[Federal Register Volume 64, Number 58 (Friday, March 26, 1999)]
[Proposed Rules]
[Pages 14668-14676]
From the Federal Register Online via the Government Publishing Office [www.gpo.gov]
[FR Doc No: 99-7222]
=======================================================================
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES
Office of the Secretary
45 CFR Part 5
RIN 0991-AB00
Revision of the Department of Health and Human Services Freedom
of Information Act Regulations and Implementation of the Electronic
Freedom of Information Act Amendments of 1996
AGENCY: Department of Health and Human Services.
ACTION: Proposed rule.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
SUMMARY: This document sets forth proposed revisions to the
Department's Freedom of Information regulations. The regulations have
been streamlined and condensed, in accord with principles of the
National Performance Review, and incorporated more ``user-friendly''
language wherever possible. These proposed revisions also contain new
provisions implementing the Electronic Freedom of Information Act
Amendments of 1996.
DATES: Submit comments on this proposed regulation on or before May 26,
1999.
ADDRESSES: Address all comments concerning this proposed rule to
Rosario Cirrincione, Freedom of Information and Privacy Acts Division,
Office of the Assistant Secretary for Public Affairs, U.S. Department
Health and Human Services, Hubert H. Humphrey Building, 200
Independence Avenue SW., Washington, DC 20201-0004.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Rosario Cirrincione (202) 690-7453.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: These comprehensive revisions of 45 CFR part
5 incorporate changes to the language and structure of the regulations
and add new provisions to implement the Electronic Freedom of
Information Act Amendments of 1996 (Pub. L. 104-231). The Department's
current Freedom of Information Act regulations are no longer in
compliance with the law in that they do not reflect the provisions of
the 1996 Amendments. This revised regulation is intended to bring the
Department into compliance and to inform the public as to how we will
implement the law in the light of the Amendments.
New Provisions
A. The following new definitions are added to the regulation:
1. Electronic mail or e-mail means a communication of information
electronically from one personal computer user to another.
2. Expedited processing means placing a request in a special queue
for processing ahead of requests which had been received earlier.
Within any special queue as well as within any regular queues we may
also maintain, requests will continue to be processed on a ``first in,
first out'' basis.
3. Form means the medium in which the record is physically
incorporated (e.g., paper, floppy disk, CD-ROM, etc.).
4. Format means a particular manner of storing or presenting the
information within a given medium, such as a particular computer
software used to generate or reproduce the record.
5. Reproduction means duplicating an existing record for release,
in whole or in part, to a requester under the Freedom of Information
Act. As appropriate to the medium of release, records may be
photocopied, microfilmed, or electronically copied onto tape or disc.
B. Response Times. The proposed regulation reflects the expanded
time frame, from 10 working days to 20 working days, permitted for
routine responses.
C. Expedited Processing. Expedited processing is provided in cases
where the requester demonstrates that failure to obtain the records on
an expedited basis could reasonably be expected to pose an imminent
threat to the life or physical safety of an individual, or, when the
requester is a person primarily engaged in disseminating information, a
showing is made that there exists an urgency to inform the public
concerning an actual or alleged Federal Government activity. Other
requests for expedited processing will be considered on a case by case
basis. The decision to grant expedited processing rests with the FOI
Officer, but may be appealed.
D. What Is Not A FOIA Request. The proposed regulation attempts to
correct a common misunderstanding by clarifying that the Freedom of
Information Act is not the proper mechanism to seek answers to specific
questions of program policy, appeal adjudication of program or
administrative decisions, or to provide input into HHS program decision
making.
E. Electronic Records. The proposed regulation emphasizes that
electronic records, including e-mail, are also subject to the Act, and
that every reasonable effort will be made to provide records in the
form and format requested.
F. Listing of FOIA Exemptions. Because they are a matter of law,
not regulation, and are readily available elsewhere, the proposed
regulation does not repeat the listing of FOIA exemptions contained in
the previous regulation.
Similar revisions to the Freedom of Information Act Regulations of
Executive Branch Agencies are occurring throughout the Government.
Public hearings are not planned but public comment on the proposed rule
is invited. Instructions as to where to mail public comments are
included, above.
We have examined the impacts of this proposal under Executive Order
12866 and the Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 601 to 612).
Executive Order 12866 directs agencies to assess all costs and benefits
of available regulatory alternatives and, when regulation is necessary,
to select regulatory approaches that maximize net benefits (including
potential economic, environmental, public health and safety, and other
advantages). Under the
[[Page 14669]]
Regulatory Flexibility Act, unless an agency certifies that a rule will
not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small
entities, the agency must analyze regulatory options that would
minimize the impact of the rule on small entities. Title II of the
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act (2 U.S.C. 1532) requires that agencies
prepare an assessment of anticipated costs and benefits before
proposing any rule that may result in an expenditure in any 1 year by
state, local, and tribal governments, in the aggregate, or by the
private sector, of $100 million or more (adjusted annually for
inflation).
HHS has reviewed this rule and has determined that it is consistent
with the regulatory philosophy and principles identified in Executive
Order 12866, and these two statutes. With respect to the Regulatory
Flexibility Act, the Secretary certifies that the rule will not have a
significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities.
Because the proposed rule does not impose any mandates on state, local,
or tribal governments, or the private sector that will result in a 1-
year expenditure of $100 million or more, HHS is not required to
perform a cost-benefit analysis under the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act.
List of subjects in 45 CFR Part 5
Administrative practices and procedure, Freedom of information.
Dated: December 10, 1998.
Donna E. Shalala,
Secretary.
For the reasons set out in the preamble, the Secretary proposes to
revise 45 CFR part 5 to read as follows:
PART 5--FREEDOM OF INFORMATION REGULATIONS
Subpart A--Basic Policy
Sec.
