97-11683. Pay Telephone Reclassification and Compensation  

  • [Federal Register Volume 62, Number 87 (Tuesday, May 6, 1997)]
    [Rules and Regulations]
    [Pages 24583-24585]
    From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
    [FR Doc No: 97-11683]
    
    
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
    
    47 CFR Part 64
    
    [CC Docket No. 96-128; DA 97-805]
    
    
    Pay Telephone Reclassification and Compensation
    
    AGENCY: Federal Communications Commission.
    
    ACTION: Final rule; waiver.
    
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    SUMMARY: On April 15, 1997, the Common Carrier Bureau (``Bureau'') 
    granted a limited waiver of the Commission's requirement that effective 
    intrastate tariffs for payphone services be in compliance with federal 
    guidelines, specifically that the tariffs comply with the ``new 
    services'' test, as set forth in the Payphone Reclassification 
    Proceeding, CC Docket No. 96-128 [``Payphone Order'' 61 FR 52307 
    (October 7, 1997); ``Order on Reconsideration'' 61 FR 65341 (December 
    12, 1996)]. Local exchange carriers (``LECs'') must comply with this 
    requirement, among others, before they are eligible to receive the 
    compensation from interexchange carriers (``IXCs'') that is mandated in 
    that proceeding. Because some LEC intrastate tariffs for payphone 
    services are not in full compliance with the Commission's guidelines, 
    the Bureau granted all LECs a limited waiver until May 19, 1997 to file 
    intrastate tariffs for payphone services consistent with the ``new 
    services'' test, pursuant to the federal guidelines established in the 
    Order on Reconsideration, subject to the terms discussed therein.
    
    DATES Effective: April 15, 1997.
    
    FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Michael Carowitz, 202-418-0960, 
    Enforcement Division, Common Carrier Bureau.
    
    SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
    
    Synopsis of Order
    
        1. Upon reviewing the contentions of the Regional Bell Operating 
    Company (``RBOC'') Coalition and the language it cites from the two 
    orders in the Payphone Reclassification Proceeding, the Bureau 
    concluded that while the individual BOCs may not be in full compliance 
    with the intrastate tariffing requirements of the Payphone 
    Reclassification Proceeding, they have made a good faith effort to 
    comply with the requirements. The RBOC Coalition concedes that the 
    Commission's payphone orders, as clarified by the Bureau Waiver Order, 
    mandate that the payphone services a LEC tariffs at the state level are 
    subject to the new services test and that the requisite cost-support 
    data must be submitted to the individual states. In addition, the RBOC 
    Coalition states that it will take whatever action is necessary to 
    comply with the Commission's orders in order to be eligible to receive 
    payphone compensation at the earliest possible date. Therefore, the 
    Bureau adopted an
    
    [[Page 24584]]
    
