The Pascua Yaqui Tribe wishes to petition the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service to list
the Sonoran Desert bald eagle for protection under the Endangered Species Act.
In order to underscore the importance of the bald eagle to the Pascua Yaqui Tribe,
it will be necessary to reiterate our original comments and present additional
arguments.
The bald eagle factors prominently into Pascua Yaqui Tribal religious practices,
such as the Wiko Ya’aura Ceremonial Society and the Aztec Dancers, just to
name two of the Tribal ceremonies. If you have further questions regarding the bald
eagle as a factor in Pascua Yaqui Tribal culture, please call Amalia Reyes,
Pascua Yaqui Tribe, Education Resource Coordinator, at (520) 879-5742.
Arizona is experiencing one of the greatest human population increases in the
United States. The Verde and Salt River reservoir systems are experiencing
enormous pressure from recreation/fishing boaters and hikers, resulting in
negative impacts to the Sonoran Desert bald eagle through foraging and nesting
disturbances. As a result of the human population explosion, the Sonoran Desert
bald eagle will be subjected to increasing human disturbance on a daily basis, but
most importantly during nesting (human disturbances can range from people
merely getting too close to the nest, impairing the ability of the nesting pair to
incubate eggs, to humans either killing the nesting adults or removing nestlings
from the nest). The Bald and Golden Eagle Act does not provide the critical
nesting buffer zone protection afforded by the Endangered Species Act.
The protection afforded the Sonoran Desert bald eagle under the Endangered
Species Act goes beyond the actual prima facie wording of the Act. Laypersons
possess stronger recognition of the existence of Endangered Species Act and
superficial knowledge of the protection afforded species under that act, than they
would of the Bald and Golden Eagle Act. Fear of the heavier sanctions imposed
under the Endangered Species Act would also be a greater deterrent to take by
humans.
Water is one of the key limiting factors to human population growth in Arizona as
well as to the Sonoran Desert bald eagle habitat. Increased human demand upon
aquifers and streams has had enormous detrimental effects to the Arizona natural
habitat, killing huge tracts of trees in, what were previously, riparian areas. The
survival of the Sonoran Desert bald eagle is inextricably attached to areas of open
water for foraging purposes. Reduction in the volume of water in the Verde and
Salt River water systems will negatively impact the Sonoran Desert bald eagle
population. The negative impact will be realized through the concentration of
fishing and recreation activities for both human and the Sonoran Desert bald
eagle, bringing the two species in closer proximity. This is another area where the
nesting buffer zone protection proffered by the Endangered Species Act will be
required, functioning as an exclosure for human fishing/recreation activity.
It is recommend that instead of using political features as specie range
boundaries in the federally listed species range map (which cuts off the federally
listed area in La Paz and Yuma Counties at U.S. Highway 95) that the federally
listed area be established by ecological factors and extended west to the
Colorado River. National Wildlife Refuge personnel stationed along the Colorado
River have annual documentation of bald eagle foraging and nesting activity along
the river. If you have further species specific questions please direct your inquiries
to William Campbell, Pascua Yaqui Tribe, Environmental Specialist, at (520) 879-
6365.
Comment on FR Doc # E8-18779
This is comment on Proposed Rule
Eagle Permits; Take Necessary To Protect Interests in a Particular Locality
View Comment
Attachments:
Comment on FR Doc # E8-18779
Title:
Comment on FR Doc # E8-18779
Related Comments
View AllPublic Submission Posted: 08/19/2008 ID: FWS-R9-MB-2008-0057-0005
Sep 15,2008 11:59 PM ET
Public Submission Posted: 08/19/2008 ID: FWS-R9-MB-2008-0057-0006
Sep 15,2008 11:59 PM ET
Public Submission Posted: 08/19/2008 ID: FWS-R9-MB-2008-0057-0007
Sep 15,2008 11:59 PM ET
Public Submission Posted: 08/21/2008 ID: FWS-R9-MB-2008-0057-0008
Sep 15,2008 11:59 PM ET
Public Submission Posted: 09/02/2008 ID: FWS-R9-MB-2008-0057-0009
Sep 15,2008 11:59 PM ET