Title:
Comment Sierra Club

Title:
Exhibit 1: Respondent's Opposition to North Dakota Motion

Abstract:
Case: 10-1252 Document 1276211 U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia. Oral Argument not yet scheduled for National Environmental Development Association's Clean Air Project v. USEPA. Respondent Opposition to Motion of the State of North Dakota for a Stay of EPA's 1 Hour Sulfur Dioxide Ambient Standard Rule.

Title:
Exhibit 10: Sulfur Dioxide Implementation

Abstract:
Sulfur Dioxide Implementation - Programs and Requirements for Reducing Sulfur Dioxide

Title:
Exhibit 11: Preliminary 1-Hour SO2 Modeling ...

Abstract:
Preliminary 1-Hour SO2 Modeling of Some Coal-Fired EGUs in Oklahoma. DRAFT- Preliminary modeling results. Prepared by Ashley Mohr, Erik Snyder and Michael Feldman, USEPA Region 6 Air Modeling Team.

Title:
Exhibit 12: MassDEP letter 2.21.2013

Abstract:
2/21/2013 letter from David Howland, Regional Engineer, Western Regional Office, Executive Office of Energy & Environmental Affairs, Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection (MassDEP) to Howard Person, Plant Manager, Mt. Tom Generating Company, LLC; regarding 310 CMR 7.02(7) Mitigation of Air Pollution, Sulfur Dioxide Emission Ambient Air Impacts of Mt. Tom Station.

Title:
Exhibit 13: Pennsylvania DEP Air Quality Program Plan Approval

Abstract:
Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) Air Quality Program Plan Approval Report (number 32-00055H) for EME Homer City Gen LP/Center TWP, Operator EME Homer City Generation LP issued 4/2/2012. DEP Auth ID: 897196

Title:
Exhibit 14: USEPA Letter 4.25.2012

Abstract:
4/25/2012 letter from Genevieve Damico, Chief, Air Permits Section, Region Five, USEPA; to Michael W. Ahern, Manager, Permit Issuance and Data Management Section, Division of Air Pollution Control, Ohio Environmental Protection Agency regarding clarifications concerning federal enforceability of Ohio Administrative Code (OAC) rule 3745-15-07.

Title:
Exhibit 15: High Level Summary of Meeting 5.31.2012

Abstract:
High Level Summary of Meeting with States/Locals/Tribes 5/31/2012 (Not Final Agency Action).

Title:
Exhibit 16: High Level Summary of Meeting 6.1.2012

Abstract:
High Level Summary of Meeting with Industry 6/1/2012 (Not Final Agency Action)

Title:
Exhibit 17: USEPA NOV Letter 4.20.2011

Abstract:
4/20/2011 letter from Cheryl L. Newton, Director, Air and Radiation Division, Region 5, USEPA; to Howard Chapman Jr., President, H. Kramer & Co. as a Notice of Violation (NOV) [EPA-5-11-IL-ll] to H. Kramer & Co.

Title:
Exhibit 18: Barry AL

Abstract:
Barry Steam Electric Generating Plant Bucks, Alabama, Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS, June 22, 2012

Title:
Exhibit 19: Colbert AL

Abstract:
Colbert Fossil Plant, Tuscumbia, Alabama, Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS 6//22/2012

Title:
Exhibit 2: Brief of Respondent USEPA et al.

Abstract:
Case: 10-1252 Document 1341707 U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia. Oral Argument not yet scheduled for National Environmental Development Association's Clean Air Project et al. v. USEPA. Brief for Respondent et al. 11/14/2011

Title:
Exhibit 20: Gorgas AL

Abstract:
Gorgas Steam Electric Generating Plant Parrish, Alabama Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS 6/22/2012

Title:
Exhibit 21: Greene County AL

Abstract:
Greene County Steam Electric Generating Plant Forkland, Alabama Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS 6/22/2012

Title:
Exhibit 22: Independence AR

Abstract:
AERMOD Modeling of SO2 Impacts of the Entergy Independence Coal Plant Final Report 9.20.2011 prepared for Andrea Issod, Sierra Club San Francisco, California.

