94-20842. Rail General Exemption AuthorityExemption of Non-Ferrous Recyclables and Railroad Rates on Recyclable Commodities

  • [Federal Register Volume 59, Number 163 (Wednesday, August 24, 1994)]
    [Unknown Section]
    [Page 0]
    From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
    [FR Doc No: 94-20842]
    
    
    [[Page Unknown]]
    
    [Federal Register: August 24, 1994]
    
    
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    
    INTERSTATE COMMERCE COMMISSION
    49 CFR Parts 1039 and 1145
    
    [Ex Parte No. 346 (Sub-No. 36)]
    
     
    
    Rail General Exemption Authority--Exemption of Non-Ferrous 
    Recyclables and Railroad Rates on Recyclable Commodities
    
    AGENCY: Interstate Commerce Commission.
    
    ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking.
    
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    SUMMARY: The Commission is considering whether to exempt partially from 
    regulation the rail transportation of non-ferrous recyclables set forth 
    in the Appendix. If these commodities are exempted, they will be added 
    to the list of exempt commodities in the Commission's regulations as 
    set forth below, and the exemption will be subject to the conditions 
    and limitations provided therein.
    
    DATES: Comments are due on September 23, 1994.
    
    ADDRESSES: Participants must send an original and 10 copies of their 
    statement referring to Ex Parte No. 346 (Sub-No. 36) to: Office of the 
    Secretary, Case Control Branch, Interstate Commerce Commission, 
    Washington, DC 20423.
    
    FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Beryl Gordon, (202) 927-5610. [TDD for 
    hearing impaired: (202) 927-5721.]
    
    SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The Association of American Railroads (AAR), 
    numerous member railroads in their individual capacities,1 and the 
    Institute of Scrap Recycling Industries, Inc. (ISRI) (collectively, 
    petitioners) have petitioned the Commission to institute a proceeding 
    to consider the partial exemption from regulation under 49 U.S.C. 10505 
    of the rail transportation of 28 non-ferrous recyclable 
    commodities.2 The proposed exemption would be effected by: (a) 
    Adding the non-ferrous recyclables listed below to the list of exempt 
    commodities set forth at 49 CFR 1039.11(a), (b) adding conforming 
    language at the beginning of the list in paragraph (a),3 and (c) 
    modifying 49 CFR 1039.14(b)(5), as set forth below.4 The proposed 
    exemption would apply to all rail carriers nationwide, and would 
    encompass all provisions of Subtitle IV of Title 49 of the United 
    States Code, subject to the exceptions set forth in 49 CFR 1039.11, 
    except the provisions of 49 U.S.C. 10731(e) relating to maximum rates.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
        \1\These railroads are: Burlington Northern Railroad Co., 
    Chicago and North Western Railway Company, Consolidated Rail Corp., 
    CSX Transportation, Inc., Norfolk Southern Railway Co., The 
    Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railway Company, Soo Line, Inc., 
    Southern Pacific Transportation Co., and Union Pacific Railroad Co.
        \2\Accompanying the proposal are supporting verified statements 
    from AAR, AAR member railroad Consolidated Rail Corp., and ISRI.
        \3\We are not entirely clear on where petitioners intend for 
    this conforming language to be inserted. Petitioners should clarify 
    this matter.
        \4\The Commission previously determined that exemptions for non-
    ferrous recyclables can best be effected by amending 49 CFR 1145.9, 
    rather than 49 CFR 1039. Exempt. from Regulation--Rail Transp. of 
    Scrap Paper, 9 I.C.C.2d 957, 964 (1993). Petitioners propose 
    completely revising 49 CFR part 1145 and instead identifying the 
    exempted commodities in 49 CFR 1039.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
        In addition, on the theory that the existing regulations are not 
    compatible with a market-driven transportation system, AAR and ISRI 
    have petitioned the Commission for consideration of substantial 
    amendments to 49 CFR part 1145, Railroad Rates on Recyclable 
    Commodities, as set forth below.5 Thus, petitioners seek exemption 
    from regulation, other than maximum rate regulation (and the 
    limitations at 49 CFR 1039.11(a)), for the rail transportation of non-
    ferrous recyclables, and the substitution of the new maximum rate 
    regulations they propose for the existing regulations. As discussed 
    below, although there is some opposition to this proposal, we are 
    instituting this rulemaking in order to obtain additional information 
    and public comment.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
        \5\Petitioners do not propose amending or deleting the reference 
    in 49 CFR 1039.11(a) to 49 CFR 1145.9. Such action, if the rules 
    were adopted, would appear necessary.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    Proponents' Views
    