5.1 Purpose.
5.2 Policy.
5.3 Scope.
5.4 Relationship between the FOIA and the Privacy Act of 1974.
5.5 Definitions.
Subpart B--Obtaining a Record
5.21 How to request records.
5.22 Expedited processing.
5.23 Requests not handled under the FOIA.
5.24 Referral of request outside the Department.
5.25 Responding to your request.
Subpart C--Release and Denial of Records
5.31 Designation of authorized officials.
5.32 Release of records.
5.33 Denial of requests.
5.34 Appeal of Denials.
5.35 Time limits.
Subpart D--Fees
5.41 Fees to be charged--categories of requests.
5.42 Fees to be charged--general provisions.
5.43 Fee schedule.
5.44 Procedures for assessing and collecting fees.
5.45 Waiver or reduction of fees.
Subpart E--Records Available for Public Inspection
5.51 Records available.
5.52 Indices of records.
Subpart F--Predisclosure Notification for Certain Kinds of Commercial/
Financial Records
5.61 General.
Authority: 5 U.S.C. 552, 18 U.S.C. 1905, 31 U.S.C. 9701, 42
U.S.C. 1306(c), E.O. 12600.
Subpart A--Basic Policy
Sec. 5.1 Purpose.
This part contains the rules that the Department of Health and
Human Services (HHS) follows in handling requests for records under the
Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). It describes how to make FOIA
requests; who can release records and who can decide not to release
them; how much time it should take to make a determination regarding
release; what fees may be charged; what records are available for
public inspection; why some records are not released; and your right to
appeal and to then go to court if we still refuse to release records.
Sec. 5.2 Policy.
As a general policy, HHS follows a balanced approach in
administering the FOIA. We recognize the right of the public to access
records in the possession of the Department but also realize that some
materials are nonetheless protected by the statute. In addition, we
recognize the legitimate interests of persons or organizations who have
submitted material to the Department or who would otherwise be affected
by the release of records. For example, we have no discretion to
release certain records, such as trade secrets and confidential
commercial information, which we are prohibited by law from releasing.
This policy calls for the fullest responsible disclosure consistent
with those requirements of administrative necessity and confidentiality
recognized in the Freedom of Information Act. In particular, the
Department encourages a ``pro-active'' approach to making information
available through press releases, public information programs, and to
the greatest degree possible, electronically, through the large number
of web sites sponsored and maintained by HHS components.
Sec. 5.3 Scope.
These rules apply to all components of the Department. Some units
may establish additional rules because of unique program requirements,
but such rules must be consistent with these rules and must have the
concurrence of the Assistant Secretary for Public Affairs. Existing
implementing rules remain in effect to the extent they are consistent
with the new Departmental regulation. If additional rules are issued,
they will be published in the Federal Register, and you will be able to
get copies from our Freedom of Information Officers.
Sec. 5.4 Relationship between the FOIA and the Privacy Act of 1974.
(a) Coverage. The FOIA and this rule apply to all HHS records,
including those covered by the Privacy Act. The Privacy Act, 5 U.S.C.
552a, applies only to records that are about individuals but only if
those records are in a system of records. ``Individuals'' and ``system
of records'' are defined in the Privacy Act and in our Privacy Act
regulation, part 5b of this title.
(b) Requesting your own records. If you are an individual and
request records, then to the degree that you are requesting your own
records in a Privacy Act system of records, we will handle your request
under the Privacy Act and part 5b of this title. If there is any record
that we need not release to you under those provisions, we will also
consider your request under the FOIA and this rule, and we will release
the record to you if the FOIA requires it.
(c) Requesting another individual's record. Whether or not you are
an individual, if you request records that are about an individual
(other than yourself) and that are in a system of records, we will
handle your request under the FOIA and this rule. (However, if our
disclosure in response to your request would be permitted by the
Privacy Act's disclosure provisions, 5 U.S.C. 552a(b), for reasons
other than the requirements of the FOIA, and if we decide to make the
disclosure, then we will not handle your request under the FOIA and
this rule. For example, when we make routine use disclosures pursuant
to requests, we do not handle them under the FOIA and this rule.
Routine use is defined in the Privacy Act and in part 5b of this
title.) If we handle your request under the FOIA and this rule and the
FOIA does not require releasing the records to you, then the Privacy
Act may prohibit the release and remove our discretion to release.
[[Page 14670]]
Sec. 5.5 Definitions.
As used in this part,
Agency means any executive department, military department,
government corporation, government controlled corporation, or other
establishment in the executive branch of the Federal Government, or any
independent regulatory agency. Thus HHS is an agency. A private
organization is not an agency even if it is performing work under
contract with the Government or is receiving Federal financial
assistance. Grantee and contractor records are not subject to the FOIA
unless they are in the possession of HHS or its agents, such as
Medicare health insurance carriers and intermediaries.
Commercial use means, when referring to a request, that the request
is from or on the behalf of someone who seeks information for a use or
purpose that furthers the commercial, trade, or profit interests of the
requester or of a person on whose behalf the request is made. Whether a
request is for a commercial use depends on the purpose of the request
and the use to which the records will be put. The identity of the
requester (e.g., individual, non-profit corporation, for profit
corporation) or the nature of the records, while in some cases
indicative of that purpose or use, is not necessarily determinative.
When a request is from a representative of the news media, a purpose or
use supporting the requester's new dissemination function is not
considered a commercial use.
Department or HHS means the U.S. Department of Health and Human
Services. It includes Medicare health insurance carriers and
intermediaries to the extent they are performing functions under
agreements entered into under sections 1816 and 1842 of the Social
Security Act, 42 U.S.C. 1395h, 1395u.
Duplication means the process of making a copy of a record and
sending it to the requester, to the extent necessary to respond to the
request. Such copies include paper copy, microfilm, audio visual
materials, and magnetic tape, cards, and discs.
Educational institution means a preschool, elementary, or secondary
school, institution of undergraduate or graduate higher education, or
institution of professional or vocation education, which operates a
program of scholarly research.
Electronic mail or e-mail means a communication of information
electronically from one personal computer user to another.
Expedited Processing means placing a request in a special queue for
processing ahead of other requests which had been received earlier.
