    al., 1997). A follow-up of BASF employees (Ott MG, Zober A. 1996. Cause 
    specific mortality and cancer incidence among employees exposed to 
    2,3,7,8-TCDD after a 1953 reactor accident. Occupational and 
    Environmental Medicine 53(9): 606-612.) found two deaths from a total 
    of five cases (SIR=1.4, CI 0.4-3.2), but they were described as due to 
    ``bladder or kidney'' cancer. A cohort of Swedish fisherman with 
    presumed elevated-exposure (Svensson et al., 1995) showed
    
    [[Page 59237]]
    
    an SIR of 0.7 (CI 0.4-1.3), while a comparison cohort showed an SIR of 
    0.9 (CI 0.7-1.1). SMRs for the two cohorts were 1.3 (CI 0.4-3.1) and 
    1.0 (CI 0.6-1.6), respectively. Other new occupational and 
    environmental studies showed results around the null (Hertzman et al., 
    1997; Gambini et al., 1997; and Bertazzi et al., 1997). Among Vietnam 
    veteran studies, a study of the mortality experience of Australian 
    veterans relative to military personnel who did not serve in Vietnam 
    reported a statistically significant RR of 0.6 based on one death among 
    Vietnam veterans and two in the comparison group (Crane et al., 1997b). 
    An update of a study of Massachusetts veterans (Clapp, 1997) found an 
    OR of 0.6 (CI 0.2-1.3) based on 80 cases.
        On the basis of its review of new studies, NAS found that there is 
    no evidence that exposure to herbicides alone is related to bladder 
    cancer. Exposure to TCDD in combination with other known bladder 
    carcinogens made it difficult to isolate any additional effect of 
    herbicides. Considering the entire evidence, the Secretary has found 
    that the credible evidence against an association between herbicide 
    exposure and urinary bladder cancer outweighs the credible evidence for 
    such an association, and he has determined that a positive association 
    does not exist.
    
    Renal Cancer
    
        NAS found in VAO that the leather industry, asbestos, cadmium, 
    petroleum products, analgesics, smoking, and obesity are associated 
    with renal cancers. Studies of renal cancers in relation to herbicide 
    exposure have generally produced inconclusive results because they 
    failed to adequately control for these confounding factors. Only one 
    study of agricultural and forest workers showed a significantly 
    increased risk of death from renal cancers; however, the preponderance 
    of studies, including the two largest, showed either no relationship 
    with renal cancers or increased risk which was not significant. (See 59 
    FR 343 for study citations.)
        In Update 1996, NAS reviewed two new studies (Blair et al., 1993; 
    and Visintainer et al., 1995) that showed increased risk for renal 
    cancer that was not significant. A third cohort study (Bertazzi et al., 
    1993) demonstrated no increased risk of renal cancer in highly exposed 
    individuals. One Danish case-control study (Mellengaard et al., 1994) 
    showed increased risk for renal cancer; however, the results were 
    considered highly uncertain because of the wide confidence limits. (See 
    61 FR 41445 for study citations.)
        In Update 1998, NAS found that the most important new study was 
    that of the IARC cohorts (Kogevinas et al., 1997). This study reported 
    26 cases of kidney cancer (SMR=1.6; CI 1.1-2.4) for workers exposed to 
    TCDD, and an SMR of 1.1 (CI 0.7-1.6) for all workers exposed to any 
    phenoxy herbicide or chlorophenol. However, the study provided no trend 
    analysis by duration of exposure or time since exposure. Clapp's update 
    on Massachusetts Vietnam veterans (Clapp, 1997) reported an OR of 1.0 
    (CI 0.4-2.3). A study comparing all Australian Vietnam veterans to the 
    male Australian population reported SMR=1.2 (CI 0.8-1.9) (Crane et al., 
    1997a). Another study of Australian Vietnam veterans compared with 
    military personnel who did not serve in the conflict reported a 
    statistically significant RR of 3.9 based on three deaths among Vietnam 
    veterans and one in the comparison population between 1982 and 1984 
    (Crane et al., 1997b). However, this study did not have exposure 
    information. Other studies reviewed by NAS produced equivocal results. 
    NAS concluded that of the literature published since Update 1996, only 
    the IARC study points to a possible association between herbicide 
    exposure and renal cancer, but that, due to its marginal significance, 
    lack of trend data, and heterogeneity of the cohorts, it was not strong 
    enough to outweigh the equivocal results of the other studies. 
    Therefore, on the basis of all available evidence, the Secretary has 
    found that the credible evidence against an association between renal 
    cancer and herbicide exposure outweighs the credible evidence for such 
    an association, and he has determined that a positive association does 
    not exist.
    
    Testicular Cancer
    
        In VAO, NAS identified the major risk factors for testicular cancer 
    as undescended testis and other factors, such as genetic abnormalities, 
    infections, etc., which produce atrophy and dysfunction. Occupational 
    and environmental studies found either no association between herbicide 
    exposure and testicular cancer, or increased risk which was not 
    significant. (See 59 FR 343 for study citations.) In Update 1996, NAS 
    reviewed three new studies that produced results generally consistent 
    with the 1993 findings, i.e., either no association with testicular 
    cancer, or increased risk which was not significant. (See FR 61 41445 
    for study citations.)
        In Update 1998, NAS found minimal new information on this rare 
    cancer based on a review of 10 new studies (Kogevinas et al., 1997; 
    Ramlow et al., 1996; Hertzman et al., 1997; Bertazzi et al., 1997; 
    Zhong Y, Raffnsson V. 1996. Cancer incidence among Icelandic pesticide 
    users. International Journal of Epidemiology 25(6): 1117-1124; Dalager 
    NA, Kang HK. 1997. Mortality among Army Chemical Corps Vietnam 
    veterans. American Journal of Industrial Medicine 31(6): 719-726; 
    Watanabe KK, Kang HK. 1996. Mortality patterns among Vietnam veterans: 
    a 24-year retrospective analysis. Journal of Occupational and 
    Environmental Medicine 38(3): 272-278; Crane et al., 1997a; Crane et 
    al., 1997b; and Clapp 1997). NAS felt that what new information there 
    is provides little evidence of a connection between testicular cancer 
    and herbicide exposure. Several studies of military working dogs showed 
    abnormal testicular pathology and a moderate excess of seminomas in 
    dogs that had worked in Vietnam. However, NAS did not feel that these 
    studies carried great weight in the absence of exposure data and 
    without observed excesses in human populations. Accordingly, the 
    Secretary has found that the credible evidence against an association 
    between testicular cancer and herbicide exposure outweighs the credible 
    evidence for such an association, and he has determined that a positive 
    association does not exist.
    