        Section 10505 requires us to grant an exemption when we find that: 
    (1) Regulation is not necessary to carry out the national rail 
    transportation policy of 49 U.S.C. 10101a (NRTP); and (2) either (a) 
    the transaction or service is of limited scope, or (b) regulation is 
    not needed to protect shippers from an abuse of market power. 
    Petitioners assert that their proposal meets these criteria.
        Petitioners propose the subject commodities for exemption for the 
    following reasons:
        (1) Continued regulation of these commodities is not necessary to 
    carry out the NRTP at 49 U.S.C. 10101a. According to petitioners, 
    although the transportation of this traffic is highly competitive, an 
    exemption would further increase competition for this traffic and 
    promote numerous NRTP goals, such as (a) increased competition for the 
    traffic, (b) safe and efficient transportation, (c) reduced 
    administrative burdens for both rail carriers and shippers, and (d) 
    increased ratemaking flexibility and financial stability for rail 
    carriers (including, by eliminating tariff and contract filing 
    requirements, the ability to respond more quickly to market changes and 
    shipper demand for resulting rates and services). Current competition 
    is reflected in statistics on rates and revenue from rail 
    transportation of non-ferrous recyclables.6
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
        \6\AAR reports that, from 1981 to 1991, real revenue per car for 
    transportation of non-ferrous recyclables declined 42%. AAR adds 
    that rail market share in 1991 for each non-ferrous recyclable 
    commodity was 25% or less of the market total.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
        (2) The involved rail transportation is limited in scope. The 
    transportation of non-ferrous recyclables is a small percentage of 
    total rail transportation, and shippers have access to alternative 
    transportation modes. Moreover, the proposed exemption would not 
    relieve carriers of their obligations under 49 U.S.C. 10731(e).
        (3) This traffic is generally competitive, subject to intermodal, 
    intramodal, and geographic competition, making regulation unnecessary 
    to protect shippers from market power abuse. Moreover, shippers would 
    continue to have the protection of the mandatory rate cap under 49 
    U.S.C. 10731(e).
        Regarding the proposed amendments to 49 CFR part 1145, petitioners 
    state that the proposed streamlined procedure is designed ``to assure 
    that rate adjustments do not exceed applicable aggregate maximum rate 
    ratios,'' and ``to simplify the implementation of the [rate] cap and to 
    be compatible with an environment in which carriers must change rates 
    frequently in response to changing market conditions.'' Petition at 14. 
    Petitioners further assert that, ``By agreeing not to request the even 
    greater flexibility of complete deregulation, AAR and ISRI have removed 
    the need for the Commission to make a finding with respect to whether 
    continued regulation of maximum rates is necessary for all non-ferrous 
    recyclable issues.'' Id. at 15 (note omitted).
        According to petitioners, the new maximum rate regulations they 
    propose ``are designed to be self-policing thus permitting the shipper 
    and railroad to work out adjustments without Commission intervention.'' 
    Id. at 20. Parties may ask the Commission to resolve a dispute only if 
    the shipper and railroad are unable to agree on the relief to be 
    provided under the regulations. Id.
    
    Opposition to Petition
    
        Huron Valley Steel Corporation (Huron)7 and Star Recycling, 
    Inc. (Star) have filed in opposition to petitioners' proposal. They 
    argue that the Commission should dismiss the petition because the 
    proposal would preclude the Commission from fulfilling its statutory 
    mandate with respect to recyclables rate levels, and therefore would 
    violate 49 U.S.C. 10731(e). We withhold our final determination with 
    respect to their requests for dismissal, and elect to treat their 
    pleadings as opposition to AAR and ISRI's petition, and invite comment 
    on Huron and Star's contentions.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
        \7\Huron is a member of ISRI, but previously advised ISRI that 
    it opposes the petition and that ISRI was not to file the petition 
    on its behalf.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
        Huron and Star reason that the Commission has no statutory 
    authority to grant petitioners' proposed exemption. They argue that 
    Congress singled out recyclable or recycled materials other than iron 
    or steel as a specific exemption from the general deregulatory and 
    procompetitive purposes of the Staggers Rail Act of 1980,8 and 
    that the Commission's mandate is not limited or preempted by the 
    Commission's exemption authority at 49 U.S.C. 10505.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
        \8\Pub. L. No. 96-448, 94 Stat. 1905 (1980). Section 204 of the 
    Act, codified at 49 U.S.C. 10731(e), specifically addressed 
    recyclables.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
        Star contends that the proposal ``would devastate the ability of 
    shippers of recyclables to obtain adequate and efficient rail 
    transportation services'' by permitting rail carriers ``to refuse to 
    provide a level service meeting shippers' needs (or any service at 
    all), absent the shippers' agreement to transportation contracts that 
    would then be outside the Commission's rate jurisdiction, and would 
    therefore render any controls over rate levels illusory.'' Star motion 
    at 3. Huron asserts that the partial exemption being sought fails to 
    meet the criteria of 49 U.S.C. 10505.
        In addition, Star contends that the ``streamlined'' rate procedures 
    proposed to be substituted at 49 CFR part 1145 also would undermine the 
    Commission's carefully established balance ``between avoidance of 
    regulatory burden on the carriers and effective supervision of 
    recyclables rate levels.'' Star motion at 2. Huron argues that the 
    proposed rules ``would be both cumbersome and costly''; that they would 
    constitute ``an impermissible delegation of the ICC's public duties to 
    private groups''; and that they would contravene the law by permitting 
    the railroads to charge rates that are 10 percent above the statutory 
    cap. Huron reply at 33, 41.
        We invite comments and data concerning the proposal and its 
    opposition. Although we believe that the approach suggested by the 
    railroads and ISRI may have merit, publication of this notice, along 
    with the rules as proposed by AAR and ISRI, is not intended to suggest 
    a predisposition regarding the rules at this time. The proposal makes 
    substantial changes to a set of rules that were recently adopted by the 
    Commission at the suggestion of a coalition of shipper and carrier 
    interests by, for example, providing a 10 percent rate cushion and 
    eliminating the prejustification requirement for above-the-cap rate 
    groups. Proponents should show how the new system will benefit shippers 
    and carriers and will otherwise advance the objectives of the NRTP. 
    Proponents should also explain in some detail how the new rules will 
    work in practice.9
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
        \9\For example, proponents may wish to address in depth 
    operational questions such as how an ``average rate'' is to be 
    ``frozen,'' and how the rules are designed to work with regard to 
    proportional rates and combinations of local rates.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
        The opponents of the proposal have focused largely on our statutory 
    authority to issue a partial exemption in light of the specific 
    statutory language regarding recyclables. Although we welcome 
    additional comments on our statutory authority to adopt the exemption, 
    commentors objecting to the proposal should, in addition, point out in 
    practical terms why, in their view, the proposal will be unfair to 
    them, or otherwise will not achieve its stated objective. Commentors 
    may also address the appropriateness of the proposed exemption for any 
    of these commodities on an individual basis.
    
