Steven A. Levy, VMD State Police Surgeon- K9 Unit
860-
349-3485
Durham Veterinary Hospital, PC Fax 860-349-8649
178 Parmelee Hill Road email
drstevelevy@yahoo.com
Durham, CT 06422
October 17, 2006
Environmental Protection Agency
Amitraz has been used for many yeas as an acaracide in veterinary medicine.
Formadines inhibit monoamine oxidase and block neurotransmitter amines to
paralyze ticks resulting in decreased feeding and attachment. Control of acarine
ectoparasites of dogs is important both as a primary veterinary medical matter
and also as a potential limiting strategy for zoonotic impact on humans.
Ticks are the most common vectors of infectious disease for dogs in the United
States. In virtually all areas of the United States there are tick species that
transmit microorganism such as Borrelia burgdorferi, Anaplasma
phagocytophilum, Ehrlichia canis, Ehrlichia chaffeensis, Rickettsia rickettsii,
Babesia canis, and other emerging pathogens to dogs. Additionally, mites in the
genus Demodex and Sarcoptes often parasitize dogs and cause the clinical
syndrome known as mange.
Amitraz acts through a rapid neurotoxic effect on ticks and causes a phenomenon
known as clinical repellence. That is, dogs treated with Amitraz may be acquired
by host seeking ticks but contact with the treated skin and fur of these dogs
exposes the ticks to Amitraz thus preventing attachment and resulting in ticks
that are both unattached to the treated dog but also neurologically damaged and
therefore unable to attach to other hosts (including humans). The result is the
appearance of ticks having been repelled by the treated dog but the effect is more
significant because rather than leaving healthy ticks with the ability to acquire
another (human or animal) host in the environment the ticks have been exposed to
a lethal dose of Amitraz and will be unable to acquire new hosts.
Prevention of tick attachment and feeding are essential steps in prevention of tick-
transmitted diseases of dogs. Some tick-borne diseases may be transmitted very
rapidly (Rickettsia rickettsii in as little as 5 hours, Anaplasma phagocytophilum
within 24 hours and Borrelia burgdorferi in 24 to 52 hours) and effective prevention
of transmission must not just kill ticks but also prevent host acquisition and
feeding. The ability of Amitraz to prevent transmission of a tick-borne infection in
dogs has been demonstrated Elfassy, Goodman, Levy, et al. JAVMA, 2001;
219:185-189.).
Morbidity caused by parasitism with mange mites is a major clinical concern for
small animal veterinary practitioners. The availability of a pesticide with activity
against ticks and mange mites may eliminate the need for treating dogs with
multiple products when control or treatment of various combinations of parasites
is required. Demodectic mange often leads to severe secondary bacterial
infections and Sarcoptic mange in dogs may lead to the incidental parasitism of
humans leading to cutaneous lesions, pruritis and visits to health care providers.
Amitraz has been used safely in dogs. A mange dip (Mitaban?) and a tick
control collar (Preventic?) have been in the hands of veterinarians for more than a
decade. Offering Amitraz in a metered dosing/dispensing container for monthly
use will support safety. The availability of an effective antidote for toxicity
(yohimbine) should help ensure safe use. I have routinely used both products in
my practice since they were released for use.
Decreased transmission of tick-borne organisms, blood loss, secondary
cutaneous infections and self-trauma have been the benefits of using these
products. Further, clinical repellence typical of neurotoxic tick control agents like
Amitraz prevents ticks from being transported into human contact by untreated
dogs and then potentially leaving the canine and acquiring a human host. A
healthy, unattached tick on an untreated dog may be transferred to a human by
direct contact with the dog prior to the tick attaching to the dog. Activity against
mange mites has successfully treated infested dogs and decreased incidental,
temporary transmission of Sarcoptic mites to humans who may suffer pruritis from
bites.
Amitraz is a proven safe and effective antiparasite agent for use in canine practice.
Comment submitted by S. A. Levy
This is comment on Notice
Amitraz; Tolerance Reassessment Decision; Notice of Availability
View Comment
Related Comments
Public Submission Posted: 08/25/2006 ID: EPA-HQ-OPP-2004-0048-0045
Oct 23,2006 11:59 PM ET
Public Submission Posted: 10/18/2006 ID: EPA-HQ-OPP-2004-0048-0046
Oct 23,2006 11:59 PM ET
Public Submission Posted: 10/24/2006 ID: EPA-HQ-OPP-2004-0048-0047
Oct 23,2006 11:59 PM ET
Public Submission Posted: 10/24/2006 ID: EPA-HQ-OPP-2004-0048-0048
Oct 23,2006 11:59 PM ET