Title:
Exhibit 23: White Bluff AR

Abstract:
AERMOD Modeling of SO2 Impacts of the Entergy White Bluff Coal Plant Final Report 9/28/2011 prepared for Andrea Issod, Sierra Club San Francisco, California.

Title:
Exhibit 24: Sundt AZ

Abstract:
H. Wilson Sundt Generating Station Tucson, Arizona Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS 9/27/2012

Title:
Exhibit 25: Cholla AZ

Abstract:
Cholla Generating Station Joseph City, Arizona Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS 9/18/2012

Title:
Exhibit 26: Navajo AZ

Abstract:
Navajo Generating Station Page, Arizona Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS 9/20/2012

Title:
Exhibit 27: Martin Drake CO

Abstract:
Figure 1 (page 22)- Regional View Martin Drake Power Plant, Colorado Springs, Colorado Evaluation of Compliance with the 1-hour NAAQS for SO2; and Figure 2 (Local View) Martin Drake Power Plant, Colorado Springs, Colorado Evaluation of Compliance with the 1-hour NAAQS for SO2

Title:
Exhibit 28: Crystal River FL

Abstract:
Crystal River Power Plant Crystal River, Florida Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS 6/25/2012

Title:
Exhibit 29: Lansing FL

Abstract:
Lansing Smith Electric Generating Plant Lynn Haven, Florida Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS 6/26/2012

Title:
Exhibit 3: USEPA Memorandum 4.21.1983

Abstract:
4/21/1983 Memorandum (PN 107-83-04-21-C) from Sheldon Meyers, Director, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards (OAQPS), Office of Air, Noise and Radiation, USEPA; to Director, air and Waste Management Division Regions II-IV, VI-VIII, I; and Director, Air Management Regions I, V, II; regarding the Section 107 Designation Policy Summary

Title:
Exhibit 30: Branch Plant GA

Abstract:
Branch Steam Electric Generating Plant Milledgeville, Georgia. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS 8/21/2012

Title:
Exhibit 31: Wansley GA

Abstract:
Wansley Steam Electric Generating Plant Roopville, Georgia. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS 8/21/2012

Title:
Exhibit 32: Yates GA

Abstract:
Yates Steam Electric Generating Plant Newnan, Georgia. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS 8/21/2012

Title:
Exhibit 33: MWG Facilities in Illinois Air Dispersion Modeling Analysis

Abstract:
Air Dispersion Modeling Analysis For Verifying Compliance with the One-Hour SO2 NAAQS: Midwest Generation Facilities in Illinois 10/11/2011.

Title:
Exhibit 34: Evaluation of Compliance for Big Sandy Plant et al.

Abstract:
Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS for Big Sandy Plant - Louisa, Kentucky; Cane Run Generating Station,- Louisville, Kentucky; Cooper Power Station, Somerset, Kentucky; Dale Power Station, Ford, Kentucky; Green River Generating Station, Central City, Kentucky; H.L. Spurlock Generating Station, Maysville, Kentucky; Mill Creek Generating Station, Louisville, Kentucky; Robert Reid Power Station, Robards, Kentucky; and Tyrone Generating Station, Versailles, Kentucky 2/10/2012

Title:
Exhibit 35: Shawnee KY

Abstract:
Shawnee Fossil Plant Paducah, Kentucky Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS 9/12/2013

Title:
Exhibit 36: Big Cajun LA

Abstract:
Big Cajun II Generating Station New Roads, Louisiana. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS, 9/10/2012

Title:
Exhibit 37: Brayton Point MA

Abstract:
Dominion Energy Brayton Point Station Somerset, Massachusetts. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS, 8/31/2012

