Comment on FR Doc # E7-14489

Document ID: IRS-2007-0098-0006
Document Type: Public Submission
Agency: Internal Revenue Service
Received Date: September 28 2007, at 02:08 PM Eastern Daylight Time
Date Posted: November 8 2007, at 12:00 AM Eastern Standard Time
Comment Start Date: September 21 2007, at 12:00 AM Eastern Standard Time
Comment Due Date: October 25 2007, at 11:59 PM Eastern Standard Time
Tracking Number: 802ac2b4
View Document:  View as format xml

This is comment on Proposed Rule

Section 67 Limitations on Estates or Trusts

View Comment

Re: Proposed Regulations under Section 67 (2 percent floor) The proposed regulations provide that administrative costs "unique" to estates and trusts are not subject to the 2 percent floor. It is obvious that the regulations were written with Subchapter J estates and trusts in mind, given the references to "beneficiaries" of the estate or trust, contests of wills and trusts, and the court cases cited in the preamble. The Office of Chief Counsel has published AM 2007-0010, which concludes than an individual's bankruptcy estate under Subchapter V (section 1398) is an "estate or trust." I recommend that AM 2007-0010 be revoked because the phrase "estate or trust" is necessarily limited to Subchapter J estates and trusts, as explained in my September 3 article in Tax Notes, Is an Individual's Bankruptcy Estate an "Estate or Trust"? See 116 Tax Notes 843-856. If the Office of Chief Counsel continues to maintain the position that "estate or trust" includes bankruptcy estates of individuals, it will then be necessary for the Office to determine which deductible administrative expenses (those described in section 1398(h)(1)) meet the "unique" test set forth in the proposed section 67 regulations. For example, are the costs incurred by the chapter 7 trustee in having the bankruptcy estate's income tax return prepared "unique" to the estate and thus deductible in full? Are the court costs incurred in filing the bankruptcy petition under chapter 7 or 11 "unique" to the estate? Are the costs of maintaining estate property and paying property taxes "unique" to the estate? All of these issues are discussed in my article. The answers are not easy but answers are required if the Office of Chief Counsel continues to maintain the position that a section 1398 bankruptcy estate is an "estate or trust" within the meaning of section 67(e)(1).

Related Comments

    View All
Total: 23
Comment on FR Doc # E7-14489
Public Submission    Posted: 11/08/2007     ID: IRS-2007-0098-0006

Oct 25,2007 11:59 PM ET
Comment on FR Doc # E7-14489
Public Submission    Posted: 11/08/2007     ID: IRS-2007-0098-0007

Oct 25,2007 11:59 PM ET
Comment on FR Doc # E7-14489
Public Submission    Posted: 11/08/2007     ID: IRS-2007-0098-0008

Oct 25,2007 11:59 PM ET
Comment on FR Doc # E7-14489
Public Submission    Posted: 11/08/2007     ID: IRS-2007-0098-0009

Oct 25,2007 11:59 PM ET
Comment on FR Doc # E7-14489
Public Submission    Posted: 11/08/2007     ID: IRS-2007-0098-0010

Oct 25,2007 11:59 PM ET