    Environmental and Energy Considerations
    
        We preliminarily conclude that, if an exemption is granted, it will 
    not significantly affect either the quality of the human environment or 
    the conservation of energy resources. We invite comments in this area.
    
    Initial Regulatory Flexibility Analysis
    
        Pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 605(b), we preliminarily conclude that an 
    exemption would not have a significant economic impact on a substantial 
    number of small entities. No new regulatory requirements would be 
    imposed, directly or indirectly, on such entities. The impact, if any, 
    would be to reduce the amount of paperwork, tariff filing, and related 
    activities. If an exemption were granted, it would be based on a 
    finding that (a) the transportation at issue is of limited scope, and/
    or (b) regulation of this transportation is not necessary to protect 
    shippers (including small shippers) from abuse of market power. See 49 
    U.S.C. 10505(a). Such findings, if made, would indicate that a 
    substantial number of small entities would not be significantly 
    affected. We invite comments in this area.
    
    List of Subjects
    
    49 CFR Part 1039
    
        Agricultural commodities, Intermodal transportation, Manufactured 
    commodities, Railroads.
    
    49 CFR part 1145
    
        Railroads, Rates, Recyclable commodities.
    
        Decided: August 16, 1994.
    
        By the Commission, Chairman McDonald, Vice Chairman Phillips, 
    Commissioner Morgan. Commissioner Simmons dissented in part with a 
    separate expression.
    Vernon A. Williams,
    Acting Secretary.
    
                             Non-Ferrous Recyclables                        
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
        STCC                         Commodity description                  
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
    2051118......  Bakery waste or sweeping: feed.                          
    22941........  Textile waste: garnetted, processed, or recovered.       
    22973........  Textile fibres, noils, nubs for spinning.                
    22994........  Packing cloths or rags: processed textile wastes.        
    24293........  Shaving or sawdust.                                      
    30311........  Declaimed rubber.                                        
    3229924......  Cullet (broken glass).                                   
    33312........  Copper matte, flue dust, or residues: skimmings,         
                    tailings, scale.                                        
    33322........  Lead matte, flue dust, slag skimmings, etc.              
    33332........  Zinc dross, residue, ashes, skimmings.                   
    33342........  Aluminum residue: ashes, skimmings, slag, smelting       
                    residues.                                               
    33398........  Misc. non-ferrous residue, inc. solder skimmings, type   
                    metal dross, tin, nickel dross.                         
    40112........  Ashes: fly ash, coal cinders, photo silver ash,          
                    incinerator ash, metal bearing.                         
    40212........  Brass, bronze, copper, or alloy scrap, tailings, or      
                    wastes.                                                 
    40213........  Lead, zinc, or alloy scrap: lead borings, zinc castings. 
    40214........  Aluminum scrap: borings, grindings, turnings, foil scrap.
    4021960......  Tin scrap: metallic tin, clippings, drippings, shavings, 
                    for remelting.                                          
    40221........  Textile waste: waste cotton, rope, rags, nec.            
    40231........  Wood scrap: woodpulp waste, spent wood, waste bark.      
    40251........  Chemical or petroleum waste: spent acid, lubricating     
                    grease, waste oil.                                      
    40261........  Rubber or plastic scrap, clippings or trimmings.         
    4029114......  Municipal garbage waste, solid, digested and ground.     
    4029176......  Auto shredder residue.                                   
    4111434......  Bags, old: Burlap, gunny, jute, or nec.                  
    4111580......  Old bags for conversion into bale coverings.             
    42111........  Non-revenue mvmt. of containers moving in reverse of     
                    loaded direction.                                       
    42112........  Non-revenue mvmt. of shipping devices moving in reverse  
                    of loaded direction.                                    
    42311........  Revenue mvmt. of containers moving in reverse of loaded  
                    direction.                                              
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
        For the reasons set forth in the preamble, title 49, chapter X, 
    parts 1039 and 1145 of the Code of Federal Regulations are proposed to 
    be amended as follows:
    