    Leukemia
    
        In VAO, NAS found evidence for a possible association between 
    herbicide exposure and leukemia from studies of farmers and residents 
    of Seveso, Italy. When farmers were stratified by suspected herbicide 
    exposure, the incidence of leukemia was generally not elevated, and in 
    some cases elevation appeared to be due to factors other than herbicide 
    exposure. Those studies generally did not adequately control for other 
    significant confounding exposures. The suggestive evidence of increased 
    risk concerning Seveso, Italy, was not significant because of the small 
    number of actual cases in which leukemia was found. (See 59 FR 343-44 
    for study citations.)
        In Update 1996, NAS reviewed seven new studies. Six of these 
    studies showed no association between herbicide exposure and leukemia 
    or a nonsignificant elevated risk. One study, a mortality study of 
    farmers, showed a significantly increased PCMR for leukemia but did not 
    correlate the increased PCMR to suspected herbicide exposure and did 
    not control for other confounding factors. (See 61 FR 41445 for study 
    citations.)
        In Update 1998, NAS again found that, generally, the evidence of an
    
    [[Page 59238]]
    
    association of leukemia with herbicide exposure came from studies of 
    agricultural workers and a small subset of the Seveso cohort. A 
    population-based case-control study of farm workers in northeastern 
    Italy (Amadori D, Nanni O, Falcini F, Saragoni A, Tison V, Callea A, 
    Scarpi E, Ricci M, Riva N, Buiatti E. 1995. Chronic lymphocytic 
    leukaemias and non-Hodgkin's lymphomas by histological type in farming-
    animal breeding workers: a population case-control study based on job 
    titles. Occupational and Environmental Medicine 52(6): 374-379.) found 
    a high risk among farmers who are also involved in animal breeding 
    (OR=1.8, 95% CI 1.2-2.6). However, analysis of the population broken 
    down by the more frequent occupational categories showed no 
    significantly high risk in any occupation. A survey of total and site-
    specific cancer incidence in male and female adults from 1959 to 1987 
    (Waterhouse D, Carman WJ, Schottenfeld D, Gridley G, McLean S. 1996. 
    Cancer incidence in the rural community of Tecumseh, Michigan: A 
    pattern of increased lymphopoietic neoplasms. Cancer 77(4): 763-770.), 
    as compared with site-specific cancer incidence rates reported by the 
    Connecticut tumor registry, showed a significantly increased incidence 
    of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, Hodgkin's disease, and chronic lymphocytic 
    leukemia. A nested case-control study of this group, using risk factor 
    information documented prior to diagnosis, found that the RR of a 
    family history of lymphoma, leukemia, or multiple myeloma was 
    significantly increased among patients with lymphoproliferative 
    neoplasms (OR=3.8, CI 1.5-9.8; p=.005). The follow-up of the Seveso 
    population (Bertazzi et al., 1997) also suggested an increased risk, 
    but the results were based on very limited data from one small subset 
    of the whole cohort. Other studies, including occupational studies 
    (Kogevinas et al., 1997; Ramlow et al., 1996), a study of agricultural 
    workers (Gambini et al., 1997), and studies of Vietnam veterans 
    (Dalager and Kang, 1997; Crane et al., 1997b), showed no increased risk 
    or increases or decreases that were not significant.
        An association of leukemia with herbicide exposure is biologically 
    plausible, and the histological similarity of chronic lymphocytic 
    leukemia with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma also suggests an association. 
    Nonetheless, the overall evidence is too slight to warrant assigning 
    leukemia to a higher category. Accordingly, the Secretary has found 
    that the credible evidence against an association between leukemia and 
    herbicide exposure outweighs the credible evidence for such an 
    association, and he has determined that a positive association does not 
    exist.
    