Within any special queue as well as within any regular queues we may
also maintain, requests will continue to be processed on a ``first in/
first out basis,'' except for requests expedited on the basis of an
imminent threat to the life or safety of a specific person, which will
always be placed at the head of the queue.
Form means the medium in which the record is physically maintained
(e.g., paper, floppy diskette, CD-ROM, etc.)
Format means a particular manner of storing or presenting the
information within a given medium, such as a particular computer
software used to generate or reproduce the record.
Freedom of Information or FOIA means section 552 of Title 5, United
States Code.
Freedom of Information Officer means any HHS official who has been
delegated the authority to release or withhold records, and assess,
waive, or reduce fees in response to FOIA requests.
Multitrack Processing means a system of separate processing queues
into which requests are placed based on their complexity and scope. HHS
components may establish such processing systems if, in their
judgement, such an arrangement will enable them to provide better
service to requesters.
Non-commercial scientific institution means an institution that is
not operated substantially for purposes of furthering its own or
someone else's business, trade, or profit interests, and that is
operated for the purposes of conducting scientific research whose
results are not intended to promote any particular product or industry.
Records means any handwritten, typed, printed or electronic
documents (such as memoranda, letters, studies, tables, charts, drafts,
transcripts, and minutes) and documentary material in other forms (such
as magnetic tapes, cards or discs; paper tapes; audio or video
recordings; maps; photographs; slides; microfilm; and motion pictures).
It does not include objects or articles such as exhibits, models,
office equipment, duplicating machines, computers or audiovisual
processing materials. In particular, it does not include such objects
or articles even to the extent that there is information inscribed or
imprinted on them, or electronic instructions embedded in them. Nor
does it include books, magazines, brochures, pamphlets, or other
reference material in formally organized and officially designated HHS
libraries, where such materials are available under the rules of the
particular library.
Representative of the news media means a person actively gathering
information for an entity organized and operated to publish or
broadcast news to the public. News media entities include television
and radio broadcasters, publishers of newspapers or periodicals who
distribute or make their products available for purchase or
subscription by the general public, and those who may disseminate
information to the general public, by subscription, through electronic
means. We will treat freelance journalists as representatives of a news
media entity if they can show a likelihood of publication through such
an entity. A publication contract is such a basis, and a requester's
past publication record may provide such a basis.
Reproduction means duplicating an existing record for release, in
whole or in part, to a requester under the Freedom of Information Act.
As appropriate to the medium of release, records may be photocopied,
microfilmed, or electronically copied onto tape or disc.
Request means asking for records, whether or not you specifically
refer to the Freedom of Information Act. Requests from other Executive
Branch agencies and Federal court orders for documents are not included
within this definition. Judicial subpoenas from other than Federal
courts are requests to the extent provided by part 2 of this title.
Review means, when used in connection with processing records for a
commercial use request, examining records to determine what portions,
if any, may be withheld, and any other processing that is necessary to
prepare the records for release. It includes only the examining and
processing that are done the first time we analyze whether a specific
exemption applies to a particular record or portion of a record. It
does not include examination done in the appeal stage with respect to
an exemption that was applied at the initial response stage, nor does
it include the process of researching or resolving general legal or
policy issues regarding exemptions.
Search means looking for records or portions of records responsive
to a request. It includes reading and interpreting a request, manually
searching hard copy paper files, electronically searching automated
files and data bases, and page-by-page and line-by-line examination to
identify responsive portions of a document. It does not include,
however, line-by-line examination where merely duplicating an entire
page would be a less expensive
[[Page 14671]]
and quicker way to comply with a request.
Subpart B--Obtaining a Record
Sec. 5.21 How to request records.
(a) General. Our policy is to answer all requests as accurately and
completely as possible from existing records. In order to accomplish
this most efficiently and with a minimum of misunderstanding, we
require all requests to be submitted in writing, by postal service,
facsimile or messenger. All requests, no matter how submitted, must be
signed by the person making the request and contain the postal address
of the requester and the name of the person responsible for the payment
of any fees that may be charged. A phone number where we can reach the
requester to get clarification of the request or resolve other issues
concerning the request, is strongly recommended. Providing the request
in writing assures that all the rights provided by the FOIA and these
regulations are protected (for example, the right to administratively
appeal any denials we may make and the right to have our decisions
reviewed in Federal court).
(b) Addressing requests. It will help us to handle your request
sooner if you address it to the Freedom of Information Officer of the
HHS component that is most likely to have the records you want. (See
Sec. 5.31 of this part for a list of HHS Freedom of Information
Officers.) If you cannot determine who is most likely to have the
records you seek, send the request to: HHS Freedom of Information
Officer, Room 645-F, Hubert H. Humphrey Building, Department of Health
and Human Services, 200 Independence Avenue SW, Washington, DC 20201.
Write the words ``Freedom of Information Act Request'' on the envelope
and on the letter.
(c) Details in the letter. You should provide all the details you
can that will help us identify and locate the records you want. A
request submitted without details, such as one for ``all records you
have on (a particular subject),'' is likely to require a great deal of
search time and be very expensive, even if we find few or no records.
If you are not sure how to write your request or what details to
include, communicate with a Freedom of Information Officer.
Sec. 5.22 Expedited processing.
You may ask that your request be handled in an expedited fashion.
(a) Reasons for expedited processing. We will expedite the
processing of your request if you demonstrate:
(1) That failure to obtain the requested records on an expedited
basis could reasonably be expected to pose an imminent threat to the
life or physical safety of a specific individual; or
(2) With respect to a request made by a person primarily engaged in
disseminating information, that there exists an urgency to inform the
public concerning actual or alleged Federal Government activity. (A
routine publication deadline, of itself, shall not constitute urgency.)
(3) We will consider other reasons for expedited processing on a
case-by-case basis. (One situation that may warrant expedited
processing in some cases occurs where lack of such processing will
deprive you of information for which you have a substantial need for
purposes of litigation with a governmental agency. If you ask for
expedited processing on this basis, you must show that you submitted
the request as soon as possible after learning of the need for the
records.)