    PART 1039--EXEMPTIONS
    
        1. The authority citation for part 1039 would continue to read as 
    follows:
    
        Authority: 49 U.S.C. 10321 and 10505; and 5 U.S.C. 553.
    
        2. In section 1039.11, paragraph (a) is proposed to be amended by 
    adding the following sentence at the end of the text preceding the 
    table and by adding the following entries at the end of the table to 
    read as follows:
    
    
    Sec. 1039.11  Miscellaneous commodities exemptions.
    
        (a) * * * The following commodities are exempted from all 
    regulation except maximum rate regulation pursuant to 49 U.S.C. 
    10731(e), subject to the exceptions set forth in this section unless 
    otherwise exempted from maximum rate regulation. 
    
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
        STCC No.                STCC tariff                   Commodity     
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                                                            
                                  * * * * * * *                             
    2051118.........  6001-V, eff. 1-1-94.............  Bakery waste or     
                                                         sweeping: feed.    
    22941...........  ......do........................  Textile waste:      
                                                         garnetted,         
                                                         processed, or      
                                                         recovered.         
    22973...........  ......do........................  Textile fibres,     
                                                         noils, nubs for    
                                                         spinning.          
    22994...........  ......do........................  Packing cloths or   
                                                         rags: processed    
                                                         textile wastes.    
    24293...........  ......do........................  Shaving or sawdust. 
    30311...........  ......do........................  Reclaimed rubber.   
    3229924.........  ......do........................  Cullet (broken      
                                                         glass).            
    33312...........  ......do........................  Copper matte, flue  
                                                         dust, or residues: 
                                                         skimmings,         
                                                         tailings, scale.   
    33322...........  ......do........................  Lead matte, flue    
                                                         dust, slag         
                                                         skimmings, etc.    
    33332...........  ......do........................  Zinc dross, residue,
                                                         ashes, skimmings.  
    33342...........  ......do........................  Aluminum residue:   
                                                         ashes, skimmings,  
                                                         slag, smelting     
                                                         residues.          
    33398...........  ......do........................  Misc. non-ferrous   
                                                         residue, inc.      
                                                         solder skimmings,  
                                                         type metal dross,  
                                                         tin, nickel dross. 
    40112...........  ......do........................  Ashes: fly ash, coal
                                                         cinders, photo     
                                                         silver ash,        
                                                         incinerator ash,   
                                                         metal bearing.     
    40212...........  ......do........................  Brass, bronze,      
                                                         copper, or alloy   
                                                         scrap, tailings, or
                                                         wastes.            
    40213...........  ......do........................  Lead, zinc, or alloy
                                                         scrap: lead        
                                                         borings, zinc      
                                                         castings.          
    40214...........  ......do........................  Aluminum scrap:     
                                                         borings, grindings,
                                                         turnings, foil     
                                                         scrap.             
    4021960.........  ......do........................  Tin scrap: metallic 
                                                         tin, clippings,    
                                                         drippings,         
                                                         shavings, for      
                                                         remelting.         
    40221...........  ......do........................  Textile waste: waste
                                                         cotton, rope, rags,
                                                         nec.               
    40231...........  ......do........................  Wood scrap: woodpulp
                                                         waste, spent wood, 
                                                         waste bark.        
    40251...........  ......do........................  Chemical or         
                                                         petroleum waste:   
                                                         spent acid,        
                                                         lubricating grease,
                                                         waste oil.         
    40261...........  ......do........................  Rubber or plastic   
                                                         scrap, clippings or
                                                         trimmings.         
    4029114.........  ......do........................  Municipal garbage   
                                                         waste, solid,      
                                                         digested and       
                                                         ground.            
    4029176.........  ......do........................  Auto shredder       
                                                         residue.           
    4111434.........  ......do........................  Bags, old: burlap,  
                                                         gunny, jute, or    
                                                         nec.               
    4111580.........  ......do........................  Old bags for        
                                                         conversion into    
                                                         bale coverings.    
    42111...........  ......do........................  Non-revenue mvmt. of
                                                         containers moving  
                                                         in reverse of      
                                                         loaded direction.  
    42112...........  ......do........................  Non-revenue mvmt. of
                                                         shipping devices   
                                                         moving in reverse  
                                                         of loaded          
                                                         direction.         
    42311...........  ......do........................  Revenue mvmt. of    
                                                         containers moving  
                                                         in reverse of      
                                                         loaded direction.  
                                                                            