    Abnormal Sperm Parameters and Infertility
    
        Infertility incorporates two concepts: the inability to conceive 
    and the inability to produce live children. Most studies do not take 
    into account the desire for children, contraceptive practices, and 
    other factors influencing fertility. VAO found no occupational or 
    environmental studies that examined herbicide exposure and infertility, 
    and veteran studies did not support an association between herbicide 
    exposure and infertility. There are several components of male 
    fertility, including sperm parameters and reproductive hormones. The 
    common parameters used to evaluate toxic effects to sperm are number, 
    motility, structure, and morphology. NAS found in VAO that many 
    chemicals have been implicated in interfering with motility and sperm 
    structure. One occupational study and one study of Vietnam veterans 
    found no association with decreased sperm count. Another study of 
    Vietnam veterans found lower sperm concentrations and reduced sperm 
    motility, but suggested these outcomes may be associated with the 
    Vietnam experience rather than exposure to herbicides. NAS did not cite 
    any studies concerning male reproductive hormone levels in VAO. (See 59 
    FR 344 for study citations.)
        In Update 1996, NAS reviewed one occupational study. Although it 
    suggested an association between TCDD exposure and changes in male 
    reproductive hormones, there were a number of methodologic concerns 
    that did not permit definitive conclusions to be drawn. NAS noted that 
    the hormonal changes were subtle, and it is not known whether they 
    would have any implications for reproductive failure.
        In Update 1998, NAS reviewed two new studies that evaluated 
    hormone, semen quality, and fertility endpoints in relation to 
    potential dioxin exposure. The Ranch Hand study (Henriksen GL, Michalek 
    JE, Swaby JA, Rahe AJ. 1996. Serum dioxin, testosterone, and 
    gonadotropins in veterans of Operation Ranch Hand. Epidemiology 7(4): 
    352-357.) reported a relatively small decrease in testosterone in 
    relation to increased dioxin level. A study of British Columbia sawmill 
    workers (Heacock H, Hogg R, Marion SA, Hershler R, Teschke K, Dimich-
    Ward H, Demers P, Kelly S, Ostry A, Hertzman C. 1998. Fertility among a 
    cohort of male sawmill workers exposed to chlorophenate fungicides. 
    Epidemiology 9(1): 56-60.) found reduced fertility rates among exposed 
    workers but could not consistently attribute this to chlorophenate 
    exposure. NAS again determined that uncertainty remained due to 
    methodologic limitations of some existing studies.
        NAS also reviewed the related fertility endpoint of altered sex 
    ratio as a result of dioxin/herbicide exposure. One study of a small 
    part of the Seveso population (Mocarelli P, Brambilla P, Gerthoux PM, 
    Patterson DG Jr, Needham LL. 1996. Change in sex ratio with exposure to 
    dioxin. Lancet 348(9024): 409.) suggested an altered ratio of male to 
    female children, but other studies did not support that finding (Garry 
    VF, Schreinemachers D, Harkins ME, Griffith J. 1996b. Pesticide 
    appliers, biocides, and birth defects in rural Minnesota. Environmental 
    Health Perspectives 104(4): 394-399; Heacock et al., 1998). NAS 
    concluded that experimental animal evidence and further mechanistic 
    data were needed to evaluate the relationship between sex ratio and 
    exposure to dioxin or herbicides.
        Accordingly, on the basis of all available evidence, the Secretary 
    has found that the credible evidence against an association between 
    abnormal sperm parameters and infertility and herbicide exposure 
    outweighs the credible evidence for such an association, and he has 
    determined that a positive association does not exist.
    
    Motor/Coordination Dysfunction
    
        NAS indicated in VAO that it had found no significant studies 
    available to analyze whether an association exists between herbicide 
    exposure and motor/coordination dysfunction. In Update 1996, NAS 
    reported finding no new studies directly addressing this topic. In 
    Update 1998, NAS reported that it was not aware of new studies relating 
    directly to this topic. Accordingly, the Secretary has found that there 
    is no credible evidence for an association between motor/coordination 
    dysfunction and herbicide exposure, and he has determined that a 
    positive association does not exist.
    
    Chronic Peripheral Nervous System Disorders
    
        Chronic peripheral nervous system disorders (chronic peripheral 
    neuropathy) can be induced by many common medical and environmental 
    disorders unrelated to herbicide exposure, such as alcoholism, 
    diabetes, and exposure to other toxic chemicals. In VAO, NAS stated 
    that many case
    
    [[Page 59239]]
    
    reports suggested that acute or subacute (transient) peripheral 
    neuropathy can develop with exposure to dioxin, but that the most 
    rigorously conducted studies argued against a relationship between 
    dioxin or herbicides and chronic peripheral neuropathy. VAO stated 
    that, as a group, the studies on peripheral neuropathy suffered from 
    various methodologic defects, such as not applying consistent methods 
    to define a comparison group, determine exposure, evaluate clinical 
    deficits, use standard definitions of peripheral neuropathy, or 
    eliminate confounding variables. Occupational studies that did not have 
    those methodological problems showed no difference in the incidence of 
    peripheral neuropathy for workers exposed to herbicides and workers not 
    so exposed. (See 59 FR 343 for study citations.)
        In Update 1996, NAS assigned acute and subacute peripheral 
    neuropathy to the category labeled limited/suggestive evidence of an 
    association with herbicide exposure, which it defined as meaning there 
    is evidence suggestive of an association between herbicide exposure and 
    a particular health outcome, but that evidence is limited because 
    chance, bias, and confounding could not be ruled out with confidence. 
    However, NAS continued to assign chronic peripheral neuropathy to the 
    category labeled inadequate/insufficient evidence to determine whether 
    an association exists. Two case studies reported development of 
    peripheral neuropathies within days of exposure to 2,4-D followed by 
    gradual recovery over a period of months. Studies of the Seveso, Italy, 
    accident suggested that peripheral nerve problems were more prevalent 
    in the exposed group. One of these studies demonstrated that those 
    individuals with clinical signs of significant exposure (chloracne or 
    elevated liver enzymes) showed a risk ratio of 2.8. Two subsequent 
    follow-up studies showed no increased frequency of peripheral 
    neuropathy several years after the accident among the highly exposed 
    group. Environmental studies and case reports suggest that the 
    development of peripheral neuropathy can follow high levels of exposure 
    to herbicides, and that peripheral neuropathy associated with herbicide 
    exposure will manifest very soon after exposure. The trend to recovery 
    in the individual cases reported and the negative findings of many 
    long-term follow up studies of peripheral neuropathy suggest that, if a 
    neuropathy develops, it resolves with time. Their findings are 
    consistent with others who found no evidence of increased occurrence of 
    chronic persistent peripheral neuropathy after TCDD exposure. (See 61 
    FR 41446-47 for study citations.)
        In Update 1998, NAS stated that no new information had appeared 
    since Update 1996 to alter its previous conclusions on chronic 
    persistent peripheral neuropathy. Where peripheral neuropathy is due to 
    a toxic exposure (such as to herbicides), it is characterized by acute 
    onset and subsequent resolution of the neuropathy after exposure to the 
    toxin is terminated. It would not be expected to appear for the first 
    time many years after exposure. Although the Secretary has previously 
    found a positive association between herbicide exposure and such acute 
    and subacute (transient) peripheral neuropathy, considering all of the 
    evidence, he has found that the credible evidence against an 
    association between chronic nervous system disorders and herbicide 
    exposure outweighs the credible evidence for such an association, and 
    he has determined that a positive association does not exist.
    