Title:
Exhibit 38: Mount Tom Station MA

Abstract:
Mount Tom Station Holyoke, Massachusetts. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS, 8/19/2011

Title:
Exhibit 39: Wagner Crane MD

Abstract:
Modeling the Short-term SO2 Impacts Due to Wagner and Crane Power Plant Emissions, September 2011

Title:
Exhibit 4: Declaration of John C. Vimont

Abstract:
Superior Court of the State of California, County of Santa Barbara Number SM 64010, People of the State of California, Attorney General et al. v. Santa Maria Chili Inc. Transcript copy of the Declaration of John C. Vimont dated 11/30/1990 filed 12/3/1990.

Title:
Exhibit 40: R. Paul Smith MD

Abstract:
R. Paul Smith Power Station Williamsport, Maryland. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS, 1/11/2012

Title:
Exhibit 41: Monroe MI

Abstract:
AERMOD Modeling of 1-Hour NO2 and SO2 Impacts of the Modified Monroe Power Plant

Title:
Exhibit 42: Boswell MN

Abstract:
AERMOD Modeling of SO2 Impacts of the Minnesota Power Boswell Coal Plant

Title:
Exhibit 43: Hoot Lake MN

Abstract:
AERMOD Modeling of SO2 Impacts of the Otter Tail Hoot Lake Coal Plant

Title:
Exhibit 44: Sherco MN

Abstract:
AERMOD Modeling of SO2 Impacts of the Xcel Energy Sherbune County Coal Plant

Title:
Exhibit 45: Blue Valley, Columbia Municipal, Montrose, Southwest U of MO, MO

Abstract:
Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS for Blue Valley Station - Independence, Missouri; Columbia Municipal Power Plant - Columbia, Missouri; Montrose Generating Station - Clinton, Missouri; Southwest Power Station - Springfield, Missouri; University of Missouri - Columbia Power Plant - Columbia, Missouri

Title:
Exhibit 46: Meramec, Labadie, Rush Island, MO

Abstract:
Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS for AmerenUE Meramec Plant – St. Louis, Missouri; Ameren Labadie Plant – Labadie, Missouri; AmerenUE Rush Island Plant – Festus, Missouri

Title:
Exhibit 47: Daniel MS

Abstract:
AERMOD Modeling of SO2 Impacts of the Daniel Coal Plant

Title:
Exhibit 48: Corette MT

Abstract:
J.E. Corette Steam Electric Station Billings, Montana. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS

Title:
Exhibit 49: Asheville NC

Abstract:
Asheville Steam Electric Plant, Arden, North Carolina. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS

Title:
Exhibit 5: Declaration of Roger W. Brode

Abstract:
Case: 10-1252 Document 1288492 U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia. Oral Argument not yet scheduled for National Environmental Development Association's Clean Air Project v. USEPA. Declaration of Roger W. Brode dated 1/18/2011

Title:
Exhibit 50: Gerald, North Omaha, Sheldon, NE

Abstract:
Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS for Gerald Gentleman Station - Sutherland, Nebraska; Sheldon Station - Hallam, Nebraska; North Omaha Station - Omaha, Nebraska

Title:
Exhibit 51: Merrimack Station NH

Abstract:
Merrimack Station Bow, New Hampshire. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS

Title:
Exhibit 52: Schiller NH

Abstract:
Schiller Station Portsmouth, New Hampshire. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. September 12, 2011

Title:
Exhibit 53: North Valmy NV

Abstract:
North Valmy Generating Station Valmy, Nevada. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. August 21, 2012

Title:
Exhibit 54: Danskammer NY

Abstract:
AERMOD Modeling of SO2 Impacts of the Dynergy Danskammer Plant

Title:
Exhibit 55: Dunkirk NY

Abstract:
Dunkirk Steam Generating Station Dunkirk, New York. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. May 22, 2012

Title:
Exhibit 56: Huntley NY

Abstract:
Huntley Steam Generating Station Tonawanda, New York. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. May 22, 2012