                                                                            
                                  * * * * * * *                             
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    Sec. 1039.14  [Amended]
    
        3. Section 1039.14, paragraph (b)(5) is proposed to be amended by 
    adding parentheses around the words ``other than iron and steel'', 
    removing the period and adding the following words to the end of the 
    sentence: ``to the extent not otherwise exempted from regulation.''
        4. Part 1145 is proposed to be revised to read as follows:
    
    PART 1145--RAILROAD RATES ON RECYCLABLE COMMODITIES
    
    Sec.
    1145.1  Purpose.
    1145.2  Definitions.
    1145.3  Announcement of statutory cap levels.
    1145.4  Initial challenge to individual movements.
    1145.5  Treatment of contract rates.
    1145.6  Regulation of recyclable rates.
    1145.7  Commission review.
    1145.8  Interest.
    1145.9  Jurisdiction.
    
        Authority: 5 U.S.C. 553; 49 U.S.C. 10321, 10505, 10731, and 
    10707a.
    
    
    Sec. 1145.1  Purpose.
    
        This part establishes procedures to encourage shippers and carriers 
    to negotiate directly with one another to secure mutually-satisfactory 
    rates on recyclable commodities or, if such agreement cannot be 
    reached, procedures to regulate rates on recyclable commodities in 
    compliance with 49 U.S.C. 10731(e), and to afford relief, including 
    liquidated damages, rate freezes, rate reductions, reparations and/or 
    such other relief as may be deemed appropriate. The Commission will:
        (a) Determine annually the statutory cap levels to apply for the 
    ensuing calendar year for individual Class I carriers, regions, and the 
    nation;
        (b) Determine, in response to requests from either shippers or 
    carriers for dispute resolution the applicable individual carrier ratio 
    (in a single line move), or weighted average ratio (in a joint line 
    move);
        (c) Adjudicate disputes over whether challenged rates comply with 
    this part and whether any relief is warranted; and
        (d) Issue orders directing rate freezes, reductions, payments of 
    reparations, and/or such other relief as may be deemed necessary to 
    comply with this part.
    
    
    Sec. 1145.2  Definitions.
    
        (a) Above-cap rate means a rate that produces a revenue/variable 
    cost ratio above the Pertinent Statutory Cap Level, on an annual 
    weighted average basis, using all movements of a particular recyclable 
    commodity for a particular shipper between a specific origin and 
    destination over a specified route in a full calendar year.
        (b) Annual Rate-Variable Cost Ratio means the ratio of the Weighted 
    Average Rate to the Weighted Average Variable Cost.
        (c) Base Year means the calendar year before the year in which the 
    movements that are the subject of a shipper challenge actually 
    occurred.
        (d) Below-cap rate means a rate that produces a revenue/variable 
    cost ratio equal to or below the Pertinent Statutory Cap Level, on an 
    annual weighted average basis, using all movements of a particular 
    recyclable commodity for a particular shipper between a specific origin 
    and destination over a specified route in a full calendar year.
        (e) Challenge Year means the calendar year in which a shipper files 
    a complaint with a carrier(s).
        (f) Complaint Year means the calendar year in which the movements 
    that are the subject of a shipper challenge actually occurred.
        (g) Freeze Rate means:
        (1) A Transition Rate that has been found to be above the Pertinent 
    Statutory Cap Level;
        (2) A non-Transition Rate that has been frozen at a level above the 
    Pertinent Statutory Cap Level, but equal to or below 10 percentage 
    points above the Pertinent Statutory Cap Level; or
        (3) A non-Transition Rate found to be more than 10 percentage 
    points above the Pertinent Statutory Cap Level, reduced to 10 
    percentage points above the Pertinent Statutory Cap Level, and frozen 
    at that level.
        (h) Pertinent Statutory Cap Level means the cap ratio level that is 
    computed for each individual carrier (if a single-line rate) or 
    weighted average of the individual carrier ratios of participating 
    carriers (if a through rate) for the Base Year.
        (i) Recyclable commodities, for purposes of this part, means 
    recyclable material defined at 49 U.S.C. 10731(a)(1), other than 
    recyclable or recycled iron or steel.
        (j) Statutory cap levels means the railroad revenue to variable 
    cost ratio level referred to in 49 U.S.C. 10731(3), determined:
        (1) As a national ratio;
        (2) As regional ratios for the Eastern and Western regions;
        (3) As individual carrier ratios for each Class I railroad; and
        (4) As the weighted average of the individual carrier ratios for 
    each carrier participating in a through movement over a specified 
    through route, weighted by the proportion of the variable cost of the 
    through movement accounted for by each participating carrier.
        (k) Ten percentage points above the statutory ratio means a rate 
    that produces a revenue-variable cost ratio ten percentage points above 
    the Pertinent Statutory Cap Level. For example, if the Pertinent 
    Statutory Cap Level is 150 percent of variable cost, ten percentage 
    points above the cap is 160 percent of variable cost.
        (l) Transition Rate means a Weighted Average Rate that has not been 
    increased by more than the increase in the Rail Cost Adjustment Factor 
    (Adjusted) since the Base Year.
        (m) Weighted Average Rate means the total paid for all movements of 
    a particular recyclable commodity by a particular shipper between a 
    specific origin and destination over a specified route in a full 
    calendar year, divided by the total number of movements or units of 
    shipment of that commodity for that shipper between the specific origin 
    and destination over the specified route in that year, to produce an 
    average charge per car, hundred weight, or other rate unit and an 
    average weight per car.
        (n) Weighted Average Rate-Cost Ratio Cap means the Rate-Variable 
    Cost Ratio Cap of each carrier participating in a through movement, 
    multiplied by that carrier's percentage of the through movement 
    Weighted Average Variable Cost, and summed for all carriers 
    participating in the through movement.
        (o) Weighted Average Variable Cost means the sum of the variable 
    cost of each movement of a particular recyclable commodity for a 
    particular shipper between a specific origin and destination over a 
    specified route in a full calendar year divided by the total number of 
    movement units of that commodity for that shipper between the specific 
    origin and destination over the specified route in that year.
    