    Metabolic and Digestive Disorders
    
        Metabolic and digestive disorders covered in this notice include 
    hepatic enzyme abnormality, lipid abnormalities, and ulcers. In VAO, 
    NAS found that two studies related to hepatic enzyme abnormality did 
    not demonstrate an association with liver disease, and that confounding 
    factors (alcohol abuse, cirrhosis, hepatitis, and other toxic 
    chemicals) were not ruled out. Studies showing lipid abnormalities did 
    not control for the confounding variables of obesity and genetic 
    factors, and no medical significance of the modest and variable 
    increases was demonstrated. The risk of gastric ulcers in exposed 
    populations was not sufficiently studied to establish an association 
    with herbicide exposure. Only one study indicated any increase, and in 
    that study it was difficult to rule out the many factors (e.g., 
    alcoholism, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, and H. pylori 
    infection) known to be associated with ulcers. (See 59 FR 344-45 for 
    study citations.)
        In Update 1996, NAS reviewed the same studies when considering the 
    relationship between herbicide exposure and hepatic enzyme 
    abnormalities. The noted increases in abnormal liver function tests or 
    the frequency of chronic liver disease were confounded by the lack of 
    control for alcohol abuse. One study found a nonsignificant increase in 
    liver disease among individuals exposed to dioxin, and another found no 
    correlation between serum dioxin levels and abnormalities in liver 
    function tests. One new study was reviewed in Update 1996 concerning an 
    association between herbicide exposure and lipid abnormalities that 
    showed no substantial differences between the exposed and reference 
    groups. The only new study reviewed in Update 1996 concerning a 
    relationship between ulcers and exposure to herbicides showed no 
    increases in the frequency of ulcers. (See 61 FR 41447 for study 
    citations.)
        The two major lipids are cholesterol and triglycerides. They are 
    carried in the blood attached to proteins to form lipoproteins. 
    Lipoproteins are classed according to their density: very low density 
    lipoprotein (VLDL); intermediate-density lipoprotein (IDL); low-density 
    lipoprotein (LDL, the so-called ``bad'' cholesterol particle); and 
    high-density lipoprotein (HDL, the ``good cholesterol'' particle). 
    Lipid concentrations play a major role in determining an individual's 
    susceptibility to cardiovascular disease. Disorders of lipoprotein 
    metabolism are usually characterized by abnormally high or low 
    concentrations of lipoproteins. A number of factors may influence these 
    concentrations. For example, when assessing the effects of herbicide 
    exposure, obesity must be controlled for because it is a primary 
    determinant of both triglyceride and TCDD concentrations.
        The majority of new studies reviewed by NAS in Update 1998 do not 
    suggest any effects in lipid or lipoprotein concentrations as a result 
    of exposure to herbicide agents. A study of 641 Australian Vietnam 
    veterans (O'Toole BI, Marshall RP, Grayson DA, Schureck RJ, Dobson M, 
    Ffrench M, Pulvertaft B, Meldrum L, Bolton J, Vennard J. 1996b. The 
    Australian Vietnam Veterans Health Study: II. Self-reported health of 
    veterans compared with the Australian population. International Journal 
    of Epidemiology 25(2): 319-330.), did find an increased frequency of 
    elevated cholesterol compared to that expected from national Australian 
    data (RR=3.0, 95% CI 1.3-4.7), but the health problems of these 
    veterans were self-reported, and the data are difficult to assess with 
    any degree of certainty. A follow-up of the Ranch Hand study 
    participants (Air Force Health Study (AFHS). 1996. An epidemiologic 
    Investigation of Health Effects in Air Force Personnel Following 
    Exposure to Herbicides. Mortality Update 1996. Brooks AFB, TX: 
    Epidemiologic Research Division. Armstrong Laboratory. AL/AO-TR-1996-
    0068. 31 pp.) showed essentially no differences in the prevalence of 
    high triglyceride
    
    [[Page 59240]]
    
    levels, low HDL concentrations, or high ratios of total cholesterol to 
    HDL cholesterol between the Ranch Handers and the comparison group. 
    Other studies (Calvert et al., 1996; Ott and Zober, 1996) similarly 
    indicate a negative or at best a weak association for prevalence of any 
    abnormal lipid or lipoprotein concentrations.
        In Update 1998, NAS reviewed a few credible studies reporting some 
    increase in gastrointestinal disease possibly associated with exposure 
    to herbicide agents. A mortality study of a cohort of workers exposed 
    to pentachlorophenol (Ramlow et al., 1996) showed a slight increase in 
    overall digestive system disease. Increases were higher for gastric and 
    duodenal ulcer specifically (SMR 3.6, CI 1.2-8.3; 15-year latency SMR 
    5.6, CI 1.8-13.0). Higher rates of digestive disease generally were 
    seen in those exposed to higher PCP levels, but a significant decrease 
    in the risk for ulcer was found at higher levels of exposure. Liver 
    cirrhosis increased significantly with level of exposure, but 
    alcoholism played a role in some of these cases and cannot, therefore, 
    be discounted in the rest. In a study of the self-reported health 
    status of Australian veterans (O'Toole et al., 1996b), data indicated 
    that the veterans reported ulcer and other digestive disease more 
    frequently than did the control group. In these instances, however, the 
    authors suggested that psychological stress due to combat may have been 
    a causative factor and implied that high alcohol consumption played a 
    role. Two studies of American Vietnam veterans (AFHS, 1996; Dalager and 
    Kang, 1997) reported an increased incidence of digestive disease, 
    particularly cirrhosis or other liver disease. Lack of data about 
    alcohol consumption, however, makes this information difficult to 
    assess. Other studies provide no evidence of an association of 
    digestive system disease with exposure to herbicide agents. Some 
    studies, in fact, suggest no association (e.g., Bullman TA, Kang HK. 
    1996. The risk of suicide among wounded Vietnam veterans. American 
    Journal of Public Health 86(5): 662-667.), which observed a significant 
    decrease in deaths due to digestive disease among Vietnam veterans who 
    had been hospitalized for wounds suffered in Vietnam.
        After considering all evidence available, the Secretary has found 
    that the credible evidence against an association between metabolic and 
    digestive disorders and herbicide exposure outweighs the credible 
    evidence for such an association, and he has determined that a positive 
    association does not exist.
    
