95-13380. Interstate Rate of Return Represcription and Enforcement Processes  

  • [Federal Register Volume 60, Number 105 (Thursday, June 1, 1995)]
    [Rules and Regulations]
    [Pages 28541-28546]
    From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
    [FR Doc No: 95-13380]
    
    
    
    =======================================================================
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------
    [[Page 28542]]
    
    FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
    
    47 CFR Part 65
    
    [CC Docket No. 92-133; FCC 95-134]
    
    
    Interstate Rate of Return Represcription and Enforcement 
    Processes
    
    AGENCY: Federal Communications Commission.
    
    ACTION: Final rule.
    
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    SUMMARY: The Federal Communications Commission (``Commission'') has 
    adopted a Report and Order (``Order'') that reforms its rules that 
    govern the procedures and methodologies for prescribing and enforcing 
    the rate of return certain Local Exchange Carriers (``LECs'') may earn 
    on interstate access services. First, the Order replaces the existing 
    rule, which calls for the initiation of rate of return represcription 
    proceedings biennially, with a semiautomatic trigger activated by 
    changes in capital costs. Second, the Order modifies the paper hearing 
    rules set out in part 65 to streamline represcription proceedings. 
    Third, the Order simplifies and streamlines the methodologies used to 
    estimate the cost of capital for those LECs still subject to rate of 
    return regulation. Finally, the Order removes the Commission's rule 
    authorizing an automatic refund, with interest, of earnings in excess 
    of ``the maximum allowable rate of return.'' The Commission adopted 
    this Order to streamline the procedures and methodologies of the rate 
    of return represcription and enforcement processes and reduce the 
    burdens these regulations impose on the remaining rate of return LECs, 
    while allowing each the opportunity to maintain its credit and to 
    attract capital. These reforms reflect the Commission's experience in 
    the 1990 Represcription Proceeding,\1\ with incentive (``price cap'') 
    regulation for the largest LECs, and with incentive regulation 
    proposals for those LECs not subject to price cap regulation.
    
        \1\ 5 FCC Rcd 7507 (1990), 55 FR 51423, December 14, 1990.
    
    EFFECTIVE DATE: July 3, 1995, except that Secs. 65.100, 65.101, 65.102, 
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    65.103, 65.104, and 65.105 shall be effective August 30, 1995.
    
    FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
    Thomas J. Beers, telephone number 202-418-0872, John C.K. Hays, 
    telephone number 202-418-0875, or John V. Giusti, telephone number 202-
    418-0878.
    
    SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: This is a summary of the FCC's Report and 
    Order in Amendment of parts 65 and 69 of the Commission's rules to 
    Reform the Interstate Rate of Return Represcription and Enforcement 
    Processes, FCC 95-134, CC Docket No. 92-133, adopted March 30, 1995 and 
    released April 6, 1995. The Commission has made the full text of the 
    Order available for inspection and copying during normal business hours 
    in the Commission's Reference Center, room 239, 1919 M Street, NW, 
    Washington, DC 20554, and will publish it in the FCC Record. The full 
    text of the Order may also be purchased from the Commission's 
    duplicating contractor, International Transcription Service, 2100 M 
    Street, NW, suite 140, Washington, DC 20037, telephone number 202-857-
    3800.
    
    Regulatory Flexibility Analysis
    
        In the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking in this proceeding,\2\ the 
    Commission certified that the Regulatory Flexibility Act of 1980 
    exempts the rules proposed in this proceeding because they will not 
    have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small 
    entities, as defined by section 601(3) of that act.\3\ LECs do not fall 
    within the Regulatory Flexibility Act's definition of a ``small 
    entity,'' which excludes any business that is dominant in its field of 
    operation. In the Competitive Carrier Rulemaking, the Commission found 
    that LECs, even small ones, enjoy a dominant monopoly position in their 
    local service area.\4\ In accordance with section 603(a) of the 
    Regulatory Flexibility Act, the Secretary sent a copy of the Notice, 
    including the certification, to the Chief Counsel for Advocacy of the 
    Small Business Administration.
    