(b) Process for asking for expedited processing. You must make your
request for expedited processing in writing. You must include a
complete explanation of the reasons that you believe justify expediting
the processing of your request. You must certify in writing that the
explanation is true and correct to the best of your knowledge and
belief. Such a certification is required, but it does not, by itself,
entitle you to expedited processing. You must address the request for
expedited processing to the FOI Officer whose component has the records
you want. (See Sec. 5.31 of this part for a list of FOI Officers in
HHS.) If the records are in more than one component of HHS, you must
address your request for expedited processing to the HHS FOI Officer.
(c) The decision. The FOI Officer will decide whether to expedite
the processing of your request for records. The decision will be made,
and notice of the decision will be sent to you, within ten calendar
days after the date of your request for expedited processing. The date
of your request will be the date it is received in the FOI office of
the component maintaining the records requested.
(d) Granting the request. Granting a request for expedited
processing does not constitute a promise to meet any particular
deadline that you may try to impose on us for responding to your
request for records.
(e) Denying the request. If we deny your request for expedited
processing, we will process your request for records with other non-
expedited requests for records, on a first-in/first-out basis. You may
appeal a decision to deny expedited processing. The denial letter will
explain the appeal process and will identify the official authorized to
decide an appeal of the decision. You must address the appeal to the
official identified in the denial letter. We will make a decision on
your appeal expeditiously and we will notify you promptly of that
decision. If we deny your appeal, you may seek judicial review of that
decision in the United States District Court in the district where you
reside or have your principal place of business, in the district where
the records are situated, or in the District of Columbia.
Sec. 5.23 Requests not handled under the FOIA.
(a) We will not handle your request under the FOIA and this
regulation to the extent that it asks for records that are currently
available, either from HHS or another part of the Federal Government,
under a statute other than the FOIA that provides for charging fees for
those records. For example, we will not handle your request under the
FOIA and these regulations to the extent that it asks for records
currently available from the Government Printing Office or the National
Technical Information Service.
(b) We will not handle your request under the FOIA and this
regulation to the extent that it asks for records that are distributed
by an HHS program office as part of its regular program activity, for
example, health education brochures distributed by the National
Institutes of Health.
(c) We will not handle your request under the FOIA and this
regulation to the extent that it asks for specific answers to questions
regarding program policies of any component of HHS, seeks adjudication
of decisions made in the administration of any our programs, or
attempts to circumvent established procedures providing for input into
our decision making processes. There are other mechanisms available to
address each of these kinds of concerns.
Sec. 5.24 Referral of requests outside the Department.
If you request records that were created by, or provided to us by,
another Federal agency, we may refer the records and your request (or
the portion of your request which would be answered by those records)
to that agency for response. We may likewise refer your request for
classified records to the agency that classified them. In these cases,
the other agency will process and respond to your request (or that
portion of your request) under that agency's regulations. You will not
need
[[Page 14672]]
to make a separate request to that agency. We will notify you when we
refer your request to another agency.
Sec. 5.25 Responding to your request.
(a) Retrieving records. The Department is required to furnish
copies of records only when they are in our possession or we can
retrieve them from storage. If we have stored the records you want in
the National Archives or another storage center, we will retrieve and
review them for possible disclosure. However, the Federal Government
destroys many old records, so sometimes, it is impossible to fill
requests. Various laws, regulations, and manuals give the time periods
for keeping records before they may be destroyed. You will find further
information about the retention of records in the Records Disposal Act
of 1944, 44 U.S.C. 3301 through 3314; the Federal Property Management
Regulations, 41 CFR 101-11.4; the General Records Schedules of the
National Archives and Records Administration; and in the HHS Handbook;
Files Maintenance and Records Disposition.
(b) Furnishing records. As stated above, the Department is required
to furnish copies only of those records we have or can retrieve. We
need not ask or compel state governments or other entities to produce
records not in our possession in order to respond to a FOIA request.
Neither are we required to create records, perform research, or
aggregate data from a variety of unrelated sources. We will, however,
conduct electronic searches of electronic files and/or data bases when
they are likely to contain the requested records, unless such a search
would significantly interfere with the operation of the electronic
information system. We will provide the records in the form or format
you request, if the existing record is readily reproducible in that
form or format. Requesters will be required to pay the actual costs of
reproducing a record in a form or format in which it is not already
maintained by the responding Departmental component, including the cost
of programming to produce an electronic record. We will not, however,
purchase special equipment or software for the sole purpose of
satisfying a requester's desire for a specific form or format, nor will
we ship records from one organizational or geographic component to
another for the sole purpose of reproducing them in the form or format
asked for by the requester. Regardless of the form or format in which
the responsive records are provided, we will usually provide only one
copy of the record to the requester.
Subpart C--Release and Denial of Records
Sec. 5.31 Designation of authorized officials.
(a) Freedom of Information Officers. To provide coordination and
consistency throughout HHS in responding to FOIA requests, only Freedom
of Information Officers have the authority to release or deny records,
or waive or reduce FOIA fees.
(1) HHS Freedom of Information Officer. Only the HHS Freedom of
Information Officer may determine whether to release or deny records,
or waive or reduce FOIA fees, in any of the following situations:
(i) The records you seek include records addressed to, sent from,
or created by an official or office of the Office of the Secretary,
including its staff offices, or of any Regional Director's Office;
(ii) The records you seek include any records of the Administration
for Children and Families, including its regional offices, or any
organizational unit of HHS not specifically identified below;
(iii) The records you seek include records of more than one of the
HHS components listed below and are not limited to the components
listed in paragraph (a)(3)(iii), (v)-(vi), (viii)-(xi) of this section.
(2) PHS Freedom of Information Officer. If the records you seek are
exclusively records of the Office of Public Health and Science, or of
the Parklawn components of the Program Support Center, or if the
records involve more than one of the components listed in paragraph
(a)(3)(iii), (v)-(vi), (viii)-(xi) of this section, including records
in the regional offices, only the PHS Freedom of Information Officer
may determine whether to release or deny those records, or waive or
reduce associated FOIA fees.