    Diabetes Mellitus
    
        In both VAO and Update 1996, NAS placed metabolic and digestive 
    disorders (including diabetes mellitus) in the category labeled 
    ``Inadequate/Insufficient Evidence to Determine Whether an Association 
    Exists.'' According to NAS, this means that the available studies are 
    of insufficient quality, consistency, or statistical power to permit a 
    conclusion regarding the presence or absence of an association. For 
    example, studies fail to control for confounding, have inadequate 
    exposure assessments, or fail to address latency.
        In Update 1998, NAS reviewed several new studies, including the 
    1997 report from the Ranch Hand study (Henrikson GL, Ketchum NS, 
    Michalek JE, Swaby JA. 1997. Serum dioxin and diabetes mellitus in 
    veterans of operation Ranch Hand. Epidemiology 8:252-258), that 
    addressed the issue of diabetes mellitus. Based on the evidence 
    reported in these and the previously reviewed studies, NAS again 
    concluded that there is inadequate/insufficient evidence to determine 
    whether an association exists between herbicide or dioxin exposure and 
    increased risk of diabetes. However, since NAS released Update 1998 the 
    National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) published 
    a report that detects an association, though not a strong association 
    between diabetes and dioxin exposure. The study does suggest a dose 
    response relationship because of excess cases of diabetes found in 
    workers having the highest serum-lipid levels of dioxin (Calvert GM, 
    Sweeney MH, Deddens J, Wall DK. 1999. Evaluation of Diabetes Mellitus, 
    Serum Glucose and Thyroid Function Among U.S. Workers Exposed to 
    2,3,7,8 tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin. Occupational and Environmental 
    Medicine 56:270-276). The Secretary has concluded that the NIOSH study 
    is potentially important enough that it warrants a full review by NAS 
    as soon as possible, and he has directed VA to amend its contract with 
    NAS for the third biennial update to require a special report on 
    herbicide exposure and diabetes, as a separate deliverable, within 
    approximately six months. The Secretary will make a determination as to 
    whether there is an association between herbicide exposure and diabetes 
    mellitus after NAS has reviewed the NIOSH report.
    
    Immune System Disorders
    
        In VAO, NAS found that the available data dealt with two categories 
    of immune system disorders: immune modulation and autoimmunity. Many 
    immune parameters were studied; however, few showed a relationship to 
    herbicide exposure. Most studies addressed such a wide range of immune 
    parameters that it was likely that at least some of the positive 
    results were due to chance alone. Other studies found no relationship 
    between immune system disorders and herbicide exposure. (See 59 FR 345 
    for study citations.)
        NAS noted in Update 1996 that no new studies of heightened 
    susceptibility to infectious disease or new studies that investigated 
    the association of autoimmune disease with exposure to herbicides had 
    been identified. However, some new information had been published 
    regarding the effects of TCDD on immunological parameters in laboratory 
    measurements. The new studies reviewed such a wide range of immune 
    parameters that it is likely that at least some of the abnormal 
    laboratory tests were due to chance. In addition, these studies failed 
    to show a relationship between laboratory abnormalities and development 
    of disease in the populations studied. (See 61 FR 41447 for study 
    citations.)
        In Update 1998, NAS reviewed two new studies relating to the 
    incidence of infectious diseases in American Vietnam veterans and two 
    new studies of Australian Vietnam veterans. A proportionate mortality 
    study of Vietnam veterans (Visintainer PF, Barone M, McGee H, Peterson 
    EL. 1995. Proportionate mortality study of Vietnam-era veterans of 
    Michigan. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine 37(4): 
    423-428) studied a cohort of 377,028 veterans who are on the Michigan 
    Department of Management and Budget's Vietnam-Era Bonus List. Vietnam 
    veterans compared with non-Vietnam veterans had a slightly elevated 
    proportionate mortality ratio from infectious and parasitic diseases 
    (PMR=1.6, CI 1.2-2.1, N=56). The study, however, did not distinguish 
    Vietnam veterans exposed to Agent Orange from those with no known 
    exposure. Watanabe and Kang (1995) (Watanabe KK, Kang HK. 1995. 
    Military service in Vietnam and the risk of death from trauma and 
    selected cancers. Annals of Epidemiology 5(5): 407-12.) found a 
    nonsignificant increased risk for infectious diseases in Vietnam 
    Marines compared with non-Vietnam Marines (RR=2.8; CI 0.8-10.3). The 
    studies of Australian Vietnam veterans did not show any increase in 
    mortality due to infectious or parasitic diseases (Crane et al., 
    1997a,b). NAS concluded that no evidence is available to associate 
    defects in the immune response with Agent Orange exposure.
    
    [[Page 59241]]
    
        NAS also discussed several studies concerning exposure to 
    halogenated aromatic hydrocarbons and shifts in lymphocyte 
    subpopulations. It concluded on the basis of these studies that there 
    is inadequate or insufficient evidence to determine whether an 
    association exists between exposure to herbicides and immune 
    suppression or autoimmunity.
        Accordingly, the Secretary has found that the credible evidence 
    against an association between immune system disorders and herbicide 
    exposure outweighs the credible evidence for such an association, and 
    he has determined that a positive association does not exist.
    