Title:
Exhibit 57: Muskogee Northeastern Sooner OK

Abstract:
Letter from Andrea Issod, Gloria Smith, Sierra Club Environmental Law Program to Joe Kordzi, USEPA; Re: EPA Docket EPA-R06-OAR-2010-0190. May 23, 2011

Title:
Exhibit 58: Armstrong Station PA

Abstract:
Armstrong Power Station, Templeton, Pennsylvania. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS, June 8, 2012

Title:
Exhibit 59: Bruce Manfield PA

Abstract:
Bruce Mansfield Plant Shippingport, Pennsylvania. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS July 12, 2012

Title:
Exhibit 6: Integrated Science Assessment ...

Abstract:
Integrated Science Assessment for Sulfur Oxides-Health Criteria September 2008 [ISA: EPA/600/R-08/047F] Annexes: [EPA/600/R-08/047FA] Contains ERRATA Sheet created on 3/4/2009. Prepared by National Center for Environmental Assessment - RTP, Office of Research and Development (ORD), USEPA

Title:
Exhibit 60: Elrama Power Plant PA

Abstract:
Elrama Power Plant Elrama, Pennsylvania. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. October 12, 2011

Title:
Exhibit 61: Hatfield's Ferry PA

Abstract:
Hatfield's Ferry Power Station Masontown, Pennsylvania. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. July 13, 2012

Title:
Exhibit 62: Homer City PA

Abstract:
Exhibit 4. Air Dispersion Modeling Analysis for Verifying Compliance with the One-Hour SO2 NAAQS: EME – Homer City Generation. January 27, 2012

Title:
Exhibit 63: Mitchell PA

Abstract:
Mitchell Power Station Monongahela, Pennsylvania. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. June 8, 2012

Title:
Exhibit 64: New Castle PA

Abstract:
New Castle Power Plant West Pittsburg, Pennsylvania. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. October 21, 2011

Title:
Exhibit 65: Shawville PA

Abstract:
AERMOD Modeling of SO2 Impacts of the GenOn Shawville Coal Plant. September 14, 2011

Title:
Exhibit 66: Sunbury Generation PA

Abstract:
Sunbury Generation Facility Shamokin Dam, Pennsylvania. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. November 9, 2011

Title:
Exhibit 67: Titus PA

Abstract:
AERMOD Modeling of SO2 Impacts of the GenOn Titus Coal Plant. October 21, 2011

Title:
Exhibit 68: Gallatin TN

Abstract:
Gallatin Fossil Plant Gallatin, Tennessee. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. March 9, 2012

Title:
Exhibit 69: Big Brown TX

Abstract:
AERMOD Modeling of SO2 Impacts of the Luminant Big Brown Coal Plant. June 2011

Title:
Exhibit 7: Federal Register

Abstract:
Federal Register of June 22, 2010 (75 FR 35520). Primary National Ambient Air Quality Standard for Sulfur Dioxide; Final Rule. 40 CFR Parts 50, 53, and 58 [EPA–HQ–OAR–2007–0352; 9160–4] RIN 2060–A048

Title:
Exhibit 70: Martin Lake TX

Abstract:
AERMOD Modeling of SO2 Impacts of the Luminant Martin Lake Coal Plant. June 2011

Title:
Exhibit 71: Monticello TX

Abstract:
AERMOD Modeling of SO2 Impacts of the Luminant Monticello Coal Plant. June 2011

Title:
Exhibit 72: Chesapeake Energy Center VA

Abstract:
Chesapeake Energy Center, Chesapeake, Virginia. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. August 26, 2011

Title:
Exhibit 73: Clinch River VA

Abstract:
Clinch River Plant Carbo, Virginia. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. October 24, 2011

Title:
Exhibit 74: Glen Lyn VA

Abstract:
Glen Lyn Plant, Glen Lyn, Virginia. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. October 21, 2011