(3) Except as indicated above, each of the Operating Divisions of
the Department has its own Freedom of Information Officer to process
requests for records which are exclusively records of that Operating
Division. Because organizational titles vary from component to
component and may change as the result of organizational realignments,
we will not use the specific organizational titles of officials who
serve as the Operating Divisions' Freedom of Information Officers.
Regardless of titles, Freedom of Information Officers are so designated
by the Heads of their respective Operating Divisions and are
frequently, but not necessarily, the primary Public Affairs officials
or Chief Information Officers of those Operating Divisions. These
officials may, with the concurrence of the Assistant Secretary for
Public Affairs, delegate their authority to release or deny records, or
reduce or deny FOIA fees. The persons to whom these authorities are
delegated are also known as Freedom of Information Officers. The
addresses and telephone numbers of Departmental Freedom of Information
Officers are listed below.
(i) HHS Freedom of Information Officer, Room 645-F, Hubert H.
Humphrey Building, 200 Independence Avenue, SW., Washington, DC 20201.
Tel: (202) 690-7453.
(ii) PHS Freedom of Information Officer, Room 13-C-24, Parklawn
Building, 5600 Fishers Lane, Rockville, Maryland 20857. Tel: (301) 443-
5252.
(iii) Freedom of Information Officer, Agency for Health Care Policy
and Research, Executive Office Center, Suite 501, 2101 East Jefferson
Street, Rockville, Maryland 20852. Tel: (301) 594-1364, ext. 1342.
(iv) Freedom of Information Officer, Administration on Aging, Room
4655, 330 Independence Avenue, SW., Washington, DC 20201. Tel: (202)
205-2814.
(v) Freedom of Information Officer, Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention, and/or the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease
Registry, 1600 Clifton Road, NE., Atlanta, Georgia 30333. Tel: (770)
639-7270.
(vi) Freedom of Information Officer, Food and Drug Administration,
Room 12-A-16, Parklawn Building, 5600 Fishers Lane, Rockville, Maryland
20857. Tel: (301) 827-6500.
(vii) Freedom of Information Officer, Health Care Financing
Administration, Room N2-20-16, North Building, 7500 Security Boulevard,
Baltimore, Maryland 21244. Tel: (410) 786-5353.
(viii) Freedom of Information Officer, Health Resources and
Services Administration, Room 1134, Parklawn Building, 5600 Fishers
Lane, Rockville, Maryland 20857. Tel: (301) 443-2865.
(ix) Freedom of Information Officer, Indian Health Service, Suite
450, Twinbrook Metro Plaza, 12300 Twinbrook Parkway, Rockville,
Maryland 20857. Tel: (301) 443-1116.
(x) Freedom of Information Officer, National Institutes of Health,
Room 2B39, Building 31, 9000 Rockville Pike, Bethesda, Maryland 20892.
Tel: (301) 496-5633.
(xi) Freedom of Information Officer, Substance Abuse and Mental
Health Services Administration, Room 12-C-15, Parklawn Building, 5600
Fishers
[[Page 14673]]
Lane, Rockville, Maryland 20857. Tel: (301) 443-8956.
(b) [Reserved]
Sec. 5.32 Release of Records.
(a) Records previously released. If we have released a record, or
part of a record, to others in the past, we will ordinarily release it
to you also. We will not release it to you, however, if a statute
forbids this disclosure to you, and we will not necessarily release it
to you if an exemption applies in your situation and did not apply, or
applied differently, in the previous situations. For example, a record
about himself/herself, released to a requester, may contain personal
information which would be removed if that record had to be released to
another party.
(b) Unauthorized disclosure. The principle stated in paragraph (a)
of this section, does not apply to any release of material which was
unauthorized.
(c) Poor copy. If we cannot make a legible copy of a record to be
released, we do not attempt to reconstruct it. Instead, we furnish the
best copy possible and note the poor quality in our reply.
Sec. 5.33 Denial of Requests.
(a) Information found but records denied in whole or in part. All
official denials are in writing and are signed by the person who made
the decision to deny all or part of your request. The denial will
include the following details, to the extent that we can do so without
revealing information that is protected by the FOIA: an estimate of the
volume of material that is being denied, a description of the withheld
material in general terms, the reasons for the denial (including
references to the specific exemption(s) of the FOIA authorizing the
withholding or deletion), and an explanation of your right to appeal
the decision (including the identity of the official to whom you should
address any appeal). If we deny information by deleting it from a
record and releasing the remaining portion of the record, we will
indicate on the released portion the amount of the deleted material to
the extent that we can do so without revealing information that is
protected by the FOIA. We will indicate this at the place of the
deletion if that is technically feasible.
(b) Unproductive searches. We will make a diligent search for
records to satisfy your request. Nevertheless, we may not be able to
find the records you want using the information you provided, or the
records may not exist. If we advise you that we have been unable to
find the records you seek despite a diligent search, although we do not
consider this to be a denial of your request, we will also advise you
of your right to appeal the adequacy of our search.
Sec. 5.34 Appeal of denials.
(a) Right of appeal. You have the right to appeal a partial or full
denial of your FOIA request, our failure to find records responsive to
your request or a denial of your request for expedited processing or a
waiver of fees. To do so, you must put your appeal in writing and send
it to the appeal official identified in the letter denying the records,
or expedited processing, or a waiver of fees, or informing you that we
could not find responsive records. You must send your appeal within 30
days from the date you receive that letter or from the date you
received any records released as a partial grant of your request.
(b) Letter of appeal. The appeal letter should state the reason why
you believe that the FOIA exemption(s) we cited does not apply to the
records you requested, or give reasons why they should be released
regardless of whether the exemption(s) applies. If you are appealing
the adequacy of our search, you should explain why you believe the
records actually do exist and where you believe they may be found.