    Circulatory Disorders
    
        NAS noted in VAO that most occupational studies concerning 
    circulatory disorders showed no increased mortality or morbidity after 
    herbicide exposure. The studies of the residents of Seveso, Italy, 
    showed some increased risk of mortality in the first five-year follow-
    up; however, those studies had a number of technical problems: they 
    were not specific to circulatory disease and did not control for the 
    confounding variables of smoking, diabetes, and hypertension. Certain 
    of the veteran studies suggested that any increase in heart disease may 
    be associated with the Vietnam experience rather than herbicide 
    exposure, and most of those studies did not adjust for confounding 
    variables. (See 59 FR 345 for study citations.)
        NAS reviewed one study in Update 1996 that showed no increase in 
    the frequency of heart disease. Another study found possible 
    correlations for elevated systolic blood pressure; however, this 
    relationship was difficult to evaluate because age and body-mass index 
    also had a significant effect. An analysis of the data from an Air 
    Force study provided some potentially significant evidence for an 
    association with dioxin exposure, since the results were derived from 
    the first large-scale study of dose-response relationships. However, 
    this study did not control for the confounding factor of diabetes. 
    There was a significant increased risk of essential hypertension for 
    the participants with a high-level of dioxin exposure. However, the 
    reverse analysis of participants suffering from hypertension did not 
    show an association with dioxin, suggesting lack of dose-response 
    relationships. (See 61 FR 41447-48 for study citations.)
        In Update 1998 NAS found sporadic reports of increased circulatory 
    disease potentially related to exposure to herbicides or TCDD. A study 
    of cancer and circulatory system mortality among 1,189 male workers in 
    a chemical plant in Hamburg, Germany (Flesch-Janys D, Berger J, Gurn P, 
    Manz A, Nagel S, Waltsgott H, Dwyer JH. 1995. Exposure to 
    polychlorinated dioxins and furans (PCDD/F) and mortality in a cohort 
    of workers from a herbicide-producing plant in Hamburg, Federal 
    Republic of Germany. American Journal of Epidemiology 142(11): 1165-
    1175.) found overall circulatory system disease mortality to be 
    elevated among exposed workers. Results were dose-dependent; the RR 
    among those exposed to the highest estimated levels of TCDD was 2.0 
    (95% CI 1.2-3.3). The increased risk appeared to be restricted to 
    ischemic heart disease (IHD). Information was not available for 
    confounding factors related to IHD, but the authors reasoned that the 
    use of an unexposed referent population combined with the strong dose-
    response relationship argued against attributing the results to 
    confounding factors. They also noted that the smoking rates and 
    socioeconomic status of both cohorts appeared to be similar. In a 
    simple random sample of Australian Army Vietnam veterans on self-
    reported health status (O'Toole et al., 1996b), hypertension and other 
    circulatory system disease were reported significantly more frequently 
    by veterans. However, there was no significant association with combat 
    exposure, and veterans were more likely to be current or former smokers 
    and to report high alcohol consumption. The ongoing study of Ranch Hand 
    veterans (AFHS, 1996), observed a significant increase of circulatory 
    disorders among ground troops (SMR 1.5, CI 1.0-2.2), with nearly half 
    of the increase due to atherosclerotic heart disease (SMR 1.4, CI 0.8-
    2.1). However, data on smoking and alcohol use were not available.
        Most studies, however, noted decreases in incidence of circulatory 
    disorders, or at best, nonsignificant increases among exposed 
    individuals. NAS found inconsistent results across the studies 
    reviewed. Interpretation of individual studies was generally limited by 
    a lack of information on cigarette smoking, obesity, serum lipid 
    levels, presence of diabetes, and other risk factors. Accordingly, 
    after reviewing all available evidence, the Secretary has found that 
    the credible evidence against an association between circulatory 
    disorders and herbicide exposure outweighs the credible evidence for 
    such an association, and he has determined that a positive association 
    does not exist.
    
    Respiratory Disorders
    
        In VAO, NAS examined studies that covered a wide variety of 
    respiratory disorders other than respiratory cancers (e.g., chronic 
    bronchitis, asthma, pleurisy, pneumonia, and tuberculosis). Studies of 
    individuals exposed in occupational settings revealed no increase in 
    mortality from respiratory disease. Environmental exposure studies 
    similarly showed no significant differences in mortality due to 
    respiratory disease. Mortality studies of Vietnam veterans generally 
    found no increased risk. Morbidity data were generally difficult to 
    evaluate because of methodological problems and because studies focused 
    on symptoms, lung function tests and x-ray interpretation rather than 
    disease. One occupational study showed no excess morbidity; another 
    occupational study found increased symptomatology of respiratory 
    disease, but did not adequately control for the confounding factor of 
    age. (See 59 FR 345 for study citations.)
        In Update 1996, NAS reviewed three new studies, all of which found 
    no significant increase in respiratory disease associated with 
    herbicide exposure. (See 61 FR 41448 for study citations.)
        In Update 1998, NAS reviewed evidence from several new occupational 
    and veteran studies (Becher et al., 1996; Svensson et al., 1995; Ott 
    and Zober, 1996; Ramlow et al. 1996; Kogevinas et al., 1997; Bullman 
    TA, Kang HK. 1996. The risk of suicide among wounded Vietnam veterans. 
    American Journal of Public Health 86(5): 662-667; O'Toole et al., 
    1996b; Watanabe and Kang, 1996; Dalager and Kang, 1997; Crane et al., 
    1997a; Crane et al., 1997b; and the ongoing study of Ranch Hand 
    veterans, AFHS, 1996). O'Toole et al., 1996b showed the strongest 
    association between exposure and respiratory disease. Although there 
    was no significant increase in overall respiratory system disease among 
    veterans, hay fever, bronchitis, emphysema, and other respiratory 
    disease were significantly elevated compared to the general population. 
    However, these conditions were not related to an index of combat 
    exposure, and the veterans were more likely to have smoked at some 
    point in their lives than the general population. Although, in general, 
    there were sporadic reports of increased respiratory disease 
    potentially related to exposure to herbicides or dioxin, the results 
    were inconsistent across the studies. In addition, interpretation of 
    individual studies was generally limited by a lack
    
    [[Page 59242]]
    
    of information on cigarette smoking. Accordingly, the Secretary has 
    found that the credible evidence against an association between 
    respiratory disorders (other than certain respiratory cancers) and 
    herbicide exposure outweighs the credible evidence for such an 
    association, and he has determined that a positive association does not 
    exist.
    