    
    Sec. 1145.3  Announcement of statutory cap levels.
    
        Each calendar year, as soon as the Commission can do so, and based 
    on the latest cost and revenue data available, the Commission will 
    state the statutory cap levels required to apply for the Complaint 
    Year. These cap levels will be stated:
        (a) As a national ratio;
        (b) As regional ratios for the Eastern and Western regions; and
        (c) As individual carrier ratios for each Class I railroad (each 
    non-Class I railroad will apply the regional ratio for the region in 
    which its operations predominate).
    
    
    Sec. 1145.4  Initial challenge to individual movements.
    
        (a) Shipper complaint to carrier. A shipper may institute a 
    complaint if it asserts, with supporting evidence, that the rate-
    variable cost ratio of a Weighted Average Rate charged for movements of 
    a particular recyclable commodity from a specific origin to a specific 
    destination over a specified single line or through route exceeded the 
    Pertinent Statutory Cap Level.
        (1) Complaints to a carrier(s) shall be accompanied by sworn 
    testimony, including cost evidence, either adjusted or unadjusted, 
    using the Commission's personal computer-based Phase III URCS Costing 
    Model (or a successor model), and evidence of a particular recyclable 
    commodity shipments made or received within the Complaint Year over a 
    specified route between a specific origin and destination.
        (2) Complaints to a carrier(s) must show that the Weighted Average 
    Rate-Variable Cost Ratio exceeded the Pertinent Statutory Cap Level. In 
    making the showing, a complaint shall use costs from the Base year, 
    indexed to the Complaint Year. The statutory cap ratios shall be those 
    computed by the Commission based on the data from the Base Year. Any 
    rates charged pursuant to a written contract entered into pursuant to 
    49 CFR 1145.5 shall not be included in the weighted average for 
    purposes of calculating the Weighted Average Rate. The shipper must 
    state with specificity the relief sought and the reasons and evidence 
    supporting the shipper's claim for relief. The claim shall be served on 
    each carrier participating in the moves not later than February 28th of 
    the Challenge Year, by first class mail or express delivery, or by any 
    other means agreed upon by shipper and carrier(s).
        (b) Carrier(s) reply to shipper's complaint. (1) If the carrier(s) 
    agrees with the shipper's evidence, the carrier(s) shall reply to the 
    complaining shipper in writing, stating its intention to enter into a 
    settlement agreement for relief, as appropriate. The carrier(s) shall 
    serve its reply on the shipper not later than April 30th of the 
    Challenge Year by first class mail, express delivery, or by any other 
    means agreed upon by shipper and carrier(s).
        (2) If the carrier(s) disagrees with the shipper's evidence, the 
    carrier(s) shall file a reply, accompanied by sworn testimony, 
    including cost evidence, either adjusted or unadjusted, using the 
    Commission's personal computer-based Phase III URCS Costing Model (or a 
    successor model), pointing out any errors in the data and calculations 
    submitted to it by the shipper. The carrier(s) shall serve its reply on 
    the shipper not later than April 30th of the Challenge Year by first 
    class mail, express delivery, or by any other means agreed upon by 
    shipper and carrier(s).
        (c) Shipper rebuttal. The shipper may file a rebuttal not later 
    than May 30th of the Challenge Year by first class mail, express 
    delivery, or by any other means agreed upon by shipper and carrier(s).
        (d) Settlement negotiations. Shipper and carrier(s) shall negotiate 
    in good faith to reach a voluntary settlement of the issues in any 
    complaint brought under this part.
        (1) Any settlement reached under this part shall be in writing and 
    signed by a representative of both the shipper and the carrier(s) 
    within 60 days of the last filing.
        (2) If shipper and carrier(s) do not reach a settlement within 60 
    days of the last filing, then the shipper shall serve notice on the 
    carrier(s) if it intends to submit the matter to the Interstate 
    Commerce Commission for resolution, not later than August 10th of the 
    Challenge Year, and both shipper and carrier(s) shall make a joint 
    filing to the Commission of all written evidentiary material previously 
    provided to the other party, with separate transmittal letters (not to 
    exceed four pages) from the shipper and carrier(s) which shall state 
    the relief requested but shall not include any new evidence, not later 
    than August 31st of the Challenge Year.
        (e) The Commission shall determine whether the challenged rate 
    exceeds the Pertinent Statutory Cap Level, and, if so, determine the 
    appropriate remedy under this part.
        (f) Filings made under this part shall be prepared in a manner 
    consistent with the rules of practice at 49 CFR parts 1100 through 1102 
    and 1104.
    