(c) Review process. Before making a decision on any FOIA appeal,
the designated reviewing official will consult with the Office of the
General Counsel to ensure that the rights and interests of all parties
affected by the appeal decision are protected. The concurrence of the
Assistant Secretary for Public Affairs is also required on all appeal
decisions. The response to an appeal made by the reviewing official
constitutes the Department's final action on the request. If the
reviewing official grants your appeal of a denial of records, in whole
or in part, we will send the releasable documents to you promptly or
else explain the reasons for any delay and inform you of the
approximate date you can expect to receive copies of newly released
materials. If the decision is to deny your appeal, the official will
state the reasons for the decision in writing and inform you of the
FOIA provision for judicial review.
Sec. 5.35 Time limits.
(a) General. The FOIA sets certain time limits for us to decide
whether to disclose the records you requested, and to decide appeals.
If we fail to meet these deadlines, you may proceed as if we had denied
your request or appeal. We will try diligently to comply with the time
limits, but if it appears that processing your request may take longer
than we would wish, we may contact you to determine if a more focused
request might satisfy your needs. If a narrower scope will not suffice,
or still will not permit us to process your request within the basic
time limits, we will inform you of the actual time we estimate that it
will take to answer your request. Time limits begin when your request
is initially received in the office of the FOIA Officer responsible for
releasing or denying those records, or of the official responsible for
deciding the appeal. FOIA and appeals offices acknowledge receipt of
requests and appeals when they are received, so if you have not heard
from us within a reasonable time (usually about two weeks), you should
call or write to be sure that your request or appeal was not
misaddressed or misrouted.
(b) Time allowed.
(1)We will decide whether to release the records within twenty (20)
working days after your request reaches the appropriate FOIA office, as
identified in Sec. 5.31. When we decide to release records, we will
provide the records or let you know when you can expect them, or will
make arrangements with you to inspect them, as soon as possible after
that decision.
(2)We will decide an appeal within twenty (20) working days after
the appeal reaches the appropriate appeal official.
(c) Extension of time limits. FOIA Officers or review officials may
extend the time limits in unusual circumstances. Extensions at the
request stage and at the appeal stage may not exceed a total of 10
working days, except as provided by paragraph (d) of this section. We
will notify you in writing of any extension. ``Unusual circumstances''
include situations when we must:
(1) Search for and collect records from field facilities, storage
centers, or locations other than the office processing the request;
(2) Search for, collect, or examine a great many records in
response to a single request;
(3) Consult with another office or agency that has a substantial
interest in the determination of the request;
(4) Conduct negotiations with submitters and requesters of
information to determine the nature and extent of non-disclosable
proprietary materials.
(d) Extensions longer than 10 days. If unusual circumstances, as
defined in paragraph (c) of this section, exist, and if we do not
believe that we can process your request even within the extra ten-day
period described in paragraph (c) of this section, we will notify you
of that conclusion. We will also give you the
[[Page 14674]]
opportunity to narrow the scope of your request so that it can be
processed in a shorter time, and/or to agree on a time frame longer
than the extra ten working days for our processing of your request.
(e) Aggregating requests. If a group of requests by the same
requester, or by a group of requesters acting together, involve related
matters and appear to actually constitute a single request, we may
aggregate them in order to determine whether unusual circumstances, as
defined above, exist.
Subpart D--Fees
Sec. 5.41 Fees to be charged--categories of requests.
The paragraphs below state, for each category of request, the type
of fees that we will generally charge. For each of these categories,
however, the fees may be limited, waived, or reduced for the reasons
given in Secs. 5.42 through 5.45, or for other reasons.
(a) Commercial use request. If your request is for a commercial
use, HHS will charge you the costs of search, review, and duplication.
(b) Educational and scientific institutions and news media. If you
are an educational institution or non-commercial scientific
institution, operated primarily for scholarly or scientific research,
or a representative of the news media, and your request is not for a
commercial use, HHS will charge you only for the duplication of
records. Also, HHS will not charge you the copying costs for the first
100 pages of duplication or its equivalent, depending on the medium
involved.
(c) Other requesters. If your request is not the kind described by
paragraph (a) or (b) of this section, HHS will charge you only for the
search and the duplication. Also, we will not charge you for the first
two hours of search time, or for the copying costs of the first 100
pages of duplication or its equivalent.
Sec. 5.42 Fees to be charged--general provisions.
(a) We may charge you search fees even if the records we find are
exempt from disclosure, or even if we do not find any records at all.
(b) If we are not charging you for the first two hours of search
time, under Sec. 5.41(c), and the search is done electronically
(including doing computer programming), we will charge you search costs
only to the extent that they exceed the equivalent of two hours salary
for a search of paper records calculated as prescribed in Sec. 5.43.
(c) If we are not charging you for the first 100 pages of
duplication, under Sec. 5.41 (b) or (c), then those 100 pages are the
first 100 pages of photocopies of standard size pages, or if the record
is provided in another form, the cost of duplication will be reduced by
an amount equivalent to the cost of photocopying 100 standard size
pages.
(d) We will not charge you any fee at all if the costs of billing
and processing the fee are likely to equal or exceed the amount of the
fee. These amounts vary significantly from component to component. For
requests processed by the HHS Freedom of Information Office, this
amount was $25 as of May 1998.
(e) If we determine that you (acting alone or in concert with
others) are breaking down a single request into a series of requests in
order to avoid (or reduce) the fees charged, we may aggregate all these
requests for purpose of calculating the fees to be charged.
(f) We will charge interest on unpaid bills beginning on the 31st
day following the day the bill was sent. We will use the provisions of
part 30 of this title in assessing interest, administrative costs and
penalties, and in taking actions to encourage payment.
Sec. 5.43 Fee schedule.