    Skin Cancer
    
        In VAO, NAS assigned skin cancer to a category labeled limited/
    suggestive evidence of no association with herbicide exposure. This is 
    defined as meaning that several adequate studies, covering the full 
    range of levels of exposure that humans are known to encounter, are 
    mutually consistent in not showing a positive association between 
    herbicide exposure and the particular health outcome at any level of 
    exposure. There were many credible studies that showed no association 
    or a negative association with herbicide exposure. (See Chapter 8 of 
    VAO.)
        Update 1996 reviewed one new study (Lynge, 1993) that did find an 
    excess risk of skin cancer. However, another new study found no 
    increased risk of skin cancer. Three other new studies were too small 
    to have sufficient statistical power to give definitive results. A 
    mortality study of farmers in 23 states utilizing occupational 
    information from death certificates found an increased PCMR for skin 
    cancer in white male farmers. This study, however, did not correlate 
    the increased PCMR to suspected herbicide exposure and did not control 
    for other confounding factors. NAS felt that these studies, while not 
    providing suggestive evidence of an association with herbicide 
    exposure, undermined the evidence of no association discussed in its 
    first report, and thus warranted changing skin cancer from the 
    ``limited/suggestive evidence of no association'' category to the 
    ``inadequate/insufficient evidence to determine whether an association 
    exists'' category. (See 61 FR 41448 for study citations.)
        In Update 1998, NAS discussed malignant melanoma separately from 
    squamous and basal cell carcinomas because of the different biologic 
    behaviors and risk factors for these cancers.
    
    Melanoma
    
        Two new studies showed a statistically significant increase in 
    melanoma mortality, but the data are not particularly strong. A study 
    of U.S. Marine and Army veterans (Watanabe and Kang, 1996) found an 
    increased risk of skin cancers only among Marine veterans (PMR=1.3, CI 
    1.0-1.6). Army veterans showed no increased risk in comparison to any 
    of the control groups. This study made no distinction between melanoma 
    and other skin cancers. A study of Australian Vietnam veterans (Crane 
    et al., 1997a) showed an increased risk when compared to the Australian 
    population, but no increased risk when the comparison group was non-
    Vietnam veterans (Crane et al., 1997b). None of these studies 
    controlled for exposure to sunlight, the greatest risk-factor for 
    malignant melanoma. A study of Swedish fishermen (Svensson et al., 
    1995) reported no elevated incidence of melanoma and found a decreased 
    risk of death from the disease compared to the general Swedish 
    population. Other new studies and updates of previous studies found 
    either no increased risk or only a slightly elevated increase that was 
    not considered significant (Bertazzi et al., 1997; Kogevinas et al., 
    1997; Hertzmann et al., 1997; Dalager and Kang, 1997; Clapp, 1997). NAS 
    did not feel that the evidence warranted altering its prior 
    determination that there was inadequate or insufficient evidence of an 
    association between exposure to herbicide agents and the subsequent 
    development of malignant melanoma.
    
    Basal Cell and Squamous Cell Carcinomas
    
        The most compelling study reviewed by NAS was a Canadian community 
    case-control study (Gallagher RP, Bajdik CD, Fincham S, Hill GB, Keefe 
    AR, Coldman A, McLean DI, 1996. Chemical exposures, medical history, 
    and risk of squamous and basal cell carcinoma of the skin. Cancer 
    Epidemiology, Biomarkers and Prevention 5(6): 419-424.), which found an 
    increased risk for squamous cell carcinoma, but not basal cell 
    carcinoma, in individuals exposed to herbicides (OR=1.5, CI 1.0-2.3). 
    The risk increased with increasing lifetime exposure. However, neither 
    control for confounders nor assessment of exposure were adequate. 
    Moreover, the findings in this study are in conflict with the earlier 
    findings in the Ranch Hand study (Wolfe WH, Michalek JE, Miner JC, Rahe 
    A, Silva J, Thomas WF, Grubbs WD, Lustik MB, Karrison TG, Roegner RH, 
    Williams DE, 1990. Health status of Air Force veterans occupationally 
    exposed to herbicides in Vietnam. I. Physical health. Journal of the 
    American Medical Association 264: 1824-1831.) of an increased incidence 
    of basal cell carcinoma, but not squamous cell carcinoma. The study of 
    Swedish fishermen (Svensson et al., 1995) showed a statistically 
    significant increase in the incidence of such cancers (RR=2.3, CI 1.4-
    3.5) among the fishermen who ate more of the fish potentially 
    containing higher levels of organochlorine compounds. However, this 
    study provided no measurements of the levels of TCDD or arsenic in 
    either fish or fishermen. Other studies reviewed by NAS generally 
    reported no statistically significant increases of basal cell or 
    squamous cell carcinomas in exposed groups. Again, NAS did not feel 
    that the evidence warranted altering its prior determination that there 
    was inadequate or insufficient evidence of an association between 
    exposure to herbicide agents and the subsequent development of basal 
    cell and squamous cell carcinomas.
        Accordingly, based on all available evidence, the Secretary has 
    found that the credible evidence against an association between these 
    skin cancers (malignant melanoma, basal cell carcinoma, and squamous 
    cell carcinoma) and herbicide exposure outweighs the credible evidence 
    for such an association, and he has determined that a positive 
    association does not exist.
    