        \2\ Amendment of parts 65 and 69 of the Commission's rules to 
    Reform the Interstate Rate of Return Represcription and Enforcement 
    Processes, Notice of Proposed Rulemaking and Order, 7 FCC Rcd 4688 
    (1992) (Notice), 57 FR 31944, July 20, 1992.
        \3\ 5 U.S.C. 601(3).
        \4\ 85 FCC 2d 1, 23-24 (1980), 45 FR 76148, November 18, 1980.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    Paperwork Reduction
    
        The Commission estimates the public reporting burden for the 
    collections of information to average 100,000 hours per represcription, 
    including the time for reviewing instructions, searching existing data 
    sources, gathering and maintaining the data needed, and completing and 
    reviewing the collections of information. Send comments regarding these 
    burden estimates or any other aspects of the collections of 
    information, including suggestions for reducing the burden, to the 
    Federal Communications Commission, Records Management Branch, Room 234, 
    Washington, DC 20554, and to the Office of Management and Budget, 
    Paperwork Reduction Project, Washington, DC 20503.
    
    Synopsis of the Report and Order
    
        Part 65 of the Commission's rules sets forth procedures and 
    methodologies for prescribing and enforcing the rate of return certain 
    local exchange carriers (``LECs'') may earn on interstate access 
    service.\5\ The Commission adopted those rules in 1985. In the Notice 
    in this proceeding,\6\ the Commission proposed a fundamental reform of 
    those rules in order to reflect the dramatic changes in the 
    telecommunications industry and the regulation of it that had occurred 
    since that time. This Order accomplishes that reform by streamlining 
    the rate of return represcription and enforcement processes in ways 
    that, the Commission believes, will substantially reduce the burden of 
    its regulations on the public and on those LECs still subject to rate 
    of return regulation. The changes achieve a proper balance of 
    regulatory goals by allowing a carrier the opportunity to ``maintain 
    its credit and to attract capital'' \7\ and by ensuring that ratepayers 
    are charged reasonable rates for interstate services.
    
        \5\ 47 CFR part 65.
        \6\ Notice, 7 FCC Rcd 4688 (1992), 57 FR 31994, July 20, 1992.
        \7\ FPC v. Hope Natural Gas, 320 U.S. 591, 603 (1944).
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
        When part 65 was adopted, the Commission used rate of return 
    principles to regulate the rates for the interstate communications 
    services of the American Telephone and Telegraph Company (``AT&T'') and 
    all LECs. Since that time, price cap initiatives have removed all 
    interexchange and most interstate access revenues from such regulation. 
    The Commission has also created optional programs that allow the 
    remaining rate of return LECs to increase their opportunities for 
    increased profit and risks of loss above the levels they would face 
    under traditional, rate of return regulation.
        To reflect the altered environment as well as the Commission's 
    experiences in implementing the part 65 rules, the Order changes 
    virtually every aspect of our rate of return represcription and 
    enforcement processes for telephone companies. First, the Order amends 
    the current rule that contemplates a new represcription proceeding 
    every two years regardless of conditions in the capital markets. The 
    Order replaces that rule with one that relies on the yields
    [[Page 28543]] on ten-year United States Treasury securities to 
    determine when represcription might be warranted. Under this system, 
    the Commission's Common Carrier Bureau will issue a notice asking 
    whether the Commission should institute a represcription proceeding 
    only if, for six consecutive months, the six-month average of those 
    yields deviates by 150 basis points (1.5 percent) or more from the 
    yield on these securities measured as of our most recent 
    represcription. After evaluating the responses to such a notice, the 
    Commission will decide whether a represcription proceeding is necessary 
    and will then issue an order that either sets forth a procedural 
    schedule for the proceeding or announces that a represcription 
    proceeding is not necessary. Thus, the Order adopts a semi-automatic 
    trigger that initiates an inquiry into whether a represcription is 
    needed, rather than a trigger that automatically initiates a costly 
    represcription.
        The current rules also establish a ``paper hearing'' process for 
    represcription proceedings that is modelled after the system used in 
    evidentiary hearings. Because this process contains procedural steps 
    beyond those necessary for a full and complete record, the Order adopts 
    streamlined procedures that will reduce the inordinate delays and costs 
    experienced in previous represcription proceedings, yet provide parties 
    full opportunity to present and evaluate relevant evidence. The Order, 
    therefore, streamlines the paper hearing system by removing unnecessary 
    provisions such as those relating to cross-examination and oral 
    argument options, notices of appearance, proposed findings of fact and 
    conclusions, and use of a separated trail staff. Elimination of these 
    provisions will significantly reduce procedural burden and delays. The 
    Order also adopts the automatic discovery requirement proposed in the 
    Notice in order to achieve further procedural efficiencies by 
    eliminating the need for routine additional discovery.
        Part 65 now uses a weighted average cost of capital to calculate a 
    unitary, overall rate of return for rate of return LECs. This 
    calculation requires the Commission to determine a cost of equity, cost 
    of debt, and capital structure for LEC interstate access service. To 
    help the Commission determine these components, part 65 requires the 
    Regional Bell Holding Companies (``RHCs'') to undertake complex studies 
    and submit the resulting data for inclusion in the record in 
    represcription proceedings. Because the Commission has found in past 
    proceedings the cost of equity studies unnecessary and the cost of debt 
    and capital structure studies unduly complex the Order eliminates the 
    rules that require them. To facilitate the represcription process, 
    however, the Order specifies methods to calculate cost of debt and 
    capital structure that rely on readily available data regarding the 
    largest LECs for presumptive use in future represcription proceedings. 
    Under this approach, the Commission will use the specified 
    methodologies in future represcription proceedings unless the record in 
    those proceedings shows that the methodologies would produce 
    unreasonable results.
        Part 65 had authorized an automatic refund, with interest, of 
    earnings exceeding what the rules refer to as ``the maximum allowable 
    rate of return.'' \8\ In the Automatic Refund Decision,\9\ the United 
    States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit (``D.C. 
    Circuit'') remanded this rule to the Commission. Because we find that 
    our tariff review and complaint processes are sufficient to enforce the 
    prescribed interstate rate of return, we eliminate that rule.
    
