I am submitting as an IA, A&P, former flight test DER for Taylorcraft in Alliance,
Oh. and the President of the Taylorcraft Foundation the Type Club for the
Taylorcraft under EAA. the Foundation has over 800 members. About six of them
have submitted to this comment period. As noted by most, this particular
Taylorcraft, the "Wiley" ship is not considered to be a Taylorcraft, this was an
Experimential aircraft and had parts from various Models installed. The attach
fititngs on this aircraft were TOTALLY unacceptable on an Airworthy aircraft, they
were improperly covered, improperly maintained and this was not an airworthy
aircraft.
Many owners, mechanics and restorers have expressed their opinion that this
is an action by the FAA that is not needed. I understand that the NTSB is very
concerned due to the double fatal accidnet and probably insisted on a "mandatory"
inspection that can only be assured by the issuance of an AD.
I do believe that in the interest of safety for our owners and passengers a one
time visual inspection is appropriate for this situation and hope that reports back
from the field will show that we have been doing the proper inspections at annual &
100 hr time.
I will be working with the Type Certicicate holder to insure that all owners
understand the serious nature of the proper inspection of this critical area. I can
report that to this date the strut fittings are passing the inspection. I do know of
one situtation where the tubing aft of the area in question was found to be
corroded, again this was an aircraft that had a corrosion problem in other areas
too! I recommend they consider another fuselage or a compete inspection of
theirs and a lot of tubing replacement. I was one of the people involved in the
drafting of this NPRM with the FAA engineer, Andy McAnaul along with the TC
holder at that time. I have inspected four aircraft to this date , all passed. I did
show two owners that they need to clean things a bit more on a regular basis.
Related Comments
Total: 5
Anonymous Public SubmissionPosted: 02/22/2008
ID: FAA-2008-0177-0003
James Zangger Public SubmissionPosted: 02/22/2008
ID: FAA-2008-0177-0004
Taylorcraft Foundation TF# 1
This is comment on Rule
Airworthiness Directives; Taylorcraft Models A, B, and F Series Airplanes
View Comment
Related Comments
Public Submission Posted: 02/22/2008 ID: FAA-2008-0177-0003
Public Submission Posted: 02/22/2008 ID: FAA-2008-0177-0004
Public Submission Posted: 03/21/2008 ID: FAA-2008-0177-0012
Public Submission Posted: 03/04/2008 ID: FAA-2008-0177-0008
Public Submission Posted: 02/25/2008 ID: FAA-2008-0177-0005