Comment on FR Doc # N/A

Document ID: IRS-2008-0109-0006
Document Type: Public Submission
Agency: Internal Revenue Service
Received Date: February 23 2009, at 02:40 PM Eastern Standard Time
Date Posted: February 24 2009, at 12:00 AM Eastern Standard Time
Comment Start Date: December 8 2008, at 12:00 AM Eastern Standard Time
Comment Due Date: March 9 2009, at 11:59 PM Eastern Standard Time
Tracking Number: 808bc494
View Document:  View as format xml

View Comment

Dear Sir or Madam, In follow up on my comments regarding the treatment of discounted stock options as non-qualified deferred compensation under section 409A rules, I would recommend a more fair approach to the claculations of taxes and penalties: Only the amount of the actual discount should be treated as non-qualified deferred compensation subject to section 409A rules, the remainder of the profit from exercising discounted option should be treated as normal income. It would make sense that the taxes and penalties should only be paid upon exercise of the discounted options. Example: 1200 options with a disounted price of $17.37 (vs the market price at the date of the grant of $18) Upon exercising these options and selling the stock at $20: I would declare 1200x$0.63= $756 as non-qualified deferred compensation and pay the resulting taxes and penalties, but the remainder 1200x$2 = $2400 would be taxed as standard income, as if these options were granted at the correct price of $18. This seems a pretty fair solution to me, which would penalize erroneously backdated stock options without requiring recipients to pay taxes on never received income or pay more in penalties than the actual discount received. Thank you for your consideration of this proposal, J.L. de Jong

Related Comments

    View All
Total: 9
Further Guidance on the Application of Section 409A to Nonqualified Deferred
Public Submission    Posted: 02/06/2009     ID: IRS-2008-0109-0002

Mar 09,2009 11:59 PM ET
Further Guidance on the Application of Section 409A to Nonqualified Deferred
Public Submission    Posted: 02/18/2009     ID: IRS-2008-0109-0003

Mar 09,2009 11:59 PM ET
Comment on FR Doc # E8-28894
Public Submission    Posted: 02/23/2009     ID: IRS-2008-0109-0005

Mar 09,2009 11:59 PM ET
Comment on FR Doc # N/A
Public Submission    Posted: 02/24/2009     ID: IRS-2008-0109-0006

Mar 09,2009 11:59 PM ET
Comment on FR Doc # E8-28894
Public Submission    Posted: 03/10/2009     ID: IRS-2008-0109-0007

Mar 09,2009 11:59 PM ET