        \8\ 47 CFR 65.700
        \9\ AT&T v. FCC, 836 F.2d 1386 (D.C. Cir. 1988) (per curiam) 
    (Automatic Refund Decision).
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
        Part 65 also provides that ``the maximum allowable rate of return'' 
    equals the prescribed rate of return plus a buffer zone. The buffer 
    zones are defined by adding 25 basis points to overall interstate 
    earnings and 40 basis points each to earnings within the common line, 
    traffic sensitive, and special access categories. The Order retains 
    these buffer zones at their present levels. The zones serve an 
    important role in our complaint process by recognizing the effects 
    fluctuations in demand and operating costs may have on rate of return 
    LECs' earnings, while protecting customers from unreasonably high 
    rates. In monitoring compliance, the Order retains a two-year 
    enforcement period in order to provide sufficient time to reduce the 
    risk of targeting error and the risk that carriers will need to make 
    frequent rate changes to remain within the authorized rate of return.
        Accordingly, it is ordered, pursuant to sections 1, 4(i), 4(j), 
    201-205, 218-220, and 403 of the Communications Act of 1934, as 
    amended, 47 U.S.C. 151, 154(i), 154(j), 201-205, 218-220, 403, that 
    part 65 of the Commission's rules, 47 CFR part 65, is amended, as 
    specified below.
    
    List of Subjects in 47 CFR Part 65
    
        Telephone.
    
    Federal Communications Commission.
    William F. Caton,
    Acting Secretary.
    
    Rule Amendments
    
        Part 65 of title 47 of the CFR is amended as follows:
        Parts 65 of the Commission's rules and regulations, 47 CFR part 65, 
    is amended as follows:
    
    PART 65--INTERSTATE RATE OF RETURN PRESCRIPTION PROCEDURES AND 
    METHODOLOGIES
    
        1. The authority citation for part 65 is revised to read as 
    follows:
    
        Authority: Secs. 4, 201, 202, 203, 205, 218, 403, 48 Stat., 
    1066, 1072, 1077, 1094, as amended, 47 U.S.C. 151, 154, 201, 202, 
    203, 204, 205, 218, 219, 220, 403.
    
