Utilities Comments on the Proposed Approval of Ohio's NOx Budget Trading Program

Title:
Utilities Comments on the Proposed Approval of Ohio's NOx Budget Trading Program

Abstract:
Re: Comments Opposing U.S. EPA's September 13, 2007 Proposed Approval and Promulgation of Air Quality Implementation Plans; Ohio; Oxides of Nitrogen Budget Trading Program This letter is on behalf of the Environmental Committee of the Ohio Electric Utility Institute and the following specified member companies: Buckeye Power, Inc., Columbus Southern Power Company (a unit of AEP), Dayton Power & Light Company, Duke Energy Ohio, ,Ohio Power Company (a unit of AEP), and Ohio Valley Electric Corporation

Title:
Utilities Comments on the Proposed Approval of Ohio's NOx Budget Trading Program (2)

Abstract:
Attachment A: ERAC Hearing Transcript

Title:
Utilities Comments on the Proposed Approval of Ohio's NOx Budget Trading Program (3)

Abstract:
Attachment B: Utilities ERAC Exhibit OUG-1, O.A.C. 3745-14-05 effective May 7,2005 Attachment C: O.A.C. 3745-14-05 effective April 24,2006 (or the "Emergency Rule") Attachment D: O.A.C. 3745-14-05 effective May 26,2006 (or the "Revised Rule")

Title:
Utilities Comments on the Proposed Approval of Ohio's NOx Budget Trading Program (4)

Abstract:
Attachment E: Utilities ERAC Exhibit OUG-2, O.A.C. 3745-14-05 effective July 7,2007 (or the "Final Rule) Attachment F: Utilities ERAC Exhibit OUG-3, Map: NOx Budget (2005) for Power Plants included in U.S. EPA's NOx Budget Program (Ozone Season Only) Attachment G: Utilities ERAC Exhibit OUG-4, Utilities March 27, 2006 Comments Regarding Potential Energy Rules for CincinnatilDayton Areas Attachment H: Utilities ERAC Exhibit OUG-5, Utilities June 2,2006 Comments Regarding Ohio EPA's Emergency Rules to Take Allowances From the New Source Set Aside Attachment I: Utilities ERAC Exhibit OUG-6, Map: Power Plants and NOx Budget in Ohio Attachment J: Utilities ERAC Exhibit OUG-7, Expert Report of Ken Weiss

Title:
Utilities Comments on the Proposed Approval of Ohio's NOx Budget Trading Program (5)

Abstract:
Attachment K: Utilities ERAC Exhibit OUG-8, Appendix to the Expert Report of Ken Weiss Attachment L: Utilities ERAC Exhibit OUG-9, Flowchart: Air Quality and SIP Planning Process; Map: Cincinnati and Dayton MSA Map: Power Plants and NOx Budget in Ohio Map: NOx Budget (2005) for Power Plants included in U.S. EPA's NOx Budget Program (Ozone Season Only) Chart: Allowances versus Reductions: Two Sources Chart: Allowances versus Reductions: Scenario A Chart: Allowances versus Reductions: Scenario B Attachment M: Utilities ERAC Exhibit OUG-10, September 27,2006 Letter from B. Frey to J. Petro Attachment N: Utilities ERAC Exhibit OUG-11, Ohio EPA Proposed O.A.C. 3745- 14-05 Responsiveness Summary Attachment 0 : 70 F.R. 17029, Approval and Promulgation of Implementation Plans for Kentucky

Title:
Utilities Comments on the Proposed Approval of Ohio's NOx Budget Trading Program (6)

Abstract:
Attachment P: 70 F.R. 581 19, Approval and Promulgation of Air Quality Implementation Plans; Texas Attachment Q: September 4, 1992, Memorandum from John Calcagni Attachment R: September 20,2005, Letter from Jay Bortzer to Bob Hodanbosi Attachment S: Utilities' January 12,2007, Informal Comments to US. EPA Opposing Approval of Ohio's request

Title:
Utilities Comments on the Proposed Approval of Ohio's NOx Budget Trading Program (7)

Abstract:
Attachment T: Utilities' February 15,2007, Informal Comments to US. EPA Opposing Approval of Ohio's request.

Title:
Utilities Comments on the Proposed Approval of Ohio's NOx Budget Trading Program (8)

Abstract:
Attachment U: Utilities' March 13, 2007, Informal Comments to US. EPA Opposing Approval of Ohio's request