Title:
Exhibit 75: Yorktown Power Station VA

Abstract:
Yorktown Power Station Yorktown, Virginia. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. August 31, 2011

Title:
Exhibit 76: Alma JM Madget Columbia Edgewater Genoa Manitowoc Nelson Dewey Pleasant Prairie Pullium Valley Weston WI

Abstract:
Letter from Shahla M. Werner, Ph.D. and John Muir, Chapter Director, Sierra Club to Mike Friedlander, Wisconsin DNR, GEF II regarding 1-Hour SO2 Designations

Title:
Exhibit 77: Albright Power Station WV

Abstract:
Albright Power Station, Albright, West Virginia Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. September 19, 2011

Title:
Exhibit 78: Kammer WV

Abstract:
AERMOD Modeling of SO2 Impacts of the AEP Ohio Power Kammer Plant. November 16, 2011

Title:
Exhibit 79: Kanawha River Plant WV

Abstract:
Kanawha River Plant, Glasgow, West Virginia Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. October 25, 2011

Title:
Exhibit 8: Final Regulatory Impact Analysis (RIA)...

Abstract:
Final Regulatory Impact Analysis (RIA) for the SO2 National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) June 2010. Prepared by Air Benefit-Cost Group, Health and Environmental Impact Division, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards (OAQPS), USEPA

Title:
Exhibit 80: Dave Johnston WY

Abstract:
PacifiCorp Energy Dave Johnston Plant Converse County, Wyoming. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. September 12, 2012

Title:
Exhibit 81: Jim Bridger WY

Abstract:
PacifiCorp Energy Jim Bridger Plant, Sweetwater County, Wyoming. Sierra Club Evaluation of Compliance with 1-hour SO2 NAAQS. September 12, 2012

Title:
Exhibit 9: USEPA Memorandum 3.24.2011

Abstract:
3/24/2011 Memorandum from Stephen D. Page, Director, Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards (OAQPS), USEPA to Regional Air Division Directors, Region I-X regarding Area Designations for the 2010 Revised Primary Sulfur Dioxide National Ambient Air Quality Standards.

Title:
Exhibits 50a-81a

Abstract:
Some of the files submitted by Sierra club are not supported by FDMS, they can be made available upon request to the Docket Center.

Title:
Exhibits:18a-49a

Abstract:
Some of the files submitted by Sierra club are not supported by FDMS, they can be made available upon request to the Docket Center.

Title:
Figure 1 Plots of Modeled Nonattainment (Part 2)

Abstract:
Continuation of Figure Plots of Modeled Nonattainment pages 94 - 186. The document is restricted due to page 138 thru 140 (Screen view pages 45-47) has Microsoft Corporation (2010) copyrighted map data. The document can be viewed at the USEPA Docket Center, Public Reading Room. Address: USEPA West, 1301 Constitution Ave. NW, Room 3334, Washington, DC 20004. Telephone: 202-566-1744; Email: docket-customerservice@epa.gov

Title:
Figure 1 Plots of Modeled Nonattainment (Part 2) clean version

Abstract:
Continuation of Figure Plots of Modeled Nonattainment pages 94 - 186 (clean version).

Title:
Figure 1 Plots of Modeled Nonattainment Areas (Part 1)

Abstract:
Plots of Modeled Nonattainment pages 1 - 93. Pages 35, 38, 39, 50, 53, 54-60, 64 and 67 were removed due to copyright map data. The document can be viewed at the USEPA Docket Center, Public Reading Room. Address: USEPA West, 1301 Constitution Ave. NW, Room 3334, Washington, DC 20004. Telephone: 202-566-1744; Email: docket-customerservice@epa.gov

Title:
Figure 1 Plots of Modeled Nonattainment Areas (Part 1) clean version

Abstract:
Figure 1 Plots of Modeled Nonattainment Areas (Part 1) pages 1-93 clean version