        2. Section 65.1 is revised to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.1  Application of part 65.
    
        (a) This part establishes procedures and methodologies for 
    Commission prescription of an authorized unitary interstate exchange 
    access rate of return and individual rates of return for the interstate 
    exchange access rates of certain carriers pursuant to Sec. 65.102. This 
    part shall apply to those interstate services of local exchange 
    carriers as the Commission shall designate by rule or order, except 
    that all local exchange carriers shall provide to the Commission that 
    information which the Commission requests for purposes of conducting 
    prescription proceedings pursuant to this part.
        (b) Local exchange carriers subject to Secs. 61.41 through 61.49 of 
    this chapter are exempt from the requirements of this part with the 
    following exceptions:
        (1) Except as otherwise required by Commission order, carriers 
    subject to Secs. 61.41 through 61.49 of this chapter shall employ the 
    rate of return value calculated for interstate access services in 
    complying with any applicable rules under parts 36 and 69 that require 
    a return component;
        (2) Carriers subject to Sec. Sec. 61.41 through 61.49 of this 
    chapter shall be subject to Sec. 65.600(d);
        (3) Carriers subject to Secs. 61.41 through 61.49 of this chapter 
    shall continue to comply with the prescribed rate of return when 
    offering any services specified in Sec. 61.42(f) of this chapter unless 
    the Commission otherwise directs; and
        (4) Carriers subject to Sec. Sec. 61.41 through 61.49 of this 
    chapter shall comply with Commission information requests made pursuant 
    to Sec. 65.1(a).
        3. Sections 65.100 is revised to read as follows: [[Page 28544]] 
    
    
    Sec. 65.100  Participation and acceptance of service designation.
    
        (a) All interstate exchange access carriers, their customers, and 
    any member of the public may participate in rate of return proceedings 
    to determine the authorized unitary interstate exchange access or 
    individual interstate exchange access rates of return authorized 
    pursuant to Sec. 65.102.
        (b) Participants shall state in their initial pleading in a 
    prescription proceeding whether they wish to receive service of 
    documents and other material filed in the proceeding. Participants that 
    wish to receive service by hand on the filing dates when so required by 
    this Part 65 shall specify in their initial pleading in a prescription 
    proceeding, as specified in Secs. 65.103 (b) and (c), an agent for 
    acceptance of service by hand in the District of Columbia. The 
    participant may elect in its pleading to receive service by mail or 
    upon an agent at another location. When such an election is made, other 
    participants need not complete service on the filing date, and requests 
    for extension of time due to delays in completion of service will not 
    be entertained.
        4. Section 65.101 is revised to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.101  Initiation of unitary rate of return prescription 
    proceedings.
    
        (a) Whenever the Commission determines that the monthly average 
    yields on ten (10) year United States Treasury securities remain, for a 
    consecutive six (6) month period, at least 150 basis points above or 
    below the average of the monthly average yields in effect for the 
    consecutive six (6) month period immediately prior to the effective 
    date of the current prescription, the Commission shall issue a notice 
    inquiring whether a rate of return prescription according to this part 
    should commence. This notice shall state:
        (1) The deadlines for filing initial and reply comments regarding 
    the notice;
        (2) The cost of debt, cost of preferred stock, and capital 
    structure computed in accordance with Secs. 65.302, 65.303, and 65.304; 
    and
        (3) such other information as the Commission may deem proper.
        (b) Based on the information submitted in response to the notice 
    described in Sec. 65.101(a), and on any other information specifically 
    identified, the Commission may issue a notice initiating a prescription 
    proceeding pursuant to this part.
        (c) The Chief, Common Carrier Bureau, may issue the notice 
    described in Sec. 65.101(a).
        5. Section 65.102 is revised to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.102  Petitions for exclusion from unitary treatment and for 
    individual treatment in determining authorized return for interstate 
    exchange access service.
    
        (a) Exclusion from unitary treatment will be granted for a period 
    of two years if the cost of capital for interstate exchange service is 
    so low as to be confiscatory because it is outside the zone of 
    reasonableness for the individual carrier's required rate of return for 
    interstate exchange access services.
        (b) A petition for exclusion from unitary treatment and for 
    individual treatment must plead with particularity the exceptional 
    facts and circumstances that justify individual treatment. The showing 
    shall include a demonstration that the exceptional facts and 
    circumstances are not of transitory effect, such that exclusion for a 
    period of a least two years is justified.
        (c) A petition for exclusion from unitary treatment and for 
    individual treatment may be filed at any time. When a petition is filed 
    at a time other than that specified in Sec. 65.103(b)(2), the 
    petitioner must provide compelling evidence that its need for 
    individual treatment is not simply the result of short-term 
    fluctuations in the cost of capital or similar events.
        6. Section 65.103 is revised to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.103  Procedures for filing rate of return submissions.
    