    
    Sec. 1145.5  Treatment of contract rates.
    
        Rates charged on movements pursuant to a rate contract executed in 
    writing between a shipper and a carrier will not be included in 
    calculating the annual Rate-Variable Cost Ratio of any shipper 
    complaint about a recyclable rate. Movements made pursuant to ``rate 
    quotations,'' ``exempt tariff circulars,'' or similar types of rate 
    publications normally used for exempt traffic in lieu of published 
    common carrier tariffs filed with the Commission pursuant to 49 U.S.C. 
    10762, incorporating the terms of the Uniform Straight Bill of Lading, 
    and used without other writing or agreement between the shipper and 
    carrier for line haul service, shall not come within the definition of 
    a contract under this section.
    
    
    Sec. 1145.6  Regulation of recyclable rates.
    
        (a) Determination of whether a rate is a transition rate. (1) A 
    shipper complaining to a carrier will compute the percentage increase 
    in the RCAF between the third quarter of the year of the Complaint Year 
    and the third quarter of the Base Year. If there has been a decline in 
    the RCAF between two years, then the percentage increase shall be 
    deemed to be zero.
        (2) A shipper complaining to a carrier will compute the percentage 
    increase in the Weighted Average Rate between the Base Year and the 
    Complaint Year. If there has been a decline or no change, then the rate 
    of change shall be deemed to be zero.
        (3) If the percentage increase in the Weighted Average Rate in the 
    Complaint Year over the Base Year is either zero or is less than or 
    equal to the percentage increase in the RCAF, the rate in question is a 
    Transition Rate. If the percentage increase is greater than the 
    increase in the RCAF, the rate is not a Transition Rate.
        (4) For purposes of comparing rates in the Base Year with rates in 
    the Complaint Year, the Weighted Average Rate per hundred weight or ton 
    shall be used.
        (b) Shipper protection against increases in Transition Rates. (1) 
    Upon shipper complaint showing that the Annual Rate-Variable Cost Ratio 
    of a Weighted Average Rate that is a Transition Rate was above the 
    Pertinent Statutory Cap Level, a Transition Rate will be frozen for the 
    Challenge Year and that Freeze Rate will not be further increased via 
    RCAF increases or otherwise.
        (2) Upon the shipper's complaint to the carrier in the next year, 
    demonstrating that [the] Weighted Average Rate charged per hundred 
    weight or ton exceeded the Freeze Rate and the Pertinent Statutory Cap, 
    the shipper will be entitled to liquidated damages equal to the amount 
    by which the Weighted Average Rate for the previous year exceeded the 
    Freeze Rate for that year, multiplied by the quantity actually shipped.
        (3) If in any following year, the Weighted Average Rate produces a 
    ratio that exceeds the pertinent Statutory Cap Level, but the rate is 
    below an existing Freeze Rate, the existing Freeze Rate will remain in 
    place for that year; however, if the Weighted Average Rate produces a 
    ratio below the Pertinent Statutory Cap Level, or no showing is made 
    that the rate produces a ratio above the Pertinent Statutory Cap Level, 
    the rate is unfrozen.
        (c) Relief with respect to rates other than Transition Rates. (1) 
    Upon a shipper's complaint to a carrier showing that the Weighted 
    Average Rate has been increased above the Pertinent Statutory Cap 
    Level, to a level less than or equal to ten percentage points above the 
    Pertinent Statutory Cap Level in the previous year, the shipper shall 
    be entitled to a Freeze Rate on the movement at that level for the year 
    in which the challenge was filed with the carrier.
        (2) Upon a shipper complaint to a carrier showing that a Weighted 
    Average Rate in the Complaint Year produced a ratio that was more than 
    10 percentage points above the Pertinent Statutory Cap Level, the 
    shipper shall receive as liquidated damages an amount equal to the 
    difference between the Weighted Average Rate actually charged and the 
    Weighted Average Rate that would have applied if the Rate had been at a 