    order, which contains a limited waiver of the federal guidelines for 
    intrastate tariffs, specifically the requirement that LECs have filed 
    intrastate payphone service tariffs as required by the Order on 
    Reconsideration and the Bureau Waiver Order that satisfy the new 
    services test, and that effective intrastate payphone service tariffs 
    comply with the ``new services'' test of the federal guidelines for the 
    purpose of allowing a LEC to be eligible to receive payphone 
    compensation. The existing intrastate tariffs for payphone services 
    will continue in effect until the intrastate tariffs filed pursuant to 
    the Order on Reconsideration, the Bureau Waiver Order and the instant 
    order become effective. Because other LECs may also have failed to file 
    the intrastate tariffs for payphone services that comply with the ``new 
    services'' test of the federal guidelines, the Bureau applied this 
    limited waiver to all LECs, with the limitations set forth therein.
        2. Consistent with its conclusions above and in the interests of 
    bringing LECs into compliance with the requirements of the Payphone 
    Reclassification Proceeding, the Bureau waived for 45 days from the 
    April 4, 1997 release date of the Bureau Waiver Order the requirement 
    that LEC intrastate tariffs for payphone services comply with the ``new 
    services'' test of the federal guidelines, as set forth in paragraph 
    163 of the Order on Reconsideration and clarified in the Bureau Waiver 
    Order. LECs must file intrastate tariffs for payphone services, as 
    required by the Payphone Reclassification Proceeding consistent with 
    all the requirements set forth in the Order on Reconsideration, within 
    45 days of the April 4, 1997 release date of the Bureau Waiver Order. 
    Any LEC that files these intrastate tariffs for payphone services 
    within 45 days of the release date of the Bureau Waiver Order will be 
    eligible to receive the payphone compensation provided by the Payphone 
    Reclassification Proceeding as of April 15, 1997, as long as that LEC 
    has complied with all of the other requirements set forth in paragraph 
    131 (and paragraph 132 for the Bell Operating Companies) of the Order 
    on Reconsideration, subject to the clarifications and limited waiver in 
    the Bureau Waiver Order. Under the terms of this limited waiver, a LEC 
    must have in place intrastate tariffs for payphone services that are 
    effective by April 15, 1997. The waiver permits the LEC to file 
    intrastate tariffs that are consistent with the ``new services'' test 
    of the federal guidelines set forth in the Order on Reconsideration, as 
    clarified by the Bureau Waiver Order. The existing intrastate payphone 
    service tariffs will continue in effect until the intrastate tariffs 
    filed pursuant to the Bureau's order become effective.
        3. The RBOC Coalition and Ameritech have committed, once the new 
    intrastate tariffs are effective, to reimburse or provide credit to its 
    customers for these payphone services from April 15, 1997, if newly 
    tariffed rates, when effective, are lower than the existing rates. This 
    action will help to mitigate any delay in having in effect intrastate 
    tariffs that comply with the guidelines required by the Order on 
    Reconsideration, including the concern raised by MCI that the subsidies 
    from payphone services will not have been removed before the LECs 
    receive payphone compensation. A LEC who seeks to rely on the waiver 
    granted in the instant Order must also reimburse their customers or 
    provide credit, from April 15, 1997, in situations where the newly 
    tariffed rates are lower than the existing tariffed rates. The Bureau 
    noted, in response to the arguments raised by the IXCs, that its order 
    did not waive the requirement that subsidies be removed from local 
    exchange service and exchange access services, the ``harm'' to the IXCs 
    resulting from the delayed removal of subsidies from some intrastate 
    payphone service tariffs will be limited.
        4. The Bureau concluded that the waiver it granted, which is for a 
    limited duration to address a specific compliance issue, is consistent 
    with, and does not undermine, the rules adopted by the Commission in 
    the Payphone Reclassification Proceeding. Therefore, it rejected the 
    various alternatives to granting a waiver that were suggested by the 
    American Public Communications Council (``APCC'') and the IXCs. More 
    specifically, it concluded that APCC's proposal to require the refiling 
    of all intrastate payphone service tariffs would unduly delay, and 
    possibly undermine, the Commission's efforts to implement Section 276 
    and the congressional goals of ``promot[ing] competition among payphone 
    service providers and promot[ing] the widespread deployment of payphone 
    services to the benefit of the general public. *  *  *''. In response 
    to Sprint's proposal that we delay the effective date of the LECs' 
    interstate carrier common line reductions, the Bureau concluded that 
    the better approach would be to evaluate requests for such treatment by 
    individual LECs on a case-by-case basis. In addition, the Bureau 
    declined to treat the request of the RBOC Coalition as an untimely 
    petition for reconsideration of the Commission's rules, because the 
    RBOC Coalition did not seek reconsideration of the rules adopted in the 
    Payphone Reclassification Proceeding, but instead sought additional 
    time, in a specific, limited circumstance, to comply with those rules.
        5. In response to AT&T's arguments that a LEC must show proof that 
    its intrastate tariffs have removed payphone subsidies consistent with 
    Section 276, the Bureau noted the Commission concluded that ``[t]o 
    receive compensation a LEC must be able to certify'' that it has 
    satisfied each of the individual prerequisites to receiving the 
    compensation mandated by the Payphone Reclassification Proceeding. The 
    Commission did not require that the LECs file such a certification with 
    it. Nothing in the Commission's orders, however, prohibits the IXCs 
    obligated to pay compensation from requiring that their LEC payees 
    provide such a certification for each prerequisite. Such an approach is 
    consistent with the Commission's statement that ``we leave the details 
    associated with the administration of this compensation mechanism to 
    the parties to determine for themselves through mutual agreement.''
        6. Waiver of Commission rules is appropriate only if special 
    circumstances warrant a deviation from the general rule and such 
    deviation serves the public interest. Because the LECs are required to 
    file, and the states are required to review, intrastate tariffs for 
    payphone services consistent with federal guidelines, which, in some 
    cases, may not have been previously filed in this manner at the 
    intrastate level, the Bureau found that special circumstances exist in 
    this case to grant a limited waiver of brief duration to address this 
    responsibility. In addition, it found that its grant of a waiver in 
    this limited circumstance, does not undermine, and is consistent with, 
    the Commission's overall policies in CC Docket No. 96-128 to reclassify 
    LEC payphone assets and ensure fair PSP compensation for all calls 
    originated by payphones. Moreover, the states' review of the intrastate 
    tariffs that are the subject of this limited waiver will enable them to 
    determine whether these tariffs have been filed in accordance with the 
    Commission's rules, including the ``new services'' test. Accordingly, 
    the Bureau granted a limited waiver for 45 days from the April 4, 1997 
    release date of the Bureau Waiver Order the requirement that LEC 
    intrastate tariffs for payphone services comply with the ``new 
    services'' test of the federal guidelines, as set forth in paragraph 
    163 of the Order on Reconsideration. The
    
    [[Page 24585]]
    
    order did not waive any of the other requirements set forth in 
    paragraphs 131-132 of the Order on Reconsideration.
    
    Ordering Clauses
    
        7. Accordingly, it is ordered, pursuant to Sections 4(i,), 5(c), 
    201-205, 276 of the Communications Act of 1934, as amended, 47 U.S.C. 
    154(i), 155(c), 201-205, 276, and Sections 0.91 and 0.291 of the 
    Commission's rules, 47 CFR 0.91 and 0.291, that limited waiver of the 
    Commission's requirements to be eligible to receive the compensation 
    provided by the Payphone Reclassification Proceeding, CC Docket No. 96-
    128, is granted to the extent stated herein.
        8. It is further ordered that this Order shall be effective upon 
    release.
    
    List of Subjects in 47 CFR Part 64
    
        Communications common carriers, Telephone.
    
    Federal Communications Commission.
    William F. Caton,
    Acting Secretary.
    [FR Doc. 97-11683 Filed 5-5-97; 8:45 am]
    BILLING CODE 6712-01-P
    
    
    

Document Information

Published:
05/06/1997
Department:
Federal Communications Commission
Entry Type:
Rule
Action:
Final rule; waiver.
Document Number:
97-11683
Pages:
24583-24585 (3 pages)
Docket Numbers:
CC Docket No. 96-128, DA 97-805
PDF File:
97-11683.pdf
CFR: (1)
47 CFR 64