        (a) Rate of return submissions listed in Sec. 65.103(b)(1) and (c) 
    may include any relevant information, subject to the page limitations 
    of Sec. 65.104. The Chief, Common Carrier Bureau, may require from 
    carriers providing interstate services, and from other participants 
    submitting rate of return submissions, data, studies or other 
    information that are reasonably calculated to lead to a full and fair 
    record.
        (b) In proceedings to prescribe an authorized unitary rate of 
    return on interstate access services, interested parties may file 
    direct case submissions, responses, and rebuttals. Direct case 
    submissions shall be filed within sixty (60) calendar days following 
    the effective date of a Commission notice initiating a rate of return 
    proceeding pursuant to Sec. 65.101b). Rate of return submissions 
    responsive to the direct case submissions shall be filed within sixty 
    (60) calendar days after the deadline for filing direct case 
    submissions. Rebuttal submissions shall be field within twenty-one (21) 
    calendar days after the deadline for filing responsive submissions.
        (c) Petitions for exclusion from unitary treatment and for 
    individual treatment may be filed on the same date as the deadline for 
    filing responsive rate of return submissions. Oppositions shall be 
    filed within 35 calendar days thereafter. Rebuttal submissions shall be 
    filed within 21 calendar days after the deadline for filing responsive 
    submissions.
        (d) An original and 4 copies of all rate of return submissions 
    shall be filed with the Secretary.
        (e) The filing party shall serve a copy of each rate of return 
    submission, other than an initial submission, on all participants who 
    have filed a designation of service notice pursuant to Sec. 65.100(b).
        7. Section 65.104 is revised to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.104  Page limitations for rate of return submissions.
    
        Rate of return submissions, including all argument, attachments, 
    appendices, supplements, and supporting materials, such as testimony, 
    data and documents, but excluding tables of contents and summaries of 
    argument, shall be subject to the following double spaced typewritten 
    page limits:
        (a) The direct case submission of any participant shall not exceed 
    70 pages in length.
        (b) The responsive submission of any participant shall not exceed 
    70 pages in length.
        (c) The rebuttal submission of any participant shall not exceed 50 
    pages in length.
        (d) Petitions for exclusion from unitary treatment shall not exceed 
    70 pages in length. Oppositions to petitions for exclusion shall not 
    exceed 50 pages in length. Rebuttals shall not exceed 35 pages in 
    length.
        8. Section 65.105 is revised to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.105  Discovery.
    
        (a) Participants shall file with each rate of return submission 
    copies of all information, including studies, financial analysts' 
    reports, and any other documents relied upon by participants or their 
    experts in the preparation of their submission. Information filed 
    pursuant to this paragraph for which protection from disclosure is 
    sought shall be filed subject to protective orders which shall be duly 
    granted by the Chief, Common Carrier Bureau, for good cause shown.
        (b) Participants may file written interrogatories and requests for 
    documents directed to any rate of return submission and not otherwise 
    filed pursuant to Sec. 65.105(a). The permissible [[Page 28545]] scope 
    of examination is that participants may be examined upon any matter, 
    not privileged, that will demonstrably lead to the production of 
    material, relevant, decisionally significant evidence.
        (c) Discovery requests pursuant to Sec. 65.105(b), including 
    written interrogatories, shall be filed within 14 calendar days after 
    the filing of the rate of return submission to which the request is 
    directed. Discovery requests that are not opposed shall be complied 
    with within 14 calendar days of the request date.
        (d) Oppositions to discovery requests made pursuant to 
    Sec. 65.105(b), including written interrogatories, shall be filed 
    within 7 calendar days after requests are filed. The Chief, Common 
    Carrier Bureau, shall rule upon any such opposition. Except as stayed 
    by the Commission or a Court, any required response to a discovery 
    request that is opposed shall be provided within 14 calendar days after 
    release of the ruling of the Chief, Common Carrier Bureau.
        (e) An original and 4 copies of all information described in 
    Sec. 65.105(a) and all requests, oppositions, and responses made 
    pursuant to Secs. 65.105 (a), (b) and (d) shall be filed with the 
    Secretary.
        (f) Service of requests, oppositions, and responses made pursuant 
    to Secs. 65.105 (b), and (d) shall be made upon all participants who 
    have filed a designation of service notice pursuant to Sec. 65.100(b). 
    Service of requests upon participants who have filed designation of 
    service notices pursuant to Sec. 65.100(b) shall be made by hand on the 
    filing dates thereof.
    
