Comment from Frank Marshall, Private Citizen

I have read the Federal Register information. Based on the information presented, I am opposed to the approval of the sonar-type activities that are described in the Atlantic Ocean along the east coast of Florida. The information indicates that science has not yet advanced in the simulation of negative effects to cetaceans and describes an adaptive management approach to be used to mitigate the takings negative effects and takings. However, an adaptive management approach is not recommended for any mammals by most knowledgeable marine biologists (at least no scientist of whichI am aware). Using adaptive management as a mitigative measure for the negative effects of these training activities on cetaceans is kin to allowing human subjects to be exposed to chemical warfare but with a plan to cease the chemical warfare if humans mortality occurs or other negative effects are noticed. This method has been used in past during wartime activities and US citizens have been been almost unanimously opposed to this practice such that it has been banned. To not truly understand the detrimental effect on cetaceans such that an adaptive management strategy is required means that these activities should not be allowed at all until the full science for effects on cetacean has advanced to the point that the true effect is known. I am opposed in total to the approval of these regulations.