HHS charges the following fees:
(a) Manual searching for or reviewing of records--When the search
or review is performed by employees at grade GS-1 through GS-8, an
hourly rate based on the salary of a GS-5, step 7, employee; when done
by a GS-9 through GS-14, an hourly rate based on the salary of a GS-12,
step 4, employee; and when done by a GS-15 or above, an hourly rate
based on the salary of a GS-15, step 7, employee. In each case, the
hourly rate will be computed by taking the hourly rate for the
specified grade and step, adding 16% of that rate to cover benefits,
and rounding to the nearest whole dollar. As of November, 1998, these
rates were $14, $29, and $52, respectively. When a search involves
employees at more than one of these levels, we will charge the rate
appropriate for each, multiplied by the amount of time that person was
involved in the search.
(b) Computer searching and printing--If we need to use a computer
for any purpose involving searching for or copying records, or
providing them in a different form or format, we will charge the actual
cost of operating the computer, and charge for the time spent by the
operator and/or programmers at the rate given in paragraph (a) of this
section.
(c) Photocopying standard size pages--$0.10 per page. FOIA Officers
may charge less than $0.10 per page for particular documents where--
(1) The document has already been printed in large numbers;
(2) The program office determines that using existing stock to
answer this request, and other anticipated FOIA requests, will not
interfere with program requirements; and
(3) The FOIA Officer determines that the lower fee to be charged is
adequate to recover the prorated share of the original printing costs.
(d) Photocopying odd-size documents (such as blueprints), or
reproducing other records, (such as duplicating tapes or disks)--the
actual cost of operating the machine, plus the actual cost of materials
involved, plus charges for the time spent by the operator, at the rates
given in paragraph (a) of this section.
(e) Certifying that records are true copies. This service is not
required by the FOIA. If we agree to provide it, we will charge $10 per
certification.
(f) Sending records by express mail or other special methods. This
service is not required by the FOIA. If we agree to provide it, we will
only send the records by a method which allows the requester to
directly pay or be directly charged by the special method carrier.
(g) Performing any other special service that you request and we
agree to--Actual costs of operating any machinery, plus actual cost of
any materials involved, plus charges for the time of our employees, at
the rates given in paragraph (a) of this section.
Sec. 5.44 Procedures for assessing and collecting fees.
(a) Agreement to pay. We generally assume that when you request
records you are willing to pay the fees we charge for services
associated with your request. You may specify a limit on the amount you
are willing to spend. We will notify you if it appears that the fees
will exceed that limit, and we will ask you whether you nevertheless
want us to proceed with the processing of your request.
(b) Advance payment. If you have failed to pay previous bills in a
timely fashion, or if our initial review indicates that we will be
charging you fees exceeding $250, we will require you to pay your past
due fees, including penalties, and/or the estimated fees, or a deposit,
before we start searching for the records you want. If so, we will let
you know promptly upon receiving your request. In such cases, the
administrative time limits prescribed in Sec. 5.35 of this part (i.e.,
20 working days from receipt of initial requests and from receipt of
appeals of initial denials, plus permissible extensions of these time
limits) will begin only after we come to an agreement with you over
payment of
[[Page 14675]]
fees, or decide that a fee waiver or reduction is appropriate.
(c) Billing and payment. Except as indicated in paragraph (b) of
this section, we will begin processing your request upon receipt.
However, we will normally require you to pay all fees before we furnish
the records to you. We may, at our discretion, send you a bill along
with or following the furnishing of the records. For example, we may do
this if you have a history of prompt payment. We may also, at our
discretion, aggregate the charges for certain time periods to avoid
sending numerous small bills to frequent requesters, or to businesses
or agents representing requesters. For example, we might send a bill to
such a requester once a month. Fees should be paid in accordance with
the instructions provided by the person who responds to your request.
Sec. 5.45 Waiver or reduction of fees.
(a) Standard.(1) We will waive or reduce the fees we would
otherwise charge if disclosure of the information meets both the
following tests:
(i) It is in the public interest because it is likely to contribute
significantly to public understanding of the operations or activities
of the government, and
(ii) It is not primarily in the commercial interest of the
requester.
(2) These two tests are explained in paragraphs (b) and (c) of this
section. The burden of proof of meeting these tests rests with the
requester.
(b) Public interest. The disclosure passes the first test only if
it furthers the specific public interest of being likely to contribute
significantly to the public understanding of government operations or
activities, regardless of any other public interest it may further. In
analyzing this question, we will consider the following factors:
(1) How, if at all, do the records to be disclosed pertain to the
operations or activities of the Federal Government?
(2) Would disclosure of the records reveal any meaningful
information about government operations or activities? Can one learn
from these records anything that is not already public knowledge? Are
these or essentially equivalent records already available to the public
through some other source or mechanism?
(3) Will disclosure advance the understanding of the general public
as distinguished from a narrow segment of interested persons? This is a
critical factor under which we may consider whether the requester is in
a position to contribute to public understanding. For example, what is
the requester's expertise in the subject area of the request? Is the
requester's intended use of the information likely to disseminate the
information among the public at large? Does the requester have the
ability to affect such dissemination? An unsupported claim to be doing
research for a book or article does not demonstrate that likelihood,
while such a claim by a representative of the news media is better
evidence.
(4) Will the contribution to public understanding be a significant
one? Will the public's understanding of the government's operations be
substantially greater as a result of the disclosure?
(c) Not primarily in the requester's commercial interest. If the
disclosure passes the test of furthering the specific public interest
described in paragraph (b) of this section, we will determine whether
it also furthers the requester's commercial interest and, if so,
whether the commercial interest outweighs the advancement of that
specific public interest. In applying this second test, we will
consider the following factors:
(1) Would the disclosure further a commercial interest of the
requester or of someone on whose behalf the requester is acting?
``Commercial interests'' include interests relating to business, trade,
or profit. Not only profit-making corporations have commercial
interests--so do nonprofit corporations, individuals, unions, and other
associations. The interest of a representative of the news media in
using the information for news dissemination purposes will not be
considered a commercial interest.
(2) If disclosure would further the commercial interest of the
requester, would that effect outweigh the advancement of the public
defined in paragraph (b) of this section? Which effect is primary?