    
    Sec. 65.106  [Removed]
    
        9. Section 65.106 is removed.
    
    
    Secs. 65.200, 65.201, 65.400 and 65.510  [Removed]
    
        10. Sections 65.200, 65.201, 65.400 and 65.510 are removed.
        11. Section 65.300 is revised to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.300  Calculations of the components and weights of the cost of 
    capital.
    
        (a) Sections 65.301 through 65.303 specify the calculations that 
    are to be performed in computing cost of debt, cost of preferred stock, 
    and financial structure weights for prescription proceedings. The 
    calculations shall determine, where applicable, a composite cost of 
    debt, a composite cost of preferred stock, and a composite financial 
    structure for all local exchange carriers with annual revenues in 
    excess of $100 million. The calculations shall be based on data 
    reported to the Commission in FCC Report 43-02. (See 47 CFR 43.21). The 
    results of the calculations shall be used in the represcription 
    proceeding to which they relate unless the record in that proceeding 
    shows that their use would be unreasonable.
        (b) Excluded from cost of capital calculations made pursuant to 
    Sec. 65.300 shall be those sources of financing that are not investor 
    supplied, or that are otherwise subtracted from a carrier's rate base 
    pursuant to Commission orders governing the calculation of net rate 
    base amounts in tariff filings that are made pursuant to section 203 of 
    the Communications Act of 1934, 47 U.S.C. 203, or that were treated as 
    ``zero cost'' sources of financing in section 450 and subpart G of this 
    Part 65. Specifically excluded are: accounts payable, accrued taxes, 
    accrued interest, dividends payable, deferred credits and operating 
    reserves, deferred taxes and deferred tax credits.
        12. Section 65.301 is revised to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.301  Cost of equity.
    
        The cost of equity shall be determined in represcription 
    proceedings after giving full consideration to the evidence in the 
    record, including such evidence as the Commission may officially 
    notice.
        13. Section 65.302 is revised to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.302  Cost of debt.
    
        The formula for determining the cost of debt is equal to:
    [GRAPHIC][TIFF OMITTED]TR01JN95.000
    
    
    Where:
        ``Total Annual Interest Expense'' is the total interest expense for 
    the most recent two years for all local exchange carriers with annual 
    revenues of $100 million or more.
        ``Average Outstanding Debt'' is the average of the total debt for 
    the most recent two years for all local exchange carriers with annual 
    revenues of $100 million or more.
        14. Section 65.303 is revised to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.303  Cost of preferred stock.
        The formula for determining the cost of preferred stock is:
    [GRAPHIC][TIFF OMITTED]TR01JN95.001
    
    
    Where:
        ``Total Annual Preferred Dividends'' is the total dividends on 
    preferred stock for the most recent two years for all local exchange 
    carriers with annual revenues of $100 million or more. ``Proceeds from 
    the Issuance of Preferred Stock'' is the average of the total net 
    proceeds from the issuance of preferred stock for the most recent two 
    years for all local exchange carriers with annual revenues of $100 
    million or more.
        15. Section 65.304 is revised to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.304  Capital structure.
    
        The proportion of each cost of capital component in the capital 
    structure is equal to:
        Proportion in the capital structure =
    [GRAPHIC][TIFF OMITTED]TR01JN95.002
    
    
    
    [[Page 28546]]
    
    Where:
        ``Book Value of particular component'' is the total of the book 
    values of that component for all local exchange carriers with annual 
    revenues of $100 million or more.
        ``Book Value of Debt+Book Value of Preferred Stock+Book Value of 
    Equity'' is the total of the book values of all the components for all 
    local exchange carriers with annual revenues of $100 million or more.
        The total of all proportions shall equal 1.00.
        15. A new Sec. 65.305 is added to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.305  Calculation of the weighted average cost of capital.
    