    level producing a ratio equal to 10 percentage points above the 
    Pertinent Statutory Cap Level, multiplied by the quantity actually 
    shipped, and a Freeze Rate for the next year will be set at that level 
    equal to 10 percentage point above the Pertinent Statutory Cap.
        (3) Upon a shipper complaint to a carrier demonstrating that a 
    Weighted Average Rate exceeded a Freeze Rate in the next Complaint 
    Year, that shipper shall receive liquidated damages equal to the 
    difference between the Weighted Average Rate and the Freeze Rate, and 
    the Freeze Rate will remain in place for another year.
        (4) Upon shipper complaint to the carrier in a subsequent year 
    showing that the Weighted Average Rate produced a ratio exceeding the 
    Pertinent Statutory Cap Level, but was below an existing Freeze Rate, 
    the existing Freeze Rate will remain in place for another year. If the 
    Weighted Average Rate was below the Pertinent Statutory Cap Level, or 
    no showing is made that it is above the Pertinent Statutory Cap Level, 
    then the rate is unfrozen.
        (d) Treatment of through rates. (1) Once liquidated damages are 
    determined to be owed, whether by agreement of shipper and carrier or 
    by the Commission, the collecting carrier shall pay liquidated damages 
    to the shipper for carriers for whom the carrier collected charges.
        (2) If the challenged rate is a combination of local or 
    proportional rates or is a multiple independent factor through rate 
    (MIFTR rate), no carrier whose local or proportional rate or MIFTR rate 
    factor divided by the individual carrier's variable cost produces a 
    rate-variable cost ratio below the individual carrier Pertinent 
    Statutory Cap Level will owe liquidated damages, nor will that 
    carrier's local or proportional rate or MIFTR rate factor be frozen. No 
    carrier participating in a through movement will contribute a greater 
    amount per hundred weight or ton shipped than the amount by which its 
    Weighted Average Rate (or factor) exceeded the Weighted Average Rate 
    set at the carrier's individual Pertinent Statutory Cap Level except 
    that the carriers participating in the through rate will be jointly and 
    severally liable to the shipper for the full amount of the damages 
    suffered by the shipper.
        (e) In the event shipper and carrier(s) do not agree on whether a 
    rate is a Transition Rate, the Pertinent Statutory Cap Level, the 
    Weighted Average Rate, Weighted Average Variable Cost, or any other 
    matter arising under these regulations, the shipper or carrier(s) may 
    submit the dispute to the Commission for resolution pursuant to the 
    regulations of this part.
    
    
    Sec. 1145.7  Commission review.
    
        Four years after the regulations of this part are implemented, the 
    Commission will institute a proceeding and invite comments from all 
    interested parties on the operation of the regulations of this part, 
    and whether the regulations of this part should be further revised. The 
    Commission will review the record developed in the proceeding and take 
    whatever action it deems to be required.
    
    
    Sec. 1145.8  Interest.
    
        Interest on liquidated damages or on reparations ordered by the 
    Commission pursuant to this part will be calculated in accordance with 
    the Commission's regulations on interest, 49 CFR part 1141.
    
    
    Sec. 1145.9  Jurisdiction.
    
        The Commission has regulatory jurisdiction over all rates on 
    recyclable commodities subject to this part, and no showing of railroad 
    market dominance is required. The provisions of this part shall not 
    apply, however, to any non-ferrous recyclable commodity to the extent 
    the Commission exempts it from maximum rate regulation.
    
    [FR Doc. 94-20842 Filed 8-23-94; 8:45 am]
    BILLING CODE 7035-01-P
    
    
    

Document Information

Published:
08/24/1994
Department:
Interstate Commerce Commission
Entry Type:
Uncategorized Document
Action:
Notice of proposed rulemaking.
Document Number:
94-20842
Dates:
Comments are due on September 23, 1994.
Pages:
0-0 (1 pages)
Docket Numbers:
Federal Register: August 24, 1994, Ex Parte No. 346 (Sub-No. 36)
CFR: (11)
49 CFR 1039.11
49 CFR 1039.14
49 CFR 1145.1
49 CFR 1145.2
49 CFR 1145.3
More ...