(d) Deciding between waiver and reduction. If the disclosure passes
both tests, we will normally waive fees. In some cases, however, we may
decide only to reduce the fees. For example, we may do this when some,
but not all of the requested records pass the tests.
(e) Procedure for requesting a waiver or reduction. You must make
your request for a waiver or reduction at the same time you make your
request for records. You should explain why you believe a waiver or
reduction is proper under the analysis in paragraphs (a) through (d) of
this section. Only FOIA Officers may make the decision whether to waive
or reduce fees. If we do not completely grant your request for a waiver
or reduction, the denial letter will designate a review official. You
may appeal the denial to that official. In your appeal letter, you
should discuss whatever reasons are given in our letter for denying
your request. The process prescribed in Sec. 5.34 of this part will
apply to these appeals.
Subpart E--Records Available for Public Inspection
Sec. 5.51 Records available.
Records of general interest. We will make available the following
records of general interest for your inspection and copying. Before
releasing them, however, we may delete the names of individuals or any
information that would identify these individuals if release would
invade their personal privacy to a clearly unwarranted degree (see
Sec. 5.67 of this part). Records of these sorts created on or after
November 1, 1996, will be made available through electronic means.
(a) Orders and final opinions, including concurring and dissenting
opinions in adjudications, such as Letters of Finding issued by the
Office of Civil Rights in civil rights complaints.
(b) Statements of policy and interpretations that we have adopted
but have not published in the Federal Register.
(c) Administrative staff manuals and instructions to staff that
affect the public (we will not make available, however, manuals or
instructions that reveal unique investigative or audit procedures).
(d) Records that we have already released in response to a FOIA
request, and that we believe are being or will be requested frequently
by other requesters.
Sec. 5.52 Indices of records.
(a) Inspection and copying. We will maintain and provide for your
inspection and copying current indices of the records described in
Sec. 5.51 (a) through (c). We will also publish and distribute copies
of the indices unless we announce in the Federal Register that it is
unnecessary or impractical to do so. For assistance in locating indices
maintained by the Department, you may contact the HHS FOIA Officer at
the address and phone number shown in Sec. 5.31.
(b) Major information and records locator systems. HHS participates
in the Government Information Locator Service (GILS) program which
makes this information available through a variety of media.
(c) Electronic listing. On or, in some cases, before December 31,
1999, a full listing of records made available under Sec. 5.51 of this
section will be available electronically.
(d) Record citation as precedent. We will not cite any record
described in
[[Page 14676]]
Sec. 5.51 (a) through (c) as a precedent for action against a person
unless we have published the record or have made it available
electronically or by other means, or unless the person has timely
notice of the record.
Subpart F--Predisclosure Notification for Certain Kinds of
Commercial/Financial Records
Sec. 5.61 General.
(a) Designation of commercial information as confidential. A person
who submits records to the government may designate part or all of the
information in such records as information that the person claims is
exempt from disclosure under exemption 4 of the FOIA. The person may
make this designation either at the time the records are submitted to
the government or within a reasonable time thereafter. The designation
must be in writing. Where a legend is required by a request for
proposals or request for quotations, pursuant to 48 CFR 352.215-12,
then that legend is necessary for this purpose. Any such designation
will expire ten years after the records were submitted to the
government.
(b) Predisclosure notification. The procedures in this paragraph
apply to records on which the submitter has designated information as
provided in paragraph (a) of this section. They also apply to records
that were submitted to the government where we have substantial reason
to believe that the information in the records could reasonably be
considered exempt under exemption 4 of the FOIA. Certain exceptions to
these procedures are stated in paragraph (c) of this section.
(1) When we receive a request for such records, and we determine
that we may be required to release them, we will make reasonable
efforts to notify the submitter about these facts. The notice will
include a copy of the request, and it will inform the submitter about
the procedures and time limits for submission and consideration of
objections to disclosure. If we must notify a large number of
submitters, we may do this by posting or publishing a notice in a place
where the submitters are reasonably likely to become aware of it, or by
sending the notice to a person or persons who we reasonably expect will
give appropriate notification to the submitters or who will act on
their behalf.
(2) The submitter will have five working days from receipt of the
notice to object to disclosure of any part of the records and to state
all bases for the objections. At the discretion of the FOIA Officer,
extensions of the time within which to respond may be granted, when
requested by the submitter. These extensions shall not exceed an
additional five working days.
(3) We will give consideration to all bases that have been timely
stated by the submitter. If we decide to disclose the records, we will
notify the submitter in writing. This notice will briefly explain why
we did not sustain his/her objections. We will include with the notice
a copy of the records about which the submitter objected, as we propose
to disclose them. The notice will state that we intend to disclose the
records five working days after the submitter receives the notice
unless we are ordered by a United States District Court not to release
them.
(4) When a requester files suit under the FOIA to obtain records
covered by this subsection, we will promptly notify the submitter.
(5) Whenever we send a notice to a submitter under paragraph (b)(1)
of this section, we will notify the requester that we are giving the
submitter a notice and an opportunity to object. Whenever we send a
notice to a submitter under paragraph (b)(3) of this section, we will
notify the requester of this fact.
(c) Exceptions to predisclosure notification. The notice
requirements in paragraph (b) of this section do not apply in the
following situations:
(1) We decide not to disclose the records;
(2) The information has previously been published or made generally
available;
(3) Disclosure is required by a regulation, issued after notice and
opportunity for public comment, that specifies certain narrow
categories of records that are to be disclosed upon request. However, a
submitter may still designate such records as described in paragraph
(a) of this section, and in exceptional cases, we may, at our
discretion, follow the notice procedures in paragraph (b) of this
section.
(4) The designation appears to be obviously frivolous. We will
still, however, give the submitter the written notice as described in
paragraph (b)(3) of this section (although this notice need not explain
our decision or include a copy of the records), and we will notify the
requester as described in paragraph (b)(5) of this section.
[FR Doc. 99-7222 Filed 3-25-99; 8:45 am]
BILLING CODE 4110-60-M