        (a) The composite weighted average cost of capital is the sum of 
    the cost of debt, the cost of preferred stock, and the cost of equity, 
    each weighted by its proportion in the capital structure of the 
    telephone companies.
        (b) Unless the Commission determines to the contrary in a 
    prescription proceeding, the composite weighted average cost of debt 
    and cost of preferred stock is the composite weight computed in 
    accordance with Sec. 65.304 multiplied by the composite cost of the 
    component computed in accordance with Sec. 65.301 or Sec. 65.302, as 
    applicable. The composite weighted average cost of equity will be 
    determined in each prescription proceeding.
        16. A new Sec. 65.306 is added to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.306  Calculation accuracy.
    
        In a prescription proceeding, the final determinations of the cost 
    of equity, cost of debt, cost of preferred stock and their capital 
    structure weights shall be accurate to two decimal places.
        17. Section 65.500 is revised to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.500  Net income.
    
        The net income methodology specified in Sec. 65.450 shall be 
    utilized by all interexchange carriers that are so designated by 
    Commission order.
        18. Section 65.600(b) is revised to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.600  Rate of return reports.
    
    * * * * *
        (b) Each local exchange carrier or group of affiliated carriers 
    which is not subject to Secs. 61.41 through 61.49 of this chapter and 
    which has filed individual access tariffs during the preceding 
    enforcement period shall file with the Commission, within three (3) 
    months after the end of each calendar quarter, a quarterly rate of 
    return monitoring report. Each report shall contain two parts. The 
    first part shall contain rate of return information on a cumulative 
    basis from the start of the enforcement period through the end of the 
    quarter being reported. The second part shall contain similar 
    information for the most recent quarter. The final quarterly monitoring 
    report for the entire enforcement period shall be considered the 
    enforcement period report. Reports shall be filed on the appropriate 
    report form prescribed by the Commission (see Sec. 1.795 of this 
    chapter) and shall provide full and specific answers to all questions 
    propounded and information requested in the currently effective report 
    form. The number of copies to be filed shall be specified in the 
    applicable report form. At least one copy of the report shall be signed 
    on the signature page by the responsible officer. A copy of each report 
    shall be retained in the principal office of the respondent and shall 
    be filed in such manner as to be readily available for reference and 
    inspection. Final adjustments to the enforcement period shall be made 
    by September 30 of the year following the enforcement period to ensure 
    that any refunds can be properly reflected in an annual access filing.
    * * * * *
    
    
    Sec. 65.700  [Amended]
    
        19. In Sec. 65.700, paragraph (c) is removed and paragraph (d) is 
    redesignated as paragraph (c).
        20. Section 65.701 is revised to read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 65.701  Period of review.
    
        For both exchange and interexchange carriers subject to this part, 
    interstate earnings shall be measured over a two year period to 
    determine compliance with the maximum allowable rate of return. The 
    review periods shall commence on January 1 in odd-numbered years and 
    shall end on December 31 in even-numbered years.
    
    
    Sec. 65.702  [Amended]
    
        21. In Sec. 65.702, paragraph (a) is removed and paragraphs (b) and 
    (c) are redesignated as (a) and (b) respectively.
    
    
    Sec. 65.703  [Removed]
    
        Section 65.703 is removed.
    
    [FR Doc. 95-13380 Filed 5-31-95; 8:45 am]
    BILLING CODE 6712-01-M
    
    

Document Information

Published:
06/01/1995
Department:
Federal Communications Commission
Entry Type:
Rule
Action:
Final rule.
Document Number:
95-13380
Dates:
July 3, 1995, except that Secs. 65.100, 65.101, 65.102,
Pages:
28541-28546 (6 pages)
Docket Numbers:
CC Docket No. 92-133, FCC 95-134
PDF File:
95-13380.pdf
CFR: (23)
47 CFR 65.105(a)
47 CFR 65.105(b)
47 CFR 65.1
47 CFR 65.100
47 CFR 65.101
More ...