Comment submitted by T. Naquin

Document ID: FEMA-2004-0004-0007
Document Type: Public Submission
Agency: Federal Emergency Management Agency
Received Date: January 13 2006, at 04:23 PM Eastern Standard Time
Date Posted: January 30 2006, at 12:00 AM Eastern Standard Time
Comment Start Date: January 3 2006, at 04:03 PM Eastern Standard Time
Comment Due Date: March 6 2006, at 11:59 PM Eastern Standard Time
Tracking Number: 8011105c
View Document:  View as format xml

View Comment

-Is the presentation and format of the document useful and appropriate for its intended purpose? The presentation is useful because what is at stake needs to be elevated to response organizations conciousness. If an explosion occurs, it will likely be treated as a conventional explosion unless 'someone' announces that an RDD/IND will be or has been detonated. Current OSHA guidance for emergency responders raises no point of differentiation early on to confirm whether radioactive or nuclear material may be involved in an explosion, though responders have received training in regards to what are RDD/INDs. -Are the proposed PAGS for the early and intermediate phases implementable? If an explosion occurs, it will likely be treated as a conventional explosion unless 'someone' announces that an RDD/IND will be or has been detonated. As stated in the FR, there would be many lifesaving and first-aid actions occurring and that discovery or detection may not occur for days or weeks. I think this renders the early phase PAGS not practically implementable. While it is 'nice to be able to do' guidance, the information needed by decision makers for first responders or the general public would not be available until the early phase has passed. Interrmediate PAGS appear very implementable.

Related Comments

    View All
Total: 50
Comment submitted by Glen I. Reeves, MD, Medical Advisor on CBRN Effects, Northrop Grumman IT A&AS, Defense Threat Reduction Agency
Public Submission    Posted: 01/27/2006     ID: FEMA-2004-0004-0004

Mar 06,2006 11:59 PM ET
Comment submitted by Richard Ferrelli, Managing Director, Radiation Deconamination Solutions, LLC (RDS)
Public Submission    Posted: 01/27/2006     ID: FEMA-2004-0004-0005

Mar 06,2006 11:59 PM ET
Comment submitted by T. Naquin
Public Submission    Posted: 01/30/2006     ID: FEMA-2004-0004-0007

Mar 06,2006 11:59 PM ET
Comment submitted by Kirk Paradise, Plans Coordinator, Huntsville-Madison County Emergency Management Agency
Public Submission    Posted: 01/30/2006     ID: FEMA-2004-0004-0008

Mar 06,2006 11:59 PM ET
Comment submitted by Andrea Taylor, Environmental Specialist II, Environmental Programs, Cherokee Nation
Public Submission    Posted: 03/10/2006     ID: FEMA-2004-0004-0009

Mar 06,2006 11:59 PM ET