    Cognitive and Neuropsychiatric Effects
    
        NAS found in VAO that the studies of cognitive and neuropsychiatric 
    disorders were beset by a number of methodologic problems, including 
    exposure measures, the wide variety of ``standardized'' test 
    instruments used, and the inability to detect or correct for other 
    influences on test results such as emotional state, non-neurologic 
    disease, metabolic conditions, fatigue, medications, or style of the 
    examiner. Because of their failure to adequately control for these 
    confounding factors, those studies lacked credibility in assessing the 
    relationship of herbicide exposure to these conditions.
        Update 1996 reviewed one study that found multiple 
    neuropsychological changes; however, the significance of these findings 
    is uncertain because of the small number of subjects, possible 
    selection bias, the lack of an external control group, and the low 
    estimated amount of exposure. Another study of a large sample of 
    Vietnam veterans found reports of psychological dysfunction correlated 
    with self-reports of combat exposure and level of herbicide exposure. 
    Without confirmation of the subject reports, the significance of these 
    results is in doubt. Because of methodological problems with the 
    preceding studies and two other reviewed studies, there continued to be 
    no credible evidence for an association between herbicide exposure and 
    cognitive disorders or neuropsychiatric
    
    [[Page 59243]]
    
    effects. (See 61 FR 41446 for study citations.)
        In Update 1998, NAS briefly discussed a report from Australia 
    (O'Toole BI, Marshall RP, Grayson DA, Schureck RJ, Dobson M, Ffrench M, 
    Pulvertaft B, Meldrum L, Bolton J, Vennard J. 1996c. The Australian 
    Vietnam Veterans Health Study: III. Psychological health of Australian 
    Vietnam veterans and its relationship to combat. International Journal 
    of Epidemiology 25(2): 331-340.) that analyzed the self-reported 
    psychiatric states of Vietnam veterans as determined 20-25 years after 
    the war. This study found higher prevalences of alcohol abuse or 
    dependence, PTSD, and social and simple phobias among Vietnam veterans 
    than among the civilian population. However, there was no attempt to 
    relate these behavioral disorders to herbicide exposure. NAS stated it 
    was unaware of other new studies that provide any further evidence of 
    an association between herbicide exposure and cognitive or 
    neuropsychiatric disorders. Therefore, based on available evidence, the 
    Secretary continues to find that the credible evidence against an 
    association between cognitive or neuropsychiatric disorders and 
    herbicide exposure outweighs the credible evidence for such an 
    association, and he has determined that a positive association does not 
    exist.
    
    Reproductive Effects in Male Veterans
    
        In Update 1998 NAS, as it had in VAO and Update 1996, reviewed the 
    current literature with respect to possible associations between 
    herbicide exposure and various reproductive effects, i.e., spontaneous 
    abortion, spina bifida and other birth defects, neonatal/infant deaths 
    and stillbirths, low birth weights, and childhood cancer in offspring. 
    NAS continued to find limited/suggestive evidence of an association of 
    spina bifida with exposure to herbicides. For other reproductive 
    outcomes, while the evidence suggests that an association is 
    biologically plausible, various factors complicate reaching more 
    definitive conclusions. (See Chapter 9 of the 1998 NAS report for 
    additional information.)
        Except in the case of spina bifida, compensation of a veteran or a 
    veteran's child for these effects is beyond VA's statutory authority 
    (title 38, United States Code) and would require enabling legislation. 
    In 1996, Sec. 421 of Public Law 104-204, as amended by Sec. 404 of 
    Public Law 105-114, gave VA the authority that the Secretary had 
    requested to provide benefits for spina bifida in the natural children 
    of individuals who had served in Vietnam during the period from January 
    9, 1962, through May 7, 1975. (See 38 U.S.C., Chapter 18.)
    
    Gastrointestinal Tumors and Brain Tumors
    
        In Update 1998 NAS, as it had in VAO and Update 1996, assigned 
    gastrointestinal tumors (stomach cancer, pancreatic cancer, colon 
    cancer, and rectal cancer) and brain tumors to the category labeled 
    limited/suggestive evidence of no association with herbicide exposure. 
    This category is defined as meaning that several adequate studies, 
    covering the full range of levels of exposure that humans are known to 
    encounter, are mutually consistent in not showing a positive 
    association between herbicide exposure and the particular health 
    outcome at any level of exposure. NAS reviewed several new credible 
    studies (see the 1998 NAS report, Chapter 7) concerning all of these 
    conditions that generally showed no association or a negative 
    association with herbicide exposure. One study of workers exposed to 
    TCDD in 1953 at a BASF plant in Germany (Ott and Zober, 1996) did 
    report a statistically significant positive association of both death 
    and incidence of digestive cancer. However, one of the cases of 
    reported digestive cancer was actually primary liver cancer. If this 
    had been classified as hepatobiliary cancer, the reported association 
    probably would have been weaker. Accordingly, on the basis of all 
    evidence available, the Secretary has found that the credible evidence 
    against an association between gastrointestinal tumors (stomach cancer, 
    pancreatic cancer, colon cancer, and rectal cancer) and brain tumors 
    and herbicide exposure outweighs the credible evidence for such an 
    association, and he has determined that a positive association does not 
    exist.
        NAS reviewed scientific and medical articles published since the 
    publication of its first report as an integral part of the process that 
    resulted in ``Veterans and Agent Orange: Update 1998.'' In our 
    judgment, the comprehensive review and evaluation of the available 
    literature which NAS conducted in conjunction with its report has 
    permitted VA to identify all conditions for which the current body of 
    knowledge supports a finding of an association with herbicide exposure. 
    Accordingly, the Secretary has determined that there is no positive 
    association between exposure to herbicides and any other condition for 
    which he has not specifically determined that a presumption of service 
    connection is warranted.
    
        Approved: October 26, 1999.
    Togo D. West, Jr.,
    Secretary of Veterans Affairs.
    [FR Doc. 99-28579 Filed 11-1-99; 8:45 am]
    BILLING CODE 8320-01-P
    
    
    

Document Information

Published:
11/02/1999
Department:
Veterans Affairs Department
Entry Type:
Notice
Action:
Notice.
Document Number:
99-28579
Pages:
59232-59243 (12 pages)
PDF File:
99-28579.pdf