Specific comments about UST Form 102-13-FR-S (Chapter 13 Standing Trustee?s
Final Report and Account):
Paragraph 8: ?total value of assets abandoned by court order? - in many
jurisdictions (including mine), we don?t ?abandon? assets; we merely consent to
the stay being lifted. If a creditor wants to obtain an abandonment order, I usually
have no involvement in that, once the stay is lifted. Therefore, the total value of
abandoned assets in my cases will always be $0. This will skew the national
numbers. On the other hand, if ?abandoned? is supposed to be synonymous
with ?stay lifted,? then we need to know that.
Paragraph 9: ?total value of assets exempted? - it would be simple enough to add
up the totals from Schedule C; however, many debtors claim the value of their
exemption as ?100%? in certain assets without stating a value. If that is added in
as $0, that will also skew the total numbers nationally. There are several
categories of property in which it is entirely appropriate for a debtor to claim 100%
as exempt, regardless of the actual value, even if the value is known at the time of
filing (though in the case of certain pending lawsuits, the value is often NOT
known).
Paragraph 10: ?amount of general unsecured claims discharged without payment? -
if this refers to the amount of claims FILED that were not paid, it may not be an
accurate reflection, since many creditors do not file claims in low dividend plans;
on the other hand, if it refers to the amount of claims SCHEDULED that were not
paid, it may not be accurate either, since debtors are notoriously unfamiliar with
the amounts they owe. I am unsure what this question is seeking, so I can?t
propose an alternative wording.
Under the section headed ?summary of disbursements to creditors,? there is a
breakdown of ?debt secured by vehicle? and ?other secured.? There are numerous
cases in which the secured debt has a vehicle AND OTHER COLLATERAL also
securing the loan, with no specific breakdown of how much is secured by the
vehicle and how much is secured by the other property. This inability to break out
the totals will either cause the ?secured vehicle debt? to be inaccurately high
(because it includes other personal property), or it will cause the ?other secured?
debt to be inaccurately high (because it includes debts also secured by vehicles).
Comment on FR Doc # E8-01450
This is comment on Proposed Rule
Procedures for Completing Uniform Forms of Trustee Final Reports in Cases Filed Under Chapters 7, 12, and 13 of Title 11
View Comment
Related Comments
View AllPublic Submission Posted: 02/22/2008 ID: DOJ-EOUST-2008-0003-0002
Apr 04,2008 11:59 PM ET
Public Submission Posted: 02/22/2008 ID: DOJ-EOUST-2008-0003-0003
Apr 04,2008 11:59 PM ET
Public Submission Posted: 02/22/2008 ID: DOJ-EOUST-2008-0003-0004
Apr 04,2008 11:59 PM ET
Public Submission Posted: 02/29/2008 ID: DOJ-EOUST-2008-0003-0005
Apr 04,2008 11:59 PM ET
Public Submission Posted: 03/14/2008 ID: DOJ-EOUST-2008-0003-0008
Apr 04,2008